A mild hybrid powertrain can do more than supplement an engine or recover braking energy. In a manual-transmission vehicle, an electric motor can also help maintain drive torque while the clutch is disengaged for a gear change. This approach targets two linked drivability problems: the temporary loss of wheel torque known as a torque hole, and the torsional vibration that can be felt as longitudinal jerk when the clutch re-engages.
A prototype developed around a post-transmission, or P3, hybrid layout explored how motor placement and coordinated control could address these effects while retaining a single dry-plate clutch and conventional manual transmission. Its findings offer useful engineering lessons about system architecture, control design and validation.
Why manual gear changes create a torque hole
In a conventional manual powertrain, shifting requires the driver to disengage the clutch. This interrupts the engine’s connection to the driven wheels, so transmitted torque falls during the shift. When the clutch reconnects the engine and transmission, differences in rotational speed and the changing clutch force can produce a transient disturbance through the driveline.
Reducing the interruption is not simply a matter of commanding more motor torque. The control system must estimate the torque needed at the wheels, coordinate electric assistance with clutch operation, and manage the transition back to engine-driven torque. Poorly timed assistance or re-engagement can leave a torque discontinuity or contribute to vibration.
How a P3 mild hybrid powertrain supports continuous torque
In the studied P3 arrangement, the electric motor is positioned in line with the transmission output shaft, before the differential. Because it is downstream of the clutch, the motor can continue driving the wheels while the clutch separates the engine from the transmission during a shift. It can also provide torque during vehicle take-off.
This placement makes the motor useful for more than one operating function. A single motor can support shift torque fill, provide drive-torque assistance and contribute to regenerative braking, without using a dual-motor configuration. The trade-off is that control must account for the relationship between road speed and motor speed, as well as the state of the clutch and transmission.
The prototype’s control strategy used a pressure-based clutch model to estimate clutch behaviour and modulate electric torque during shifts. Engine speed was controlled in proportion to road speed to reduce rotational-speed mismatch as the clutch re-engaged. The system was designed as driver assistance, with automatic clutch and gear actuation identified as possible extensions rather than prerequisites for the demonstrated approach.
Coordinating torque fill with energy management
Shift control is one part of a broader hybrid energy management strategy. A rule-based controller in the system also supported drive-torque supplementation, battery recharging, regenerative braking and electric-vehicle crawl. These functions make the motor and battery serve several purposes across vehicle operation.
For engineers, this creates an integration challenge: torque availability for a shift must be considered alongside battery and motor operating limits and the other functions that may request electric power. Component sizing and architecture selection therefore need to reflect the intended use cases, not just peak assistance demand. In this project, the P3 layout was selected with the aim of limiting modification cost and complexity relative to a conventional vehicle while making effective use of one motor.
Model-based development and prototype validation
The development followed a model-based V-cycle. The powertrain and control system were modelled and simulated, with vehicle behaviour assessed in drive cycles. Hardware-in-the-loop testing supported control development and refinement before implementation on a real-time controller in the physical prototype.
The prototype was built into a modified 1990 Mazda MX-5. Its electric propulsion system included a 96 V lithium iron phosphate battery pack and a permanent-magnet motor rated at 10 kW continuous and 30 kW peak. Instrumentation captured signals including clutch position and line pressure, gear and brake inputs, transmission output torque and speed, motor torque, and battery data. These measurements enabled comparison of predicted system behaviour with physical test results.
Experimental testing examined torque interruption, acceleration, jerk, fuel use and emissions. The reported results validated the model to a high degree and showed that the system could provide continuous drive torque during shifts while substantially reducing torsional drivetrain vibration manifested as longitudinal jerk. The results support the control concept, while remaining specific to the prototype and its test conditions.
Design implications for drivetrain engineers
The work highlights several practical considerations for teams developing electrified powertrains or control functions:
- Choose motor placement around the control objective. A post-transmission motor can deliver wheel torque while the clutch is disengaged, making it suitable for torque fill.
- Model the clutch as part of the control problem. Clutch pressure and re-engagement behaviour affect how torque should be delivered and how speed mismatch is managed.
- Validate across development stages. Simulation and hardware-in-the-loop testing can expose control issues before physical testing, while instrumented prototype tests reveal differences between the model and hardware.
- Plan for system evolution. The study identifies automatic clutch actuation, computerized gear selection or an automated manual transmission as potential refinements. With those functions, target speed and torque could be known through more stages of a shift, reducing reliance on predictive control.
Conclusion
A P3 mild hybrid powertrain can use a single electric motor to address a specific limitation of manual transmissions: the loss of wheel torque during gear changes. Achieving smoother delivery depends on more than motor capacity. Architecture, clutch-aware torque control, engine-speed coordination, energy management and staged validation must work together. For engineers evaluating electrification, the prototype demonstrates a practical design pathway and a clear principle: maintain torque at the wheels by coordinating electric assistance with the mechanical shift process.