A securities class action settlement can resolve claims without a final decision on whether the defendants violated the law. A November 2019 court declaration in Sokolow v. LJM Funds Management, Ltd. describes a proposed $12.85 million cash settlement, the allegations behind the case, and a proposed method for distributing funds to eligible investors. The filing supported motions asking the court to approve the settlement and allocation plan; it does not, by itself, establish that the allegations were proven or that the court granted final approval.
The dispute involving the LJM Preservation and Growth Fund
The class action was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois in February 2018. The complaint concerned offering materials for the LJM Preservation and Growth Fund, an open-ended mutual fund whose shares were offered under a registration statement dated February 28, 2015, and related documents.
According to the complaint, the Fund was promoted as seeking capital preservation and lower-risk, moderate growth, including through risk-mitigation strategies. The plaintiffs alleged that the offering materials gave investors a misleading picture of the Fund’s exposure to market declines and volatility. They further alleged that the Fund’s options positions exposed it to substantial losses and that material risks were not adequately disclosed. These are allegations summarized in the court filing, not findings of fact.
The declaration reports that the Fund’s net asset value fell sharply in February 2018. It states that the value per share declined from $9.67 to $4.27 on February 5, then to $1.91 the following day. The filing also recounts the allegation that a spike in volatility led the Fund to liquidate open positions and suffer large capital losses.
What the proposed settlement would provide
Lead Plaintiffs and Lead Counsel reached an agreement with the Settling Defendants for a stated cash amount of $12.85 million, subject to court approval. The agreement covered the Two Roads Shared Trust, Northern Lights Distributors, NorthStar Financial Services Group, and certain individual defendants. LJM Funds Management and two other named defendants were identified in the declaration as non-settling defendants, meaning they were not parties to this settlement.
The filing presents the settlement as a way to provide a certain recovery while avoiding the risks, expense, and delay of continuing litigation. That rationale was important because the case had not reached a final judgment. At the time of the declaration, the defendants had moved to dismiss the complaint, and the motion remained part of the litigation history discussed by counsel.
A settlement payment is not the same as a finding that the defendants are liable. Rather, the proposed agreement would resolve claims against the settling parties in exchange for the settlement amount, if approved and completed under the agreement’s terms.
Why liability, causation, and damages were contested
The declaration outlines several issues that could have made the case difficult to prove. The settling defendants argued, among other things, that the offering materials disclosed the Fund’s trading strategies and related risks, including the possibility of large or immediate losses. They also disputed whether statements about investment objectives and risk mitigation were actionable representations.
Other contested questions included whether particular defendants could be held liable under the securities laws and whether they had the roles or involvement alleged by the plaintiffs. The declaration also notes that some defendants could argue that their activities were peripheral to the alleged conduct.
Even if liability were established, the parties could have disputed loss causation: whether the alleged misstatements or omissions caused investor losses, rather than market movements or other factors. The defense was expected to argue that the Fund’s losses did not all result from the alleged wrongdoing. The declaration describes the analysis of damages in an open-ended mutual fund case as potentially complex and costly, with experts likely to disagree about the causes and amount of loss.
How the proposed allocation plan would work
The proposed plan was designed to distribute the net settlement fund among eligible class members who submitted valid, timely claim forms. The net fund would be the settlement fund after specified deductions, including taxes, notice and administration costs, court-awarded litigation expenses, and court-awarded attorneys’ fees.
Under the plan, claimants’ recognized loss amounts would be used to calculate pro rata shares of the available net fund. The declaration says the calculations were based principally on the statutory damages formula in Section 11(e) of the Securities Act. In general terms, that formula compares a security’s purchase price with its sale price or, in certain circumstances, its value at a specified point.
The proposed calculations also addressed shares held through the Fund’s February 2018 collapse and its later dissolution. The amount assigned to a claim depended on factors such as when shares were purchased and sold, whether they were retained after the collapse, and what proceeds the holder received. The plan proposed no payment for distributions below $10 to limit administrative costs.
Notice, claims, and requested fees
According to the declaration, the claims administrator had distributed more than 61,000 notice packets by November 12, 2019, and arranged publication of a summary notice. At that point, the filing reported two requests for exclusion and no objections received to the settlement, allocation plan, or fee request. The stated objection and exclusion deadline was November 27, 2019; the claim-form deadline was December 11, 2019.
Lead Counsel also asked the court to award fees equal to 28% of the settlement fund, or $3,598,000, and to reimburse $25,869.93 in litigation expenses, plus accrued interest. The declaration reported more than 2,681 hours of work and a collective lodestar of approximately $1.75 million through October 18, 2019. These were requests for court approval, not amounts that the declaration itself confirms were ultimately awarded.
Practical implications
The filing illustrates how securities class actions can turn on the relationship between investment-strategy descriptions, risk disclosures, market events, and measurable investor losses. For class members, the proposed allocation method shows why eligibility, transaction records, and timely claim submission matter when a settlement fund is distributed. For readers assessing the case, it is equally important to distinguish allegations and settlement arguments from judicial findings. The declaration describes a proposed resolution and the reasons counsel supported it; the court’s approval and the claims process determine what happens next.