Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Low-temperature soldering can help electronics manufacturers reduce thermal exposure during assembly, but lowering reflow temperatures also changes the demands placed on solder joints. For ball grid array (BGA) packages, a hybrid joint made with a conventional solder ball and a low-melting-point solder paste offers one approach. Its reliability depends in part on controlling how much of the original ball alloy remains after reflow.

That makes solder paste volume more than a printing consideration. Together with alloy composition and peak reflow temperature, it influences the amount of solder ball alloy that mixes into the paste and the structure of the completed joint. Understanding this relationship can help process engineers set assembly parameters more deliberately.

Why consider low-temperature soldering?

Conventional lead-free solders such as Sn-Ag-Cu (SAC) require higher reflow temperatures than the tin-lead solder they replaced. Higher temperatures can increase thermal demands on components and laminates. They can also aggravate warpage in complex packages, where layers made from materials with different coefficients of thermal expansion deform differently as they heat.

In area-array packages, dynamic warpage can separate a solder ball from the paste or pad during reflow. Depending on how the separation develops and whether the materials reconnect, defects can include head-in-pillow (HIP) or non-wet opens. Lower peak process temperatures can reduce the risk associated with warpage, but simply choosing a low-melting-point alloy is not always sufficient.

Sn-Bi alloys are attractive because the eutectic composition melts at about 139°C. However, the mechanical properties and microstructural stability of these alloys may not provide the reliability needed for BGA joints. Alloying additions can improve properties, but may also raise the temperature required for processing.

How hybrid BGA solder joints work

A hybrid approach pairs a conventional solder ball, typically a SAC alloy, with a low-melting-point Sn-Bi-based paste. During reflow, the paste melts and wets the pad and the lower portion of the ball. Tin from the ball then dissolves into the molten paste, creating a mixed-alloy region. The process can attach the package at a lower peak temperature while retaining part of the original ball alloy.

Retaining that alloy matters because joint reliability depends on where the different materials end up. Strain tends to concentrate in the region near the component side of the joint. If a suitable proportion of the original ball alloy remains in this highly stressed area, the joint can retain characteristics associated with that alloy. The aim is not simply to maximize mixing, but to control it.

How solder paste volume affects alloy mixing

For a particular ball alloy, paste alloy and reflow temperature, the volume of deposited paste affects how much ball alloy is needed to change the molten mixture’s composition. A larger paste deposit contains more low-temperature solder. As tin dissolves from the ball, more of it may be required to bring the mixture to the composition at which it becomes fully solid at the selected reflow temperature.

This relationship provides a potential way to manage the depth of mixing into the ball. If paste volume is not controlled, the amount of original ball alloy left in the joint may vary, even when the alloy combination and reflow profile are unchanged. That variation can make it harder to maintain a consistent joint structure in production.

Using phase diagrams to estimate the process window

An equilibrium phase diagram maps which phases are present at different alloy compositions and temperatures. For a binary Sn-Bi system, it can show when a mixture is fully liquid, partly liquid and solid, or fully solid. The diagram also indicates the composition at which a mixture reaches its solidus at a chosen temperature—the point at which the remaining liquid solidifies.

In the simplified model described for hybrid joints, the solder paste melts, wets the ball and pad, and begins dissolving tin from the ball. As the mixture’s tin content rises, a solid Sn-Bi phase starts to form. Further dissolution can continue while liquid remains. Once the mixture reaches the solidus composition for the reflow temperature, it becomes solid and additional mixing during the available reflow time is expected to be limited largely to solid-state diffusion.

That model links four practical variables:

  • Phase behavior: The relevant solidus line determines the composition at which mixing stops at the chosen temperature.
  • Paste alloy composition: The starting proportion of tin and bismuth affects how much tin must enter the mixture.
  • Paste volume: The quantity of solder in the deposit influences the amount of ball alloy that can dissolve before the solidus is reached.
  • Peak reflow temperature: Changing the temperature changes the solidus composition and therefore the potential extent of mixing.

For example, the paper’s model considers a 500-micrometer pure-tin ball with Sn-50Bi paste reflowed at 165°C. Under its stated assumptions, a 100-micrometer-thick, 500-micrometer-diameter paste deposit would produce a mixed region extending about 220 micrometers into the ball. This is an illustrative calculation, not a universal process setting: actual results depend on the materials and assembly conditions.

Applying the model in production

Phase-diagram calculations can provide a starting point for selecting paste volume and reflow conditions, but they do not remove the need for process validation. The example simplifies the system: it treats the ball as pure tin, uses a binary Sn-Bi alloy and assumes behavior close to equilibrium. Real assemblies may use SAC balls, modified Sn-Bi pastes and substrates that participate in reactions. Thermal gradients can also make the boundary between mixed and original alloy non-planar.

Engineers should therefore use data for the actual alloy combination and account for relevant material interactions where they are significant. The calculation is most useful as a way to understand the direction of change and estimate a candidate process window—not as a substitute for evaluating the resulting joints.

Conclusion

Hybrid BGA joints offer a route to lower-temperature assembly, but reliability depends on controlling the balance between mixed alloy and retained solder ball alloy. Paste volume, alloy composition and peak reflow temperature all shape that balance. Using phase-diagram reasoning to guide paste-deposit design can support more consistent process development, while validation with the actual materials and assembly conditions remains essential.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author