Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Metropolitan economic dynamism can influence the environment in which manufacturers, automation suppliers and industrial operators recruit, invest and grow. A 2019 index comparing 379 U.S. metropolitan areas offers a framework for understanding that dynamism: it looks beyond a single year’s job gains to combine short- and medium-term measures of economic performance with indicators associated with longer-term growth.

For industrial decision-makers, the findings are not a site-selection formula. They do, however, highlight regional conditions worth examining alongside facility costs, logistics and customer access—including technical talent, advanced manufacturing activity, entrepreneurship and connections between employers and education providers.

How the metropolitan economic dynamism index works

The index combines nine measures spanning recent performance and longer-term economic development. These include job growth, average annual pay growth, real GDP growth and per-capita personal income. It also includes the share of employment at firms five years old or younger, an indicator intended to capture the ability of new businesses to form and scale.

To make measures with different units comparable, the analysis standardizes each using z-scores. A metro’s overall index value is the average of its scores across the nine measures. This creates a common benchmark for comparing areas, but it does not explain every local condition or guarantee that past performance will continue.

The report adjusts income measures using regional price parities, which indicate whether goods and services are generally more or less expensive than the national average. That adjustment helps account for differences in purchasing power between places rather than treating nominal income as directly comparable everywhere.

Advanced manufacturing is part of a broader industry mix

The report associates stronger-performing metros with a range of knowledge-intensive industries, including professional and technical services, information services, life sciences and advanced manufacturing. The manufacturing categories identified include semiconductors, electronic instruments, computers, communications hardware, aerospace, automotive, battery production, material sciences and industrial control systems.

This range matters to automation stakeholders because regional industrial capacity does not stand alone. Manufacturing firms may benefit from nearby engineering services, technical suppliers and a workforce with relevant skills. The report describes advanced manufacturing as one contributor to metropolitan growth, rather than the sole explanation for a metro’s performance.

Its top-ranked areas illustrate how different economic foundations can produce strong results. Midland, Texas, led the index during the period studied, with growth closely tied to oil and gas activity. Midland, Michigan, ranked third and was associated with material science and engineering assets. Elkhart-Goshen, Indiana, ranked fourth, combining manufacturing with a strong recreational vehicle industry. These examples point to distinct regional specializations—not one universal model for industrial growth.

Talent and innovation depend on regional connections

Research universities and four-year colleges can contribute knowledge, technical talent and research that connects with established companies or new ventures. The report highlights commercialization and business engagement as ways these institutions can support regional innovation. For industrial employers, the broader lesson is to consider whether local education and research organizations connect with the skills and technologies relevant to their operations.

Community colleges also have a practical role. The analysis points to programs that adapt curricula to local employer needs, along with apprenticeships and certification programs linked to workplace requirements. These connections can help align training with changing skill needs and support graduates seeking local employment.

Entrepreneurship is another part of the regional picture. The index’s young-firm employment measure reflects the employment share at businesses five years old or younger. The report also identifies incubators, accelerators and access to early-stage finance as elements of an environment that can help firms start and expand. For industrial companies, these conditions may matter when assessing the availability of emerging suppliers, technical services or potential business partners.

Why resilience requires more than one growth engine

The report also describes how reliance on a narrow set of industries can expose a metro to sector-specific changes. Areas dependent on coal mining faced pressure as coal’s share of electricity generation declined, while agricultural communities were affected by lower crop prices during the period examined. Oil-producing areas could benefit from productive deposits but remained exposed to changes in drilling activity and oil prices.

This is relevant to manufacturers and operations leaders considering regional exposure. A strong current growth rate does not, by itself, reveal how an area might respond to shifts in a dominant industry. Examining the local mix of employers, suppliers, skills and supporting services can provide a fuller picture of the operating environment.

Using regional benchmarks in industrial planning

The index is best treated as a comparative tool, not a substitute for facility-level analysis. Industrial decision-makers can use regional benchmarks to frame questions such as:

  • Is the local economy supported by a range of industries or concentrated in a few sectors?
  • Are technical education programs connected to employer skill requirements?
  • Do research institutions and business networks support applied innovation?
  • Is there an ecosystem of young firms and small businesses that could contribute to the regional supply base?

The findings also caution against assuming that every community should copy the same development strategy. The report argues for a portfolio approach that supports business expansion and entrepreneurship as well as recruitment. For industrial regions, that may mean considering workforce development and local business capacity alongside efforts to attract large employers.

Conclusion

Metropolitan economic dynamism reflects the interaction of industry performance, workforce capabilities, innovation institutions and business formation. The 2019 index provides one structured way to compare those factors across U.S. metros, while its findings show that high-performing areas can follow very different paths. For automation and manufacturing leaders, the practical takeaway is to evaluate the full regional ecosystem—especially technical talent, advanced manufacturing, education partnerships and economic concentration—when assessing long-term operating conditions.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author