For industrial companies with international operations, investor access to U.S. markets can involve financial instruments that represent shares traded abroad. The Ninth Circuit’s 2018 decision in Stoyas v. Toshiba Corp. addressed how Toshiba ADRs fit within U.S. securities law when they traded over the counter rather than on a national securities exchange. The ruling did not decide the ultimate merits of the alleged fraud. It focused on whether the claims could proceed under the Exchange Act and whether the plaintiffs should have an opportunity to amend their complaint.
Why Toshiba ADRs raised a jurisdiction question
Toshiba’s common stock traded on the Tokyo Stock Exchange, while its American Depositary Receipts (ADRs) traded in the United States on an over-the-counter market. ADRs are negotiable certificates issued by a U.S. depositary institution and represent a beneficial interest in shares of a foreign company. The depositary holds the underlying shares, while ADR holders have economic interests associated with them and may have voting rights exercised through the depositary.
Investors sued Toshiba after the company acknowledged fraudulent accounting practices and restated financial results. The claims included allegations under Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rule 10b-5, based on purchases of Toshiba ADRs. The district court dismissed the claims, reasoning in part that the OTC market was not a national exchange and that the complaint did not allege a domestic transaction involving Toshiba.
The Ninth Circuit reversed the dismissal of the Exchange Act claims and remanded the case to allow amendment. Its analysis turned on the Supreme Court’s decision in Morrison v. National Australia Bank, which limits Section 10(b)’s reach to transactions in securities listed on domestic exchanges and domestic transactions in other securities.
Toshiba ADRs qualify as securities
Before considering where the transactions occurred, the Ninth Circuit addressed whether ADRs are securities under the Exchange Act. It concluded that Toshiba ADRs fit within the statute’s broad definition, including as instruments with characteristics associated with stock.
The court considered features such as the transfer of dividends from deposited shares, negotiability, the absence of restrictions on pledging the ADRs, the ability to direct voting rights, and the relationship between ADR value and the underlying Toshiba shares. It also emphasized the economic reality of the instruments: ADRs provide a way for U.S. investors to participate in foreign companies through a U.S.-traded instrument.
This point matters because the Exchange Act’s application depends on the security and transaction at issue—not simply on where the issuer is headquartered or where alleged deceptive conduct occurred. The court treated the ADRs as securities distinct from the underlying Toshiba common stock, while recognizing their close economic connection.
OTC trading is not the same as an exchange listing
The Ninth Circuit did not decide whether Morrison’s reference to domestic exchanges means only national securities exchanges or could encompass a broader category. The court found that it did not need to resolve that question because the OTC market on which Toshiba ADRs traded was not an “exchange” under the Exchange Act.
In this case, the ADRs traded through OTC Link, an alternative trading system regulated under a separate framework. The Securities and Exchange Commission’s rules exempt qualifying alternative trading systems from the statutory definition of an exchange. Accordingly, the court did not treat OTC Link as a national securities exchange for purposes of the first category described in Morrison.
This distinction is useful for companies, investors, and compliance teams assessing market structure. A security’s availability through a U.S. trading platform does not, by itself, make that platform a national securities exchange. The legal classification of the venue remains separate from whether a trade may qualify as a domestic transaction under another part of the Morrison test.
The domestic transaction test
Although the ADRs were not listed on a national exchange, the Ninth Circuit concluded that the Exchange Act could still apply if the purchases were domestic transactions in securities not registered on such an exchange. For that analysis, it adopted the “irrevocable liability” test used by the Second and Third Circuits.
Under this approach, a court examines where the parties incurred irrevocable liability: where the buyer became obligated to take and pay for the securities, and where the seller became obligated to deliver them. The location of the issuer’s headquarters, the location of the underlying shares, or the origin of alleged misconduct does not alone settle that transactional question.
The complaint alleged that the lead plaintiff purchased Toshiba ADRs in the United States on an OTC market. The Ninth Circuit held that the plaintiffs should be allowed to amend their complaint to allege that the purchase was a domestic transaction and that the alleged fraud was “in connection with” that purchase. The decision therefore allowed a further pleading effort; it did not establish that every OTC ADR purchase is domestic or that the alleged securities fraud had been proven.
Practical implications for international issuers and market participants
Stoyas highlights several distinctions that matter when assessing cross-border securities exposure:
- Instrument: ADRs may be treated as securities in their own right, even though they represent interests in shares issued by a foreign company.
- Trading venue: An OTC alternative trading system is not automatically a national securities exchange.
- Transaction location: For securities not listed on a national exchange, the place where the parties incur irrevocable liability may be central to determining whether a transaction is domestic.
- Procedural posture: Reversal of a dismissal to permit amendment is not a finding of liability or a final determination that the complaint satisfies every element of a securities fraud claim.
For multinational issuers, investor relations, legal, and compliance teams, these distinctions reinforce the importance of understanding how depositary programs are structured and how ADRs are traded. For investors and their advisers, the case underscores that the legal analysis may depend on transaction-specific facts, not merely the nationality of the issuer or the platform through which an instrument is quoted.
Conclusion
The Ninth Circuit’s Toshiba ADR decision separated two questions often conflated in cross-border securities disputes: whether an OTC venue is an exchange and whether a particular purchase is a domestic transaction. It concluded that the relevant OTC system was not an exchange, but held that a domestic purchase of an unlisted security could still fall within the Exchange Act. The practical lesson is to examine the nature of the instrument, the trading venue, and where the parties became committed to the trade—while recognizing that the ruling addressed the opportunity to amend, not the final merits of the claims.