Standards-development organizations (SDOs) help ensure that products from different manufacturers can communicate and work together. Their standards underpin technologies used across global infrastructure, while their patent policies seek to balance patent rights with broad access to standards-compliant products. Yet those policies are often interpreted through different national legal systems, creating uncertainty for participants and implementers.
One proposed response is a shared body of interpretive principles—a “lex mercatoria” of standardization—grounded in the common understanding of SDO participants rather than tied primarily to the jurisdiction where an organization happens to be based. For industrial technology companies, the issue matters wherever standards shape product compatibility, licensing obligations, or market access.
How SDO policies govern standardization
SDOs provide forums where industry representatives develop technical standards. Their members include technology developers and manufacturers, and may also include government or civil-society participants. The organizations’ governing documents—such as bylaws, membership agreements, and operating procedures—set out how standards are proposed and approved, how the organization is run, and what participants are expected to do.
Patent rules are an important part of this private governance. A standards-essential patent (SEP) is generally one whose claims must be practiced by a product that complies with a standard. SDO patent policies commonly use two mechanisms to address potential problems involving SEPs:
- Disclosure policies ask participants to identify relevant patents, often before a standard is approved.
- Licensing policies call for SEP holders to make licenses available, often on fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms.
These policies are intended to support standards development and implementation while addressing concerns such as patent hold-up and royalty stacking. Hold-up refers to the risk that a patent owner may seek excessive royalties after manufacturers have invested in a standard and become dependent on it. Royalty stacking describes the possibility that cumulative charges for numerous patents covering one standard may become excessive in the aggregate.
Why FRAND commitments lead to disputes
Many SDO policies state their licensing obligations in broad terms, leaving room for disagreement about what FRAND means in a particular case. The questions are not limited to the royalty amount. Parties may dispute the base used to calculate a royalty, whether rates should differ between countries, how volume should affect charges, and whether a patent’s value should be assessed individually or in the context of other patents covering the standard.
Non-discrimination also raises practical questions. Parties may disagree about whether rates can vary by product use, manufacturer, market, or licensing position in the supply chain. Other points of contention include reciprocal licensing, grant-backs, and defensive suspension. In the absence of detailed guidance, the meaning of a commitment may depend heavily on the circumstances and the legal framework applied to it.
Standards-development organizations and national law
SDOs are legal entities based in particular jurisdictions, and their policies may expressly select the law of that jurisdiction or be interpreted under local law by courts. This creates a geographic overlay on rules intended to guide participation in standards used around the world.
That overlay can produce several kinds of uncertainty. It may be unclear which jurisdiction’s law governs a policy; courts may have to interpret unfamiliar foreign law using competing expert accounts; and legal tools developed in one country may not fit the structure of an SDO commitment. For example, U.S. patent-damages methods built around a hypothetical negotiation may require adjustment when applied to FRAND obligations, because the parties may already have made commitments through the standard-setting process.
The same policy can therefore be analyzed differently across jurisdictions. Courts may diverge on what constitutes a reasonable royalty, how a FRAND commitment affects an injunction, or whether the policy is an enforceable contract. This complicates the task of predicting outcomes for patent holders and manufacturers operating across markets.
Global disputes and the risk of jurisdictional competition
Standards-related patent disputes can involve multiple countries, but a court may be asked to determine terms with consequences beyond its own territory. In a prominent UK dispute, the court concluded that the FRAND license at issue should be worldwide, reasoning from the licensing practices presented in that case. The decision highlighted the potential for a national court to influence a global commercial relationship.
When courts in different countries can affect the same licensing negotiations, parties have incentives to seek a forum they consider favorable. This can encourage a race to file first and, in turn, create pressure on jurisdictions to attract disputes through procedural or substantive approaches. The concern is not simply that courts will disagree; it is that competing national interpretations may pull a shared standard-setting framework in incompatible directions.
Injunctions reveal competing interpretations
Whether a SEP holder can seek an injunction against a manufacturer that has not yet obtained a license is another area of disagreement. Some approaches treat an injunction as potentially available under general patent principles, subject to limits. In the United States, courts have considered whether a FRAND commitment affects the showing required for injunctive relief. In Europe, the Court of Justice’s decision in Huawei v. ZTE set out procedural steps for both SEP holders and implementers in certain circumstances where competition law applies.
SDO policies are often silent on litigation remedies, so courts and regulators have had to interpret the relationship between a licensing promise and the right to seek exclusionary relief. Some private commitments and policy revisions have expressly addressed injunctions, illustrating that participants may clarify expectations through SDO rules or related agreements. Differences among national patent and competition laws, however, continue to shape how those expectations are enforced.
What a shared interpretive framework could address
A lex mercatoria of standardization would not necessarily replace national law or eliminate the need for courts. Its purpose would be to develop common interpretive principles based on the practices and shared expectations of SDO participants. Such principles could help clarify recurring questions, including:
- How an SDO policy becomes binding on its participants, whether through contract, organizational rules, or another legal theory.
- Whether FRAND commitments remain applicable when a covered patent is transferred to a new owner.
- How licensing and non-discrimination obligations should be interpreted across different markets and supply-chain positions.
- What remedies are consistent with commitments made during standard development.
These questions matter because a policy can have limited practical value if its obligations are difficult to enforce or can be sidestepped through a transfer. A shared approach could make policy interpretation more coherent while recognizing that SDOs use different organizational forms and documentation.
Conclusion: Aligning private rules with global standards
SDOs are private organizations whose standards can have broad public and commercial significance. Their patent policies are also products of private ordering, but national laws often determine how those policies are interpreted and enforced. The resulting patchwork can create uncertainty around FRAND licensing, patent transfers, and injunctions, while encouraging litigation across competing forums.
For standards participants and implementers, the practical lesson is to treat SDO policy language as a consequential part of standards governance, not as administrative detail. Clearer policies can reduce ambiguity, while shared interpretive principles could help courts and participants apply commitments more consistently across borders. A common lexicon would not resolve every dispute, but it could better connect global technical standardization with the legal expectations that support it.