Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Antitrust enforcement in digital markets was a central policy question during the 2018 transition in leadership at the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC). For industrial automation companies and other technology-driven businesses, the issues raised then remain useful context: how regulators assess mergers, when market power becomes a competition concern, and whether pricing algorithms can facilitate coordination. The analysis reflected expectations at that time, not a description of current FTC policy or later outcomes.

Why FTC leadership mattered in 2018

In February 2018, the FTC had been operating with only two of its five commissioner seats filled. The Senate was considering four nominees, including Joseph Simons, a former director of the agency’s Bureau of Competition. A fuller commission was expected to have greater capacity to consider merger reviews and other competition matters, while its approach to high-profile technology firms remained uncertain.

Simons brought experience from both the FTC and private practice. As Bureau of Competition director in the early 2000s, he oversaw more than 70 antitrust enforcement actions, according to the source analysis, and supported a greater role for administrative litigation. He also helped develop Critical Loss Analysis, a method for defining markets that was later incorporated into the DOJ and FTC Merger Guidelines.

In material prepared for Congress, Simons criticized the FTC’s merger approach as too permissive and raised concerns about remedies based on divesting asset packages that were not stand-alone businesses. His comments pointed to a tougher approach to merger review, particularly where regulators believed a transaction could harm consumers through higher prices, reduced choice or effects on workers.

Merger review and remedies

The analysis expected merger enforcement to be a major focus for the incoming commission, given the number of significant transactions then under consideration. It also anticipated that vertical mergers—transactions between companies operating at different stages of a supply chain—would make up a smaller share of the FTC’s merger workload than horizontal mergers between competitors.

For vertical transactions, the expectation was that Simons might favor structural remedies over behavioral ones. A structural remedy changes the ownership or assets involved, often through divestiture. A behavioral remedy instead requires a company to follow specific rules after a deal closes. The analysis noted that the outcome of the DOJ’s AT&T-Time Warner litigation could influence the broader enforcement climate, but it did not determine how the FTC would act in a particular case.

For industrial businesses considering acquisitions, the practical lesson in the 2018 discussion was that deal review could focus not only on the market position created by a transaction, but also on whether a proposed remedy would preserve effective competition. The source does not establish how regulators would assess any specific industrial automation transaction.

Market power, consumer welfare and big tech

Simons’s stated position, as described in the analysis, distinguished size from anticompetitive conduct. A company becoming large because customers value its products or services would not, by size alone, justify antitrust action. The key question was whether a firm used its market power to restrict competition in a way that harmed consumer welfare.

This approach shaped the article’s cautious forecast about U.S. action against companies such as Amazon, Google and Facebook. Despite bipartisan concern about the influence of large technology platforms, the analysis expected substantial non-merger enforcement only where there was clear evidence of conduct that violated the consumer-welfare principle. It also anticipated that the FTC would weigh factors such as the potential harm to consumers, the importance of the sector to household budgets, agency experience and the value of clarifying legal questions.

That framework is relevant to technology suppliers across industrial markets. A large market share is not, on its own, the same as proof of unlawful conduct. The distinction highlighted in the 2018 analysis was between achieving scale through consumer-valued offerings and using dominance to impede competition.

Algorithmic pricing and competition concerns

The growth of e-commerce had prompted the FTC and DOJ to examine how data and computer algorithms might affect competition. Algorithmic pricing can let businesses respond quickly to large volumes of market information. In the source analysis, this was described as generally compatible with competitive behavior: a business may use pricing tools to adjust to market conditions.

The concern was more specific. If pricing systems are widely used, their speed and ease of adjustment could affect the incentives firms face when discounting or departing from coordinated prices. However, parallel price movements do not by themselves establish collusion. The analysis emphasized that antitrust enforcement requires evidence of an agreement or other legally relevant conduct; U.S. antitrust law is not a general system of price control.

This distinction matters for companies deploying automated pricing or purchasing systems. The existence of an algorithm or similar prices across firms is not, on its own, proof of an antitrust violation. The source instead points to the importance of examining whether there is evidence of coordination or conduct that narrows competition.

Competition policy and changing markets

The 2018 analysis also discussed the FTC’s prospective role in policing internet service providers following a change in federal broadband rules. It noted that questions about blocking, throttling and paid prioritization could intersect with competition law, while also describing uncertainty about the commission’s appetite for action. These were expectations at the time, not a statement about subsequent enforcement or regulation.

More broadly, the analysis argued that established U.S. antitrust law could be applied to changing markets without treating the FTC as a “price police.” The anticipated approach was case-specific: assess the conduct, its competitive effects and the available evidence rather than intervene simply because a firm was large or prices moved in parallel.

Practical implications for technology-driven businesses

The historical discussion offers several considerations for industrial automation leaders, system integrators and technical decision-makers evaluating market strategy:

  • Assess transactions carefully: Merger review can examine competitive effects and the credibility of proposed remedies, not just the identities of the parties.
  • Separate scale from conduct: Market position alone is distinct from evidence that a company is using dominance to restrict competition.
  • Understand pricing-system risks: Automated pricing can support rapid market responses, but competition concerns depend on the conduct and evidence involved.
  • Track policy as context: The 2018 expectations were tied to a particular leadership transition and should not be treated as a current forecast.

For businesses operating in digital and technology-enabled markets, the central takeaway is the importance of distinguishing innovation and efficient competition from conduct that undermines rivalry. The 2018 FTC discussion highlighted merger remedies, market power and algorithmic pricing as areas where that distinction would matter. It also underscored that antitrust conclusions depend on the facts of each case and the legal standards applied.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author