For industrial automation companies, patents can cover technologies central to products, equipment, and control systems. When a patent is challenged through patent inter partes review, or IPR, procedural rules can determine whether the challenge proceeds before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). A dispute involving Thryv and Click-to-Call Technologies focused on one such rule: whether a petition was filed within the statutory time limit, and whether the PTAB’s decision on that issue could be reviewed by a court.
The case highlights a distinction that matters to anyone managing a patent dispute: the decision to begin an administrative review is separate from the later decision on whether challenged patent claims are valid. The brief filed by Thryv argued that courts should not review the PTAB’s institution-stage determination that the time bar did not apply. The Federal Circuit had taken the opposing position.
How patent inter partes review works
The America Invents Act established IPR as an administrative process for challenging the patentability of claims in an issued patent. The proceeding is handled by the PTAB, which operates within the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. The process has two main stages.
- Institution: The PTAB considers the petition, the patent owner’s preliminary response, and statutory requirements. It decides whether to begin an IPR.
- Review on the merits: If the PTAB institutes review, the parties proceed through a trial-like process that can include discovery, briefing, and an oral hearing. The Board then issues a final written decision on patentability.
The statutory threshold for institution includes whether the petition shows a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail on at least one challenged claim. That threshold does not guarantee institution: the PTAB may decline to begin a review even when the petitioner meets it. If review proceeds, the Board’s final written decision addresses the patentability of the challenged claims.
The IPR one-year time bar
Under Section 315(b) of the patent statute, an IPR may not be instituted if the petition is filed more than one year after the petitioner, a real party in interest, or a privy of the petitioner is served with a complaint alleging infringement of the patent. The rule connects an administrative patent challenge to earlier infringement litigation.
In the dispute described in Thryv’s brief, Click-to-Call argued that the petition was late because a company associated with the petitioners had been served with an infringement complaint years earlier. That earlier case had been voluntarily dismissed without prejudice. The PTAB concluded that the dismissal meant the complaint did not trigger the time bar, and it instituted review. The Board later found the challenged claims unpatentable.
Click-to-Call appealed the institution-related time-bar ruling rather than challenging the PTAB’s patentability determination. The case therefore put the reviewability of a procedural decision at the center of the appeal.
Why the appealability question mattered
Section 314(d) provides that the Director’s determination whether to institute an IPR is “final and nonappealable.” Thryv argued that this language covers the PTAB’s decision about the Section 315(b) time bar because that issue is part of deciding whether an IPR may begin. In its view, the statute places institution questions outside judicial review, while allowing an appeal after the PTAB issues its final written decision on patentability.
The Federal Circuit, sitting en banc in a related case, had held that Section 315(b) time-bar determinations were appealable. Its reasoning relied in part on the general presumption that agency decisions can be reviewed by courts. The Thryv brief argued that the specific wording and structure of the America Invents Act overcame that presumption.
The competing interpretations reflect two different concerns. Limiting appeals at the institution stage can help keep the IPR process focused on the patentability question and avoid a separate court challenge over preliminary procedural decisions. Allowing review, on the other hand, offers a route to contest an agency’s interpretation of a statutory requirement that can prevent an IPR from being instituted.
What patent teams should take from the dispute
For companies in industrial automation and other technology sectors, the practical lesson is that an IPR involves more than technical arguments about a patent’s claims. Timing, corporate relationships, and the history of infringement litigation can also affect whether a challenge proceeds. The statute specifically refers to a petitioner, a real party in interest, and a privy, so identifying the relevant parties and prior proceedings is part of assessing the time-bar issue.
Patent owners and petitioners should distinguish between questions raised at institution and those addressed in the final written decision. A preliminary response can raise reasons why the petition should not proceed, including a statutory bar. If the PTAB institutes review, the case moves into a separate stage focused on patentability, with its own record and final decision.
The procedural posture also matters when considering an appeal. In this dispute, the appeal concerned the PTAB’s institution-stage time-bar decision, not the merits finding that the claims were unpatentable. That distinction can affect which statutory provisions govern and what issues are available for judicial review.
Conclusion
The Thryv dispute illustrates how the IPR institution process can turn on a procedural question before a patent’s technical merits are examined. The one-year time bar links prior infringement litigation to the availability of administrative review, while Section 314(d) addresses whether institution decisions can be appealed. For industrial technology organizations, careful attention to filing dates, party relationships, litigation history, and the separation between institution and merits stages is essential when evaluating a patent challenge.