Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

The LIC and LIT market recorded a notable recovery in the June 2020 quarter, even as volatility continued to constrain new listings and capital raisings. For investors comparing listed investment companies and listed investment trusts, the period also underscored an important distinction: a fund’s underlying portfolio performance and the return experienced by shareholders can differ materially.

Sector capitalisation rose 9.1% to $44.2 billion during the quarter. However, that recovery followed a sharp market sell-off and coincided with substantial monetary and fiscal stimulus in Australia and globally. The figures are a snapshot of a highly unusual period, rather than an indication of future performance.

LIC and LIT market activity remained subdued

There were no initial public offerings in the quarter, leaving primary market activity at zero for the first half of 2020. The report attributed the lack of listings to market volatility and wider discounts to net tangible assets (NTA), which made the conditions less favourable for prospective funds.

Secondary fundraising was similarly limited. Just $481,000 was raised across two LICs and LITs, down from $1.9 million in the preceding three months. By comparison, dividend reinvestment plans raised $21.6 million, substantially below the $80.7 million recorded in the previous quarter. The timing of dividends from large funds, including Australian Foundation Investment Company and Argo Investments, contributed to the decline. Wilson Asset Management LICs accounted for about 56% of June-quarter DRP participation.

Option exercises generated a further $409,000. Most of this came from Monash Absolute Investment Company options, although a large number of its options expired in May, representing potential capital that was not raised. These flows show why it is useful to distinguish between new issuance, shareholder offers, dividend reinvestment and option exercises when assessing listed-fund capital activity.

Share price returns and portfolio returns told different stories

Fund performance can be viewed through two measures. Pre-tax NTA returns are intended to show how the underlying investments performed, while share price returns reflect how the listed security traded on the ASX. The two can diverge when investors’ demand for a fund changes its share price relative to its NTA.

In domestic equities, the market-cap-weighted share price return, including net dividends, was 10.9% for the quarter. The corresponding pre-tax NTA return was 15.9%. The All Ordinaries Accumulation Index returned 16.5%, while the S&P/ASX 200 Accumulation Index returned 16.8%. On average, domestic LIC and LIT NTA returns underperformed their relevant benchmarks by 1.3%.

Performance varied considerably between mandates and funds. Thorney Technologies led domestic LICs and LITs by share price return, gaining 56.3%; its pre-tax NTA return was 33.3%. Its discount to pre-tax NTA narrowed from 30.7% to 18.8% over the quarter. The comparison illustrates how a recovering share price can reflect both portfolio gains and a change in the market’s valuation of the fund.

Global equity funds produced a market-cap-weighted share price return of 9.7%, compared with a 5.1% pre-tax NTA return. The MSCI World Net Total Return Index, measured in Australian dollars, returned 5.2%, while the MSCI All Country Asia ex-Japan index returned 2.6%. Results differed across individual mandates, making comparisons with an appropriate benchmark more informative than a single sector-wide figure.

Understanding LIC discounts to NTA

A LIC or LIT share price can trade above or below the value of its underlying assets per share or unit. This premium or discount to NTA is a separate consideration from portfolio performance: an investor’s market return is influenced by both changes in the assets and changes in the price-to-NTA relationship.

By the end of June, the market-cap-weighted domestic share price discount to pre-tax NTA was 2.4%, compared with a 2.5% premium at the end of March. For global mandates, the weighted average discount was 9.4%. The report also recorded average discounts of 10.6% for domestic mandates, 12.9% for global mandates and 16.4% for alternative strategies when calculated on an arithmetic basis. Because these are different averages, they should not be treated as interchangeable.

Discounts can create opportunities, but a discount alone does not establish that a fund is attractively valued. Investors may also need to consider the mandate, portfolio exposures, liquidity, operating costs and possible reasons the market is applying a lower valuation. Comparing the share price with the relevant pre-tax NTA can help clarify what is driving the observed return.

Dividend yields require context

Historical yield was another point of interest during the quarter, particularly as investors considered the effects of COVID-19 on company earnings and investment income. The report noted potential pressure on Australian bank income and the possibility that reduced special income items could flow through to LIC and LIT distributions.

LICs can retain earnings and build dividend reserves, which may support distributions through weaker periods. Their company structure also means they can generate franking credits from tax paid on profits, alongside credits received from underlying investments. These features do not guarantee that a dividend will continue at the same level. Investors assessing income may wish to distinguish between:

  • Net yield: the historical dividend or distribution relative to the share or unit price.
  • Gross yield: a yield adjusted to reflect franking credits where applicable.
  • Dividend cover and reserves: indicators that provide context on a LIC’s capacity to maintain distributions, but are not guarantees of future payments.

The report highlighted Australian Foundation Investment Company’s guidance to maintain its final fully franked dividend at 14 cents per share. It also reported a preliminary unaudited profit reserve of $1.1 billion and a franking credit balance of $207.9 million at FY20 year-end. These details illustrate why headline yield is only one part of an income assessment.

What investors should take from the quarter

The June 2020 quarter combined a strong market-capitalisation recovery with minimal new fundraising and meaningful differences between NTA and share price returns. For investors, the practical lesson is to assess a listed fund on several dimensions rather than relying on a single performance number or yield.

Compare pre-tax NTA and share price performance over consistent periods, use benchmarks that fit the fund’s investment mandate, and examine whether a premium or discount has widened or narrowed. For income-focused decisions, consider franking, dividend reserves and the source of earnings alongside historical yield. These measures provide a more complete framework for understanding LICs and LITs, while recognising that past returns and distributions cannot guarantee future results.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author