Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Credit rating reviews are intended to assess whether a company’s creditworthiness has changed, and the process can give rating agencies time to gather information and engage with management. But for firms with actively traded credit default swaps (CDS), market participants may already be evaluating that information. Evidence from 1,520 review processes between 2004 and 2015 suggests that CDS trading and credit ratings interact in ways that can reduce the amount of new information delivered by a final rating decision.

The central practical question is whether CDS spreads move as a review unfolds—and whether those movements anticipate a downgrade, upgrade, or confirmation. The findings point to a particularly active role for CDS markets in monitoring credit risk during reviews for downgrade.

How CDS markets relate to credit rating reviews

A rating review is not itself a rating change. Agencies may place a rating under review while they investigate a potential change, sometimes seeking additional information from company management. The eventual outcome may be a downgrade or upgrade, or confirmation of the existing rating.

CDS contracts offer a market-based way to trade exposure to a borrower’s credit risk. Changes in CDS spreads can therefore provide an ongoing signal about how market participants assess that risk. If spreads adjust while a rating is under review, the agency’s eventual decision may confirm information already reflected in the market rather than introduce it for the first time.

The study examined review outcomes and spread movements for listed U.S. and European non-financial firms with available CDS data and ratings from S&P, Moody’s, or Fitch. Its final sample contained 1,520 reviews, including reviews for downgrade and upgrade that ended either in a rating change or an affirmation.

CDS spread movements during reviews for downgrade

The clearest pattern appeared in reviews for downgrade. When a review ended in a downgrade, CDS spreads widened substantially during the review period. When the agency affirmed the existing rating, spreads instead tightened. This contrast indicates that market pricing evolved differently depending on the eventual outcome.

Importantly, the spread movement was not confined to the period after the agency’s decision. For reviews that led to a downgrade, spreads had already widened in the 30 days before the review announcement. That pre-announcement movement suggests CDS market participants may identify deteriorating credit conditions before the formal review process becomes public.

Spreads also changed most meaningfully earlier in the review period. For downgrade reviews, the analysis found relatively little additional movement after roughly three-quarters of the time under review had passed. By the time the agency announced its final decision, much of the market’s adjustment had already occurred.

These results support the interpretation that the final downgrade can serve partly as a confirmation of information reflected in CDS spreads. They do not establish that CDS markets know every fact available to rating agencies; rather, they show that spread dynamics can provide timely indications of how credit risk is being reassessed.

What happens during reviews for upgrade?

The pattern for reviews for upgrade was less pronounced. Spreads generally tightened around the review announcement, but the subsequent path depended on the outcome. When a review led to an upgrade, spreads tightened further during the process. When the rating was affirmed, some of the initial tightening reversed.

Unlike downgrade reviews, the study found little evidence that CDS spreads moved significantly in the period before an upgrade review announcement. The findings therefore suggest that CDS markets were better able to anticipate downgrade outcomes than upgrade outcomes in this sample.

Implications for credit monitoring

The results raise questions about the monitoring role traditionally associated with rating agencies. A review can put pressure on a company to address credit concerns, but when CDS are traded, market pricing may also communicate risk and respond as new assessments emerge.

For investors, lenders, and corporate finance teams, the findings underline the value of treating CDS spreads as one input in credit-risk monitoring—not as a substitute for comprehensive analysis. A widening spread during a downgrade review may indicate increasing concern, while tightening spreads can reflect a more favorable reassessment. Interpretation still depends on the review’s context and eventual outcome.

The distinction between market signals and agency decisions also matters. Rating agencies may continue to provide analysis and certification, even when market movements precede a formal decision. For firms without traded CDS, the review process may retain a more significant monitoring function because this market-based signal is not available.

Practical takeaway

Across the reviews examined, CDS spreads often reflected information about downgrade outcomes before rating agencies reached their final decisions. Their movements were especially informative during reviews for downgrade, while the evidence for upgrade reviews was more mixed. For credit-risk teams and decision-makers, monitoring CDS spread trends alongside rating actions can provide useful context on how market participants are reassessing a borrower. The broader implication is that, where CDS trading exists, credit monitoring is shared: agencies provide formal assessments, while markets can deliver a timely and continuously updated signal.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author