Corrosion inhibitors can help control metal loss without requiring changes to an existing process system. But an inhibitor’s effectiveness depends on the specific metal, corrosive medium and compound being evaluated. Polarization-curve testing of CT-10 steel in 0.1 N hydrochloric acid examined five amino acids and showed how their molecular structures corresponded with different levels of protection under the test conditions.
Why test inhibitors against a specific steel and environment?
Inhibitors are added to an aggressive environment to reduce corrosion, often at relatively low concentrations. Their practical appeal is that protection may be achieved without redesigning the process equipment or changing the overall technology. However, an additive that suppresses corrosion in one system may have little effect—or behave differently—in another. Inhibitor selection therefore needs to be specific to both the material and the service environment.
This study examined CT-10 steel immersed in 0.1 N hydrochloric acid. The compounds were amino acids with different functional-group arrangements: glycine and leucine, which are aliphatic monoamino-monocarboxylic acids; aspartic and glutamic acids, which have an additional carboxyl group; and arginine, an aliphatic diamino-monocarboxylic acid. Each was tested at 200 mg/L.
How polarization curves assess corrosion inhibitors
Polarization testing measures the electrochemical response of a metal as its potential is varied. The resulting curves provide information about anodic and cathodic reactions associated with corrosion. From these measurements, researchers can derive parameters such as corrosion potential, corrosion current density and polarization resistance.
In the reported experiments, a potentiostat–galvanostat was used with CT-10 steel as the working electrode, platinum as the auxiliary electrode and a saturated silver/silver chloride reference electrode. Tests were conducted at 20°C, with air freely available to the solution. The potential was scanned at 2 mV per second, and the measurements were processed using electrochemical analysis software.
Two indicators are especially useful when comparing the inhibitor-free solution with solutions containing an amino acid:
- Corrosion current density is used as an indicator of corrosion rate; a lower value indicates less electrochemical corrosion under the test conditions.
- Polarization resistance describes resistance to charge transfer at the metal–solution interface. A higher value is consistent with increased resistance to corrosion.
What the CT-10 steel results show
All five compounds produced an inhibiting effect to some degree. The reported corrosion current density for CT-10 steel without an inhibitor was 3.325 × 10-4 A/cm². With glycine, leucine, aspartic acid, glutamic acid and arginine, the study reported reductions in corrosion rate of approximately 1.71, 2.05, 1.92, 1.92 and 2.09 times, respectively. Polarization resistance increased by approximately 1.72 times with glycine, 2.35 times with leucine, 2.32 times with each of the two dicarboxylic acids, and 2.37 times with arginine.
The study classified the compounds as mixed inhibitors. In the polarization results, corrosion potential generally shifted in the negative direction, suggesting some inhibition of the cathodic process, while changes in the anodic polarization behavior indicated an effect on the anodic process as well. In practical terms, the compounds influenced both sides of the electrochemical corrosion reaction rather than acting solely on one reaction pathway.
Molecular structure and inhibitor performance
The reported effectiveness ranking placed arginine highest, followed by leucine, then glutamic and aspartic acids, with glycine lowest. The differences are associated with the compounds’ molecular structures, although the results do not establish a universal rule for predicting inhibitor performance.
Glycine has the smallest molecular structure among the compounds tested. Leucine has a longer carbon chain, and its greater effectiveness in this test is consistent with the study’s observation that structural changes can affect protection. Aspartic acid adds a second carboxyl group compared with glycine, while glutamic acid differs from aspartic acid by one additional methylene group. Their reported performance was similar, indicating that this relatively small structural change had only a limited effect in the tested system.
Arginine combines multiple functional groups, including amino-related groups, with a carbon chain. The authors proposed that such groups and heteroatoms can support adsorption at the metal surface. Adsorption is a plausible way for an organic inhibitor to interfere with interactions between the metal and corrosive solution, but the degree of protection must still be confirmed experimentally for the application in question.
Implications for corrosion-control decisions
The study also compared the findings with earlier tests on CT-3 steel in a similar acidic environment. The corrosion and electrochemical parameters for CT-10 and CT-3 were reported to be close, as was the relative ordering of the tested compounds. This supports a comparison between these particular steels and conditions; it does not show that the materials are interchangeable or that results will transfer to other acids, concentrations, temperatures or operating systems.
For engineers and plant decision-makers, the central lesson is to treat inhibitor screening as a material-and-environment-specific task. Polarization curves can help compare candidate compounds by revealing changes in corrosion current, polarization resistance and reaction behavior. The amino acids in this test reduced corrosion of CT-10 steel in 0.1 N hydrochloric acid, with arginine producing the strongest reported effect and glycine the weakest. These laboratory findings can inform candidate selection, but process use requires validation under the relevant operating conditions.