Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Cost of capital benchmarking can help industrial automation companies and their advisers put valuation assumptions into an industry context. For manufacturers, system integrators and other automation businesses, that context may inform analysis of a company, business interest, security or intangible asset. It does not replace company-specific analysis: industry averages are reference points to assess alongside a business’s own financial profile and circumstances.

A 2019 U.S. industry cost-of-capital resource illustrates the breadth of data that may support this work, including estimates for approximately 170 industries organized by Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) code. Its data ran through December 2019, so it should be understood as a historical example of an industry benchmarking framework—not as current market guidance.

What cost of capital benchmarking can show

Cost of capital is used in valuation analysis to represent the return required by providers of capital. The resource described in the handbook presents industry-level estimates of the cost of equity, cost of debt and weighted average cost of capital (WACC). WACC combines the costs of different sources of capital, weighted according to the capital structure assumptions used in the analysis.

For cost of equity, the handbook lists eight estimation approaches, subject to data availability. These include the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), versions that add a size premium or industry risk premium, build-up approaches, one- and three-stage discounted cash flow (DCF) models, and the Fama-French five-factor model. The resulting estimates are not interchangeable: each method has its own inputs and assumptions. Comparing them can help an analyst understand how method choice affects a valuation rather than treating one output as definitive.

Alongside capital cost estimates, the benchmarking data covers measures such as sales, market capitalization, capital structure, levered and unlevered betas, trading multiples, financial and profitability ratios, equity returns and aggregate forward-looking earnings-per-share growth rates. These measures can help frame an industry comparison and provide inputs for an analyst’s own work.

Applying industry benchmarks to automation businesses

Industrial automation spans different business models, from equipment and component manufacturers to engineering and integration services. A broad industry label may not capture the economics of a particular company. SIC classification can help locate relevant industry groups, but an analyst still needs to judge whether the selected peer set reflects the business being valued.

Industry benchmarks are most useful as a way to benchmark, augment and support custom analysis. For example, a valuation team assessing an automation supplier could compare its capital structure or profitability measures with an appropriate industry reference, then investigate meaningful differences. The benchmark does not explain those differences by itself, nor does it establish what a particular company is worth.

The underlying company-screening method also matters. In the handbook’s described process, the main set included seasoned companies with a minimum level of product or service sales and some positive operating cash flow. Companies classified as “pure play” had at least 75% of revenue from one SIC code. A separate high-financial-risk set was analyzed apart from the main set. The resulting statistics therefore reflect defined selection rules, not every company that might be associated with an industry.

Why capital structure and lease treatment matter

Debt-like obligations can affect how financial risk is assessed. The handbook’s analysis considered capitalized operating leases and unfunded pension obligations as off-balance-sheet debt-equivalent items, with capital structure and unlevered beta statistics calculated both with and without them. This lets users examine how including such obligations may change the industry picture.

Lease accounting changes made comparability particularly important in the period covered. Under the standards described in the handbook, lessees recognize lease liabilities and corresponding right-of-use assets, although income-statement treatment differs between U.S. GAAP and IFRS. U.S. GAAP retains different accounting models for operating and finance leases, while IFRS uses a single lessee model. The 2019 analysis excluded operating lease liabilities for companies that had adopted the new rules, aiming to maintain comparability with companies that had not yet reflected them in their annual statements.

For analysts, the practical lesson is to check how leases and other debt-like items are treated before comparing leverage, beta or valuation multiples across companies. Accounting presentation can alter the reported metrics used in a benchmark, even when the underlying business obligations remain relevant to assessing risk.

Use benchmarks as inputs, not conclusions

Industry data can provide structure for valuation work, but its value depends on careful application. Before using a benchmark, decision-makers should consider:

  • Coverage: Confirm the industry classification and whether the available sample is relevant to the business under review.
  • Selection: Understand the screening criteria and whether the analysis separates high-financial-risk companies.
  • Methods: Review the model and assumptions behind each cost-of-capital estimate.
  • Comparability: Check accounting treatment, especially for leases and capital structure measures.
  • Data date: Match the period covered by the data to the purpose of the analysis; historical benchmarks are not current estimates.

Conclusion

For industrial automation decision-makers, cost of capital benchmarking offers a disciplined way to place valuation assumptions beside industry-level measures. The most useful results come from understanding how the data was assembled, selecting relevant comparisons and adjusting the interpretation for company-specific facts and accounting differences. Treat benchmarks as evidence to support a custom analysis—not a substitute for it—and verify that the data period is appropriate before relying on the conclusions.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author