Index fund tracking depends on more than holding a portfolio that resembles a benchmark. Managers must also respond to index changes, manage the effects of trading and report how closely fund returns align with the index. Northern Trust’s interim report for the six months ended 30 June 2023 provides examples of these activities across global, regional, ESG-focused and real estate funds.
Index fund tracking: measuring results against a benchmark
A benchmark provides a reference point for assessing a fund’s performance. The report compares each fund’s return with its stated benchmark or reference index over a defined period. For example, the Northern Trust World Equity Index Fund returned 15.18% in the first half of 2023, compared with 15.09% for the MSCI World Index. The report describes this as outperformance of 9 basis points.
Results varied across the fund range. The World Custom ESG Equity Index Fund returned 15.87%, versus 15.66% for its benchmark, while the North America Custom ESG Equity Index Fund returned 17.26%, against 17.13%. These comparisons show why performance should be read fund by fund: each portfolio has its own index, investment approach and reporting period.
Some funds in the report were not designed simply to reproduce an index. Value, high-dividend, quality and low-volatility strategies were assessed against reference indices, with the review discussing the factors behind relative performance. The High Dividend ESG World Equity Fund, for instance, returned 11.64% in the period, below the MSCI World Index return of 15.09%. Its review identifies the relative weakness of high-yielding shares as a contributor to that result.
Why index rebalancing requires careful execution
Index providers periodically change their constituents. When a benchmark adds or removes companies, an index-tracking portfolio may need to adjust its holdings to reflect the revised index. The report records MSCI changes made at the end of February and May 2023. For the MSCI World Index, the February review involved 12 additions and nine deletions; the May review involved 18 additions and 14 deletions.
These changes also create a portfolio-management task: implement trades while limiting costs and unintended differences from the benchmark. Northern Trust’s reviews state that index changes were traded carefully to minimise cost and deviation. They also note that managers used the changes as an opportunity to equitise some futures exposure. In this context, equitising refers to using futures to maintain market exposure rather than leaving that exposure temporarily in cash.
The report includes one-way index turnover for the index reviews, such as 0.44% and 0.75% for the two MSCI World change dates. Turnover helps describe the scale of constituent changes, while the fund’s returns and tracking measures show outcomes from the portfolio’s perspective.
Understanding tracking error and performance periods
Tracking error is another measure included in several reviews. The report gives one-year ex-post tracking error figures as of 30 June 2023, including 0.03% for the World Equity Index Fund and 0.14% for the Europe Custom ESG Equity Index Fund. These figures describe how the fund’s returns varied relative to its benchmark over the measurement period; they are distinct from the simple difference between returns over the first half of the year.
Time period matters when interpreting any comparison. The report presents first-half returns for many active sub-funds, alongside since-inception annualised returns. Other funds had terminated during the reporting period: the North America Value ESG Fund ended on 31 January 2023, and the World EUR Hedged Equity Index Fund ended on 4 April 2023. Their reviews therefore use shorter reporting periods, not the full six months.
ESG classifications and disclosure
The report also distinguishes funds by their classification under the EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR). Article 8 funds promote environmental or social characteristics and are subject to related disclosure requirements. Several funds in the report—including custom ESG, low-carbon and green-transition strategies—are identified as Article 8. By contrast, the World Equity Index Fund and Developed Real Estate Index Fund are classified as Article 6 and are stated not to promote environmental or social characteristics or have sustainable investment as an objective.
These classifications are disclosures about a fund’s stated characteristics and regulatory reporting category. They do not replace the separate performance comparison with a benchmark. Keeping those two kinds of information distinct helps readers understand both what a fund seeks to represent and how its returns compared with its reference index.
Practical takeaways from the interim review
For investors and fund analysts, the report illustrates several useful checks when reviewing an index-based portfolio:
- Compare returns with the correct benchmark and reporting period.
- Review tracking error alongside, not instead of, the return difference.
- Note index additions, deletions and turnover as context for portfolio activity.
- Separate benchmark-tracking strategies from funds with value, income, quality or other tilts.
- Read ESG and SFDR disclosures as a distinct layer of information.
Together, these measures offer a clearer picture than headline returns alone. The interim review shows that index fund tracking involves benchmark alignment, measured execution around index changes and transparent reporting of performance and fund characteristics. For decision-makers, the practical lesson is to assess each fund against its own mandate, benchmark and reporting timeframe.