A financial statement audit provides decision-makers with an independent opinion on whether financial reports are fairly presented in all material respects. The 2021 annual statements for four Canadian investment funds offer a clear example of what that assurance covers—and, just as importantly, what it does not. For technical and operational leaders who review audited reports, the audit process offers a useful framework for understanding reporting responsibilities, evidence and risk.
What the financial statement audit covered
KPMG audited the statements of financial position, comprehensive income, changes in net assets and cash flows for the CC&L Alternative Global Equity Fund, CC&L Alternative Canadian Equity Fund and CC&L Alternative Income Fund. The report also covered PCJ Absolute Return II Fund, which began operations on March 5, 2021, so its financial performance, changes in net assets and cash flows covered the period through December 31, 2021. The other funds included year-end comparisons with 2020.
The auditor concluded that the statements presented the funds’ financial positions, performance and cash flows fairly, in all material respects, under International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). That is an opinion on the financial statements as a whole—not a guarantee that every transaction is error-free or that no misstatement exists.
How auditors approach risk and evidence
The audit was conducted under Canadian generally accepted auditing standards. The auditor’s objective was to obtain reasonable assurance that the statements were free from material misstatement, whether caused by fraud or error. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but it is not absolute: an audit may not detect every material misstatement.
Audit work begins by identifying and assessing risks that could lead to material misstatement. The auditor then designs procedures in response and gathers evidence considered sufficient and appropriate to support the opinion. The report notes that fraud can be harder to detect than error because it may involve collusion, forgery, deliberate omissions, misrepresentation or overriding internal controls.
Professional judgment and skepticism are part of this work. Auditors also consider whether:
- The accounting policies are appropriate and estimates and related disclosures are reasonable.
- The statements’ structure, content and disclosures support fair presentation of the underlying transactions and events.
- The manager’s use of the going-concern basis of accounting is appropriate, and whether relevant events or conditions create a material uncertainty.
Internal controls and management responsibility
The fund manager—not the auditor—is responsible for preparing and fairly presenting the financial statements under IFRS. The manager is also responsible for establishing the internal control it considers necessary to prepare statements free of material misstatement due to fraud or error.
Auditors obtain an understanding of internal controls relevant to their audit so they can design procedures suited to the circumstances. That work does not amount to an opinion on whether the controls are effective. This distinction matters when interpreting an audit report: an unmodified opinion on financial statements should not be read as a certification of the organization’s entire control environment.
Governance has a separate role. Those charged with governance oversee the financial reporting process, while the auditor communicates with them about the planned scope and timing of the audit and significant findings, including significant deficiencies in internal control identified during the work.
Going concern and other information
As part of the audit, the auditor considers the manager’s use of the going-concern basis: whether it is appropriate for preparing the statements and whether audit evidence points to a material uncertainty that could cast significant doubt on a fund’s ability to continue operating. If such an uncertainty exists, the auditor draws attention to the relevant disclosure; if the disclosure is inadequate, the opinion may need to be modified. The assessment is based on evidence available up to the report date, and future events can change an organization’s circumstances.
The report also distinguishes the audited statements from other published material. The funds’ Annual Management Reports on Fund Performance were the manager’s responsibility, but were not covered by the audit opinion. The auditor read that information and considered whether it was materially inconsistent with the audited statements or knowledge obtained during the audit. The report stated that there was nothing to report on this matter.
What the financial statements add to the audit opinion
The statements provide the financial detail behind the opinion. For example, the CC&L Alternative Global Equity Fund reported net assets attributable to holders of redeemable units of $28.2 million at December 31, 2021, compared with $22.5 million a year earlier. Its reported increase in net assets from operations was $6.2 million for 2021. These figures sit alongside disclosures on investments, short positions, contracts, expenses and unit transactions, allowing readers to consider the fund’s position and activity in context.
Figures alone do not explain the audit’s scope or limitations. Readers should distinguish reported results from the auditor’s conclusion, check the reporting period covered, and review the notes and accounting policies as well as the headline statements.
Practical takeaways for decision-makers
The 2021 report demonstrates a useful way to read audited financial information: identify which statements and periods were examined, understand the accounting framework, and note the boundary between management’s responsibilities and the auditor’s work. An audit opinion offers reasonable—not absolute—assurance about fair presentation, and it does not certify the effectiveness of all internal controls or provide assurance on separate management reports.
For technical and operational leaders assessing an organization’s reporting, these distinctions support better questions about evidence, estimates, governance and risk. The practical value of an audit lies not only in its conclusion, but in understanding exactly what that conclusion covers.