Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

A pension compliance audit can find an organization materially compliant overall while still identifying a specific statutory control gap that needs attention. The Illinois Teachers’ Retirement System (TRS) compliance examination for the year ended June 30, 2018, illustrates that distinction. Auditors reported one state compliance finding involving disclosures from investment managers, even as they concluded that TRS complied in all material respects with the requirements examined.

For public funds and other organizations that manage complex investment relationships, the case highlights a practical challenge: a due diligence process must not only request required information, but also establish that disclosures are complete and available before contracts are awarded.

What the pension compliance audit examined

The examination covered requirements related to the use of public funds, compliance with laws and regulations, accounting for state revenues and receipts, and the administration and recordkeeping of assets held for the state or in trust. It was conducted under Government Auditing Standards, the Illinois State Auditing Act and the state Auditor General’s Audit Guide.

The auditors expressed the opinion that TRS complied, in all material respects, with the specified requirements during fiscal 2018. That overall conclusion did not mean every tested procedure was free of exceptions. The report also disclosed one instance of noncompliance that the Audit Guide required auditors to report: incomplete investment-manager disclosures under the Illinois Pension Code.

Investment manager disclosures were incomplete

Illinois Pension Code section 40 ILCS 5/1-113.21 requires investment advisers, consultants and private market funds to provide specified information before an investment-services contract or private-market commitment is awarded. The disclosures include staffing information, such as the number and percentage of investment and senior staff who are minorities, women or people with disabilities. They also cover the number of certain contracts with businesses owned by members of those groups, along with specified contracts with other businesses where more than half of the services are performed by qualifying individuals.

In its testing, the examination found that 10 of 25 investment-manager disclosures returned to TRS—40 percent of the sample—did not properly report the required contract counts. The managers told the System that they did not track all of the requested information. TRS officials said its compliance department checked for required disclosures during due diligence, but some managers could not track or legally provide all information under the statute’s wording.

The auditors’ concern focused on the result: when required information is not obtained before a contract is awarded, the System may not meet the statutory requirement. The finding was not new. The report identified it as repeated from the 2017 and 2016 examinations, making the issue a continuing compliance matter rather than a one-year documentation exception.

Why collection and review controls matter

For organizations subject to statutory disclosure rules, a process that confirms a form was received is not necessarily enough. The finding points to the importance of distinguishing between receipt and completeness, then determining how missing or unavailable information affects the organization’s ability to proceed.

A practical control framework for this type of requirement can include:

  • Clear requirements: Translate statutory language into specific disclosure fields and review criteria.
  • Pre-award checkpoints: Link disclosure review to contract approval so unresolved items are visible before a commitment is made.
  • Exception records: Document incomplete responses, follow-up with managers and the stated reasons information is unavailable.
  • Escalation paths: Define how legal, compliance and investment teams address conflicting interpretations or limits on disclosure.
  • Recurring monitoring: Track repeat exceptions and assess whether process changes have resolved their underlying causes.

These are general control considerations drawn from the nature of the reported finding, not procedures the report says TRS adopted. The auditors recommended that the System work with investment managers to meet the disclosure requirements or seek a legislative remedy.

Management and auditors took different positions

TRS disagreed with the finding and stated that it believed its existing approach complied with the statute and its intent. The System said its interpretation was supported by conversations with the legislation’s Senate sponsor. The auditors, however, concluded that failure to obtain the required disclosures before contract award resulted in noncompliance. This difference underscores why organizations facing ambiguous or difficult-to-satisfy requirements benefit from documented legal analysis, consistent decision records and early resolution of interpretation issues.

The broader audit results provide important context. Auditors reported no internal-control deficiencies they considered material weaknesses in either compliance or financial reporting. Their financial-statement testing also disclosed no matters required to be reported under Government Auditing Standards. Those conclusions are separate from the state compliance finding; they do not negate it.

Practical implications for public-fund governance

The 2018 examination shows that a clean or unmodified financial-statement opinion does not eliminate the need to address specific compliance exceptions. Governance teams should pay particular attention when requirements depend on information supplied by external investment partners. Responsibility for a disclosure may sit with a manager, but the fund still needs a process for assessing whether the information meets its legal and operational requirements.

For boards, compliance leaders and investment teams, the practical takeaway is to make disclosure obligations part of the contract lifecycle. Define what constitutes a complete response, retain evidence of review, escalate barriers before approval and monitor recurring findings. When the organization and auditors interpret a requirement differently, documenting the rationale and pursuing clarification or legislative change may be as important as refining the collection process.

A pension compliance audit is most useful when its findings inform ongoing controls, not just year-end reporting. In this case, the central issue was the gap between requesting investment-manager disclosures and obtaining the information auditors considered necessary before contract awards. Addressing that gap requires coordinated oversight across compliance, legal and investment functions.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author