Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Bare-metal firmware security is a growing concern as connected products place microcontrollers in networked and operational environments. Unlike systems with an operating system that can isolate applications, a bare-metal program typically configures hardware, handles inputs and outputs, and runs application logic with direct access to memory and peripherals. A memory-corruption flaw can therefore reach far beyond one function: it may alter data, redirect control flow, or manipulate hardware registers.

Resource constraints make the problem harder. Microcontrollers may have limited memory and processing capacity, and their software often has strict timing requirements. Security measures must account for those constraints without breaking required behavior. Three complementary approaches address different parts of this challenge: limiting what code can do at runtime, separating software into protected regions, and making firmware easier to test away from its target hardware.

Why bare-metal systems need defense in depth

A buffer overflow or other invalid write can corrupt adjacent memory. If the affected data includes a code pointer, execution may be redirected. If the attacker can write to memory-mapped peripheral registers, the consequences may include unauthorized control of device functions. In a flat execution model, where all application code runs with broad privileges, one vulnerability can put the entire device at risk.

Microcontrollers such as those based on ARMv7-M may provide two useful hardware mechanisms: privileged and unprivileged execution modes, and a Memory Protection Unit (MPU). The MPU can set read, write, and execute permissions on physical memory regions. But hardware features alone are not enough. If application code can freely change the MPU configuration, an attacker who gains a write primitive may disable the protections. Effective defenses need to restrict both memory access and the ability to change security controls.

Privilege overlays limit elevated operations

EPOXY addresses this issue by using static analysis to identify instructions and memory accesses that require elevated privileges. The application runs with reduced privileges by default; a privilege overlay grants elevated access only around operations that need it. This approach is intended to preserve the functionality of bare-metal software while shrinking the amount of code that executes with broad authority.

The compiler-based workflow also applies several protections. These include Data Execution Prevention (DEP), which helps prevent data regions from being executed as code; stack defenses; and diversification of code and data layout. Diversification changes layouts across program variants, making it harder to reuse one discovered code sequence across many devices. EPOXY’s SafeStack adaptation separates variables that cannot be confirmed safe from the ordinary stack.

The significance for engineering teams is that protection can be applied through the build process rather than by requiring developers to redesign application source code. The work evaluated EPOXY on benchmark and IoT applications. For the IoT applications, reported average overhead was 1.8% for execution time and 0.5% for energy. These results describe the evaluated applications and should not be assumed to apply identically to every target or workload.

Automatic compartments add internal boundaries

Privilege overlays focus on which instructions need elevated access. Automatic Compartments for Embedded Systems (ACES) takes a different step: it divides a bare-metal application into compartments and enforces boundaries between them. The aim is to apply the principle of least privilege within a single application, rather than treating the entire program as one trusted unit.

ACES uses program analysis to determine relationships among code and data, then creates compartments according to a developer-specified policy. Its design treats compartment creation as a graph-reduction problem, allowing policies to balance security requirements against runtime and memory costs. During execution, the system restricts access between compartments and controls transitions between them.

This can limit the damage a compromised component can cause. For example, a compartment handling one task need not automatically receive access to every other part of the program’s data and executable code. The reported evaluation showed that ACES could create tens of compartments within a single-threaded bare-metal application, with an average runtime overhead of 15%. As with any isolation design, policy choices and application structure affect the resulting trade-offs.

Firmware re-hosting supports scalable testing

Runtime defenses reduce risk, but testing is also essential for finding vulnerabilities before deployment. Testing firmware directly on physical devices can constrain the number of test instances and make automated analysis difficult. Re-hosting runs firmware in an emulated environment, creating opportunities to use dynamic analysis and techniques such as coverage-guided fuzzing on commodity computers.

The main obstacle is firmware’s dependence on hardware. Startup code may configure clocks, poll hardware status, or interact directly with peripherals such as UARTs, timers, and network interfaces. An emulator that does not model those components accurately may stop during initialization or fail to reach important application logic. Building a complete hardware model for each device can be demanding.

HALucinator addresses this challenge by identifying hardware abstraction libraries in firmware binaries and replacing their functions with higher-level models. Because abstraction libraries provide common interfaces across hardware, modeling those interfaces can reduce the need to reproduce every underlying peripheral in detail. The resulting emulation can support interactive testing and fuzzing. The work reports that fuzzing experiments found vulnerabilities in tested firmware, illustrating the value of re-hosting as a testing method—not a guarantee that emulation will reveal every defect.

Putting the approaches into an engineering strategy

These techniques address related but distinct needs. Privilege overlays restrict elevated execution, compartments limit access among parts of an application, and re-hosting helps teams exercise firmware more extensively during testing. Together, they point toward a practical security workflow:

  • Review the trust model: identify sensitive memory, control operations, and peripheral registers that could affect device behavior.
  • Use hardware protection deliberately: configure MPU permissions and control which code can modify protection settings.
  • Choose boundaries that fit the application: use privilege separation or compartments where they can reduce the authority available to a vulnerable component.
  • Test beyond normal operation: use dynamic analysis and fuzzing to explore inputs and execution paths, including through firmware re-hosting when hardware dependencies can be modeled.

Conclusion

Bare-metal constraints do not make meaningful security protections impossible, but they do require designs that account for direct hardware access, limited resources, and application-specific behavior. Privilege overlays and automatic compartments offer ways to reduce the reach of a memory-corruption flaw, while firmware re-hosting can make deeper automated testing more accessible. For engineering and operations teams, the practical lesson is to combine build-time protections, carefully defined isolation boundaries, and systematic testing rather than relying on any single defense.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author