Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Supply chain resilience became a more urgent concern when the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted access to medical products, restricted cross-border movement and exposed dependence on overseas suppliers. For manufacturers and industrial operations, the episode underscored a practical point: production continuity depends on more than the capacity of an individual plant. It also relies on dependable sources of materials, technology, investment and skilled labor.

In testimony to a U.S. House trade subcommittee in July 2020, Hudson Institute Senior Fellow Thomas J. Duesterberg argued that the pandemic accelerated existing efforts to bring selected production back to the United States. His recommendations focused on critical sectors rather than a broad return of all manufacturing. That distinction offers a useful framework for companies and policymakers considering how to strengthen supply chains without treating reshoring as a one-size-fits-all solution.

Supply chain resilience starts with targeted priorities

Duesterberg identified national defense, medical security and selected technologies as areas where foreign dependence could create serious vulnerabilities. He highlighted specialized, sometimes dual-use technologies connected to fields such as semiconductors, advanced communications, biological products, artificial intelligence and quantum computing.

The underlying lesson for manufacturing decision-makers is to identify which inputs and capabilities are genuinely critical to operations and security. A company does not necessarily need to relocate every supplier or production step. It does need to understand where a disruption could stop production, delay delivery or compromise access to essential technology.

That analysis should include upstream dependencies. A finished product may be assembled domestically while relying on imported chemicals, minerals, components or processing capabilities. Resilience planning is therefore more effective when it maps the supply chain beyond direct suppliers and considers the availability of critical raw materials.

Reshoring requires a competitive production ecosystem

Returning production to domestic locations depends on whether businesses can operate and invest there. Duesterberg pointed to tax and regulatory conditions, research capacity and workforce skills as elements of a stronger industrial ecosystem. For manufacturers, this means reshoring decisions cannot be separated from the practical requirements of building and sustaining production.

The testimony proposed making first-year expensing for capital investment permanent and strengthening access to research and experimentation tax credits, including for small and start-up firms. It also argued for federal support for basic research in science and engineering. These proposals reflect a broader principle: public policy can help create favorable conditions for private-sector investment, while avoiding an approach that attempts to direct commercial development across entire industries.

Research collaboration was another part of the proposed approach. Pre-competitive consortia involving companies, universities and government laboratories can allow participants to share expertise, facilities and other resources. The testimony cited Manufacturing USA and National Science Foundation Industry/University Cooperative Research Centers as programs that support collaborative research, including for smaller firms that may not have the resources for extensive research efforts on their own.

Build options for critical materials and suppliers

Supply chain risk is not limited to finished goods. The testimony drew attention to rare earths and materials used in lithium-ion batteries, including cobalt, lithium, graphite and magnesium-based metals. It described their importance to manufacturing fields such as semiconductors, communications, electric vehicles, computing and energy production, and warned that concentrated foreign sourcing could leave U.S. industries exposed to disruption.

Potential responses included encouraging domestic production and processing, reviewing the time required for mine permitting, and working with allies to secure access to critical minerals. The testimony also emphasized the role of environmental and labor standards when assessing overseas sources.

For industrial organizations, these issues make supplier visibility and sourcing strategy central parts of continuity planning. Understanding where a material originates, what processing it requires and which alternative sources may be available can help clarify exposure. The goal is not simply to replace one foreign source with a domestic one; it is to consider the durability and diversity of the supply base.

Workforce capacity is part of supply chain strategy

Domestic production also depends on finding people with the skills to operate and support advanced manufacturing. Duesterberg emphasized both STEM education and hands-on training, including apprenticeships developed through cooperation between employers and educators. He noted that a proposed production facility can face difficulties if the local workforce does not have the required skills.

For plant managers and system integrators, workforce planning should therefore be considered alongside equipment, facilities and sourcing. Employers can work with community colleges and other educators to connect training with the needs of regional industries. The testimony also called attention to the importance of encouraging participation in STEM fields and expanding opportunities for groups underrepresented in them.

Use trade policy carefully and work with allies

Trade and investment rules can influence where companies produce and how technology moves across borders. Duesterberg described trade measures as potential tools against practices such as dumping, unfair subsidies and improper acquisition of intellectual property. He also argued that international trade rules needed reform to address gaps in transparency, subsidies and technology transfer.

At the same time, the testimony cautioned against broad industrial policies and escalating subsidy competition. It made the case for cooperating with allies where possible, particularly on defense, medical security and critical materials. For manufacturers, this points toward a balanced approach: assess risks across the supplier network, consider trusted partners, and account for the effects of policy changes on sourcing and investment decisions.

Conclusion: resilience is a system-wide capability

The pandemic-era debate over reshoring showed that supply chain resilience cannot be achieved through location decisions alone. It depends on targeted priorities, reliable access to materials, investment in research, a competitive environment for production and a workforce equipped with relevant skills. Manufacturers can apply these principles by identifying critical dependencies and evaluating the capabilities needed to sustain production when supply conditions change. The objective is not to eliminate every external dependency, but to make essential supply chains more dependable and better prepared for disruption.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author