China A-share ETFs can provide distinct types of exposure to mainland Chinese companies, depending on the index each fund tracks and how it holds securities. A semi-annual report for four Xtrackers funds, dated November 30, 2023, illustrates the differences: one fund focuses on larger A-share companies, another on smaller companies, while two offer broader China equity strategies. The portfolio data also highlights how sector mix and fund-of-funds structures can affect what investors are actually exposed to.
China A-share ETFs: four different approaches
All four funds described in the report use a passive or indexing approach, seeking results that generally correspond to an underlying index before fees and expenses. An index itself cannot be purchased directly, so an ETF provides an investment vehicle designed to track the specified benchmark.
- ASHR tracks the CSI 300 Index, which represents 300 of the largest and most liquid stocks in China’s A-share market.
- ASHS tracks the CSI 500 Index, comprising 500 of the smaller and most liquid A-share stocks.
- CN tracks the MSCI China All Shares Index, covering large- and mid-cap companies across securities listed in Hong Kong, Shanghai and Shenzhen, as well as specified share classes and Chinese companies listed outside China.
- ASHX tracks the MSCI China A Inclusion Index, focused on A-shares accessible through the Shanghai-Hong Kong or Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock Connect programs.
This range matters when comparing funds: “China equity” does not identify one uniform market segment. The benchmarks differ in company size, listing venue and share-class coverage.
Holdings and sector allocation shape exposure
The November 30 portfolio summaries show different concentrations among the funds. ASHR’s ten largest equity holdings represented 22.0% of net assets. Its largest holding, Kweichow Moutai, accounted for 6.5%. Financials were its largest sector allocation at 22.2% of total investments, followed by information technology at 15.5% and industrials at 15.3%.
ASHS had a more dispersed top-ten list: those holdings represented 5.5% of net assets, with the largest individual position at 1.0%. Its sector allocations were led by materials at 20.3% and information technology at 20.2%, followed by industrials at 15.1%. The contrast with ASHR reflects the different index construction and company-size focus; it should not be read as a guarantee of future sector or security weights.
ASHX also held a broad portfolio of A-shares. Its ten largest equity holdings represented 17.3% of net assets, with Kweichow Moutai at 6.0%. Financials made up 18.5% of investments, while information technology, consumer staples and industrials each represented roughly 15%.
CN had a different structure. Its largest position was ASHX, at 45.7% of net assets, alongside direct holdings such as Tencent Holdings and Alibaba Group. Its reported ten largest equity and ETF holdings accounted for 72.8% of net assets. CN’s sector allocation included consumer discretionary at 20.4%, financials at 16.3% and communication services at 13.6%. The sector figures included allocations from certain underlying funds, so the fund’s exposure cannot be understood solely by reviewing its direct company positions.
Look through fund structure and expense disclosures
CN expected to obtain exposure to A-share components indirectly by investing in ASHX. It could also invest in ASHR, ASHS or other affiliated funds. This creates a fund-of-funds element: an investor in CN may bear expenses associated with the underlying ETFs in addition to CN’s own direct expenses. The report states that the underlying funds’ expenses were not included in CN’s annualized expense ratio used for the expense example.
For the six-month period from June 1 to November 30, 2023, the report listed annualized expense ratios of 0.65% for ASHR, 0.65% for ASHS, 0.20% for CN and 0.60% for ASHX. It also noted that CN and ASHX limited expenses during the period. These figures do not capture every ownership cost: brokerage commissions and other transaction costs are separate, and CN’s stated ratio excludes indirect underlying-fund expenses.
The report’s expense examples use a $1,000 investment and distinguish actual results from a hypothetical 5% annual return before expenses. The hypothetical scenario is for comparison, not a statement of actual fund performance. For a complete cost comparison, investors need to consider the fund’s structure and relevant transaction costs alongside its stated expense ratio.
How to use the portfolio data
For technical decision-makers assessing market exposure, the practical lesson is to compare the benchmark and holdings rather than relying on a fund’s name alone. A useful review should include:
- Which market segment the index covers, including company size and listing location.
- Whether exposure is held directly or through another ETF.
- How concentrated the largest holdings are and which sectors dominate.
- What the reported expense ratio includes, and which costs sit outside it.
These details are a snapshot, not permanent fund characteristics. The report explicitly states that holdings and portfolio characteristics may change. Its figures are dated November 30, 2023 and should not be treated as current portfolio data or investment recommendations.
Conclusion
The four China A-share ETFs represent meaningfully different routes into Chinese equities: large-cap A-shares, smaller A-shares, a wider mix of China-listed securities, and Stock Connect-accessible A-shares. Comparing index scope, sector allocation, top holdings and indirect expenses helps clarify those differences. For any allocation decision, the key is to assess the exposure and costs the fund actually delivers, while recognizing that portfolio weights can change over time.