Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Coal and natural gas power generation were changing roles in North Carolina’s electricity system. By 2018, coal capacity and output had fallen from earlier levels, while natural gas combined-cycle plants had become a major source of electricity. For plant operators, system integrators, and energy decision-makers, this shift was not simply a change in fuel. It also affected how generating assets were dispatched, how the grid balanced changing demand, and how utilities assessed existing plants and future investment.

From coal-led generation to a changing resource mix

At the start of the 2000s, coal supplied about 62% of electricity generation in North Carolina. Coal generation peaked at 76.6 million megawatt-hours in 2007, then declined to 31.4 million megawatt-hours in 2018, or about 24% of state generation. Over the same period, coal capacity fell from 13,296 MW in 2000 to 10,318 MW in 2018, as older units retired and all four independent power producer coal plants stopped operating or changed fuels.

Natural gas followed a different trajectory. North Carolina had about 3,300 MW of gas-fired capacity in 2000, mostly simple-cycle combustion turbines. New combined-cycle capacity began to grow more rapidly from 2011. By 2018, the state had approximately 11,000 MW of natural gas power plants, split roughly evenly between combined-cycle units and combustion turbines.

Capacity and generation measure different things. Capacity describes a plant’s potential output, while generation reflects how much electricity it actually produces over time. In 2018, natural gas plants generated almost 44 million MWh in North Carolina, compared with 31.4 million MWh from coal. Combined-cycle units supplied about 80% of the natural gas generation, despite a capacity mix that also included substantial combustion-turbine capability.

How plant technology shapes dispatch

Combined cycle and simple cycle

A simple-cycle gas turbine burns fuel to drive a turbine connected to a generator. In a natural gas combined-cycle (NGCC) plant, the hot exhaust from the gas turbine is captured in a heat recovery steam generator. The resulting steam drives a second turbine, producing additional electricity from heat that would otherwise leave through the stack.

This second cycle helps explain why NGCC plants can produce more electricity from their fuel than simple-cycle turbines. In the source’s 2017 comparison, the average heat rate for U.S. combined-cycle plants corresponded to an efficiency of about 44.6%, while simple-cycle combustion turbines averaged about 29%. Simple-cycle units nevertheless serve an important operational role: they are commonly used as peaking plants, while combined-cycle plants can run for longer periods and serve baseload demand.

Coal steam plants also use a turbine-generator arrangement, but burn pulverized coal in a boiler to create steam. Their operating pattern has changed as the resource mix evolved. North Carolina’s remaining coal fleet included units used for baseload generation as well as intermediate and peaking operation. The source reports that 3,209 MW of Duke Energy coal capacity was operating as intermediate units and 1,679 MW as peaking units, based on annual capacity and operating-hour factors.

Flexibility becomes more important

Dispatch is shaped not only by a plant’s capacity, but also by its cost, efficiency, operating characteristics, and role in meeting demand. Coal plants can provide dependable output and historically operated at high capacity factors, but their ramp-up times can be lengthy. The source describes a typical coal start-up to full capacity as taking around 24 hours, with faster techniques potentially reducing that time while increasing thermal and pressure stress on plant components.

Gas plants can generally respond more quickly. NGCC units take several hours to reach full load, and gas turbines can adjust output to follow demand. This flexibility becomes useful when the system must accommodate variable generation from wind and solar or changing electricity demand. It does not remove the need for grid planning, but it gives operators another dispatchable resource to manage short-term variation.

Co-firing was another approach to adapting existing coal assets. Duke Energy was modifying units at Cliffside, Belews Creek, and Marshall to allow natural gas to be fired alongside coal, or in some cases across a broader range of fuel mixes. The reported projects involved substantial retrofit costs, and gas firing was estimated to create about a 5% heat-rate penalty in the affected plants. Co-firing could reduce coal use while retaining use of existing boiler equipment; it was not equivalent to building a new NGCC facility.

Environmental and infrastructure considerations

Fuel choice also has consequences for emissions, water use, and plant operations. The whitepaper reports that natural gas combustion produces lower amounts of several air pollutants than coal combustion and about 40% less carbon dioxide per unit of energy produced. It also notes that methane emissions can occur during gas extraction, processing, and transmission, making the broader fuel supply chain part of the environmental discussion.

Coal plants have additional management requirements associated with coal combustion residuals, air-pollution-control systems, and wastewater. Their cooling requirements can also be significant. Natural gas plants generally use less water than traditional coal plants, although combined-cycle facilities still need water for steam production and cooling. Siting a gas plant also depends on access to a natural gas pipeline and, for steam and cooling needs, a freshwater source.

Planning for the transition

The North Carolina outlook described in the 2019 plan anticipated further coal retirements and additional natural gas capacity. Duke Energy had announced the retirement of five coal boiler units at Asheville and GG Allen by 2025, representing 961 MW. The plan also identified projected NGCC and combustion-turbine additions, while noting that some integrated resource plan projections covered both North Carolina and South Carolina and did not assign every future addition to a specific state.

These projections were planning assumptions, not guarantees of future construction or dispatch. They illustrate why technical decision-makers need to consider more than nameplate capacity: unit age, fuel access, operating flexibility, emissions controls, water requirements, retrofit costs, and decommissioning obligations can all affect the practical role of an asset.

Conclusion

North Carolina’s experience shows how changes in fuel economics, plant performance, and operating needs can reshape an electricity fleet. Coal generation declined as units retired or ran less, while NGCC plants expanded and gas turbines provided flexible capacity. For industrial and energy leaders, the practical lesson is to assess generation resources as part of an integrated system: compare how they operate, what infrastructure they require, and how their costs and constraints affect reliability and long-term planning.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author