Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Critical minerals and bulk materials are an often-overlooked part of energy transition planning. Wind turbines, solar panels, batteries and electric vehicles depend on minerals extracted from the earth, then processed and manufactured into equipment. For industrial automation engineers, plant managers and energy decision-makers, that upstream reality matters: energy technologies bring different material requirements, sourcing dependencies and end-of-life challenges.

A 2020 report by Mark P. Mills argues that, compared with hydrocarbon-based energy systems, some green energy technologies require substantially more material to deliver equivalent energy. The precise comparison depends on the technology, assumptions and system boundaries. But the report’s central operational point is clear: evaluating energy infrastructure requires looking beyond installed equipment to include mining, processing, transport, supply security and disposal.

Critical minerals in the energy transition supply chain

Energy-producing equipment is built from both common materials—such as steel, concrete and glass—and more specialized minerals. Batteries, electric motors and wind turbine electrical systems may use lithium, cobalt, nickel, copper and rare earth elements. Solar technologies also rely on specific materials, including indium in some semiconductor applications.

These materials move through a multistage supply chain: extraction, ore processing, refining, component production and equipment manufacturing. A constraint or disruption at any stage can affect access to finished components. The report highlights that mineral production and refining are geographically concentrated for some materials, creating potential exposure to import dependence and geopolitical risk.

Material demand also reflects more than the weight of the finished equipment. Mineral concentrations in ore can be low, and mining may require removing overburden—the soil and rock above an ore deposit—before processing begins. The quantity of earth moved varies with the mineral, deposit and location. For engineers and planners, this is why a component-level bill of materials does not describe the full physical footprint of its supply chain.

Why material intensity matters for infrastructure planning

Wind and solar installations capture energy from diffuse, variable sources. Where a project must provide electricity when sunlight or wind is unavailable, the broader system may also require additional generation capacity, storage or other supporting infrastructure. Those choices affect the total amount and types of materials required.

The report uses a 100-megawatt natural gas turbine as a comparison point, estimating that matching its output with wind requires multiple turbines and a larger land footprint. It also describes substantial requirements for concrete, steel and fiberglass in wind installations. These figures are specific to the report’s assumptions; they should not be treated as universal design values. Project-level assessments need to account for site conditions, technology selection and the intended reliability of the system.

Material production has energy requirements of its own. Mining equipment consumes fuel, while crushing, separating and refining ores require energy and, in some cases, chemicals. Manufacturing steel, glass, concrete and battery components also contributes to the embodied energy of equipment. Consequently, an energy system’s resource profile includes not only the energy it produces or stores, but also the inputs needed to build and maintain it.

Recycling helps, but does not remove sourcing needs

Recycling can recover useful materials, particularly when valuable metals are present. However, the report cautions against assuming that all energy equipment can be recycled economically or at high rates. Products contain mixtures of materials that can be difficult to separate, and low concentrations can make recovery challenging. Wind turbine blades, for example, use reinforced composite materials that the report describes as difficult to recycle.

Equipment lifetimes also mean that end-of-life volumes grow over time as successive generations of installations reach retirement. Batteries, solar panels and turbine components therefore create planning needs for collection, dismantling, processing and disposal. Recycling may supplement primary mineral supply, but the report argues it cannot be assumed to eliminate the need for new mining.

For industrial operators and system integrators, this distinction supports practical questions during procurement and project design:

  • Which materials are essential to the selected equipment and its supporting systems?
  • Where are those materials mined, refined and manufactured?
  • What sourcing or import dependencies could affect project schedules or long-term availability?
  • What end-of-life pathways exist for batteries, panels, blades and other major components?

Supply security is a planning issue, not just a mining issue

The report notes that the United States has become dependent on imports for some minerals and relies on imports for a significant share of its needs for others. It describes domestic mining as one possible response to supply exposure, alongside accepting import dependence or limiting the scale of new demand. Each approach involves trade-offs, including access to resources, permitting and the environmental and labor conditions associated with extraction.

For energy and automation projects, supply-chain resilience is therefore broader than identifying a preferred technology. It includes understanding the origin and processing of critical inputs, considering supplier and material alternatives where feasible, and accounting for the resources required throughout an asset’s lifecycle. The source does not present recycling or digital services as a complete substitute for this assessment.

Conclusion: include materials in energy decisions

Energy infrastructure depends on physical materials, and changing the mix of generation and storage technologies changes the materials and supply chains involved. The report’s message for technical decision-makers is not that one technology choice resolves every challenge, but that responsible planning should include mineral demand, embodied energy, sourcing risks and end-of-life management. Bringing those factors into project evaluation can help organizations make more informed decisions about equipment, procurement and the long-term resilience of energy systems.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author