Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

The proposed CSG Fuji Xerox acquisition illustrates how a public-company takeover structured as a scheme of arrangement moves through disclosure, shareholder voting and court review. In December 2019, CSG Limited announced that the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) had registered the scheme booklet for Fuji Xerox Asia Pacific Pte Ltd’s proposed acquisition of all CSG shares. The announcement set out the proposed cash payment, the approvals required and the timetable then expected for the transaction.

How the CSG Fuji Xerox acquisition was structured

Rather than proceeding through individual share purchases, the proposal used a scheme of arrangement: a formal arrangement between CSG and its shareholders under which Fuji Xerox Asia Pacific would acquire all CSG shares if the required conditions were met. The proposed result was for Fuji Xerox Asia Pacific to obtain 100% ownership and control of CSG.

The scheme was conditional on approval by CSG shareholders and the court, along with satisfaction or waiver, where permitted, of other conditions precedent. ASIC’s registration of the scheme booklet enabled the document to be sent to shareholders, but it did not itself approve the transaction. The booklet explained the proposal and the voting process; the shareholder decision and the court’s later consideration remained separate steps.

The New South Wales Supreme Court had ordered CSG to convene a shareholder meeting and dispatch the booklet. The company said the booklet, including the meeting notice, proxy form and independent expert’s report, would be sent to shareholders by 23 December 2019. The court order to convene the meeting was not an endorsement of the scheme’s merits or a direction about how shareholders should vote.

Cash consideration and the independent assessment

If the scheme became effective, eligible shareholders were to receive $0.31 in cash for each CSG share. The expected payment date, described as the implementation date, was 19 February 2020. These were proposed terms and dates in the December 2019 announcement, dependent on the required approvals and conditions.

CSG reported that the independent expert, Lonergan Edwards & Associates Limited, assessed the value of CSG shares on a 100% controlling-interest basis at between $0.27 and $0.30 per share. The expert concluded that the scheme was fair and reasonable and in shareholders’ best interests in the absence of a superior proposal. The proposed $0.31 consideration was above that assessed range.

The booklet also compared the offer with historical trading prices before the transaction announcement. It stated that $0.31 represented premiums of 31.9% to the 23 October 2019 closing price of $0.235, 35.4% to the one-month volume-weighted average price (VWAP) of $0.229, and 55.2% to a VWAP of $0.200 measured from the announcement of CSG’s FY19 results to 23 October 2019. These comparisons were presented as part of the board’s case for the proposal, not as a prediction of future share prices.

Shareholder vote and court process

The scheme meeting was scheduled for 3 February 2020. For the resolution to pass, it required both at least 75% of the votes cast and approval by a majority in number of shareholders present and voting. Shareholders could vote in person or appoint a proxy, attorney or corporate representative. Proxy forms had to reach the share registry by 5.00pm Sydney time on 31 January 2020.

If shareholders approved the scheme, the company expected to return to the New South Wales Supreme Court for a second hearing on 5 February 2020. The court would consider whether to approve the scheme following the vote. The timetable also anticipated lodgement of court orders with ASIC and suspension of CSG share trading on that date, followed by a record date on 12 February and payment on 19 February. The booklet cautioned that dates were indicative and could change.

Reasons shareholders might weigh the proposal differently

CSG’s directors unanimously recommended voting in favour, subject to no superior proposal emerging and the independent expert continuing to support its conclusion. The recommendation reflected, among other factors, the cash offer, its premium to selected historical prices and the certainty of receiving cash if the scheme was implemented. The board also cited the risks and uncertainties of continuing to hold shares while CSG pursued its transformation and growth strategy.

The booklet also identified reasons a shareholder might vote against the proposal. These included wanting to participate in CSG’s future performance, believing its strategic options could create greater value, preferring to retain the investment’s existing risk and liquidity characteristics, or anticipating a more attractive competing offer. Tax consequences could also differ between shareholders, so the booklet advised readers to consider their own circumstances and seek professional advice where appropriate.

CSG said no superior proposal had emerged by the time of the announcement. Its largest shareholder, Caledonia (Private) Investments Pty Limited and its associates, which held approximately 29.1% of shares, had indicated an intention to vote in favour, subject to stated conditions. That intention did not replace the need for the wider shareholder vote or court approval.

Practical implications of a scheme process

The proposed transaction shows why registration of a scheme booklet should be understood as one milestone in a longer approval process, not as confirmation that a takeover is complete. Shareholders were asked to review the terms, expert opinion, risks, voting requirements and timetable before deciding. If the scheme received the required approvals and conditions were met, shares would transfer and shareholders would receive the cash consideration. If it did not proceed, shareholders would retain their CSG shares and remain exposed to the company’s ongoing risks and opportunities.

For technical decision-makers following corporate changes involving suppliers, service providers or other business partners, the practical lesson is to distinguish announced proposals from completed transactions. The transaction’s status depends on its conditions and approval steps; the scheme booklet and formal company announcements provide the relevant basis for understanding those steps.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author