Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

A U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) opinion on solid-state drives clarified an important issue for companies involved in patent disputes: the domestic industry requirement does not limit qualifying U.S. investment to manufacturing. Engineering, research and development (R&D), and other technical work may also contribute under certain parts of the statute, provided the activities and expenditures meet the relevant legal criteria and relate to the products at issue.

For industrial technology companies, the decision highlights two practical points. First, U.S. engineering and product-support operations can matter in a Section 337 investigation even when they are not production-line activities. Second, those investments must be documented and allocated in a way that connects them to the products identified in the case.

What the domestic industry requirement tests

Section 337 of the Tariff Act allows the ITC to investigate certain imports alleged to infringe intellectual property rights. A complainant must establish both a technical prong and an economic prong to show that a relevant domestic industry exists. The technical prong concerns whether the domestic industry products practice the asserted patent. The economic prong concerns qualifying U.S. investments and activities.

The statute identifies three routes for meeting the economic prong. A domestic industry may be supported by significant investment in plant and equipment under subsection (A), significant employment of labor or capital under subsection (B), or substantial investment in exploitation of the intellectual property under subsection (C). These criteria are stated in the alternative, so a complainant need not satisfy all three.

Engineering and R&D are not confined to subsection (C)

The Commission rejected the view that subsections (A) and (B) cover manufacturing alone. Although subsection (C) expressly refers to engineering and R&D as examples of investment in intellectual-property exploitation, the Commission found that this wording does not exclude engineering or R&D expenditures from the other subsections.

Under subsections (A) and (B), the central question is whether the investment in plant and equipment, or the employment of labor or capital, is with respect to the articles protected by the patent. The Commission explained that this does not require the additional showing associated with subsection (C): a connection between the investment and exploitation of the asserted patent itself.

This distinction matters for companies whose U.S. contributions include product development, engineering support, testing, integration, repair, or technical customer work. Such activities are not automatically qualifying investments. However, they should not be dismissed simply because they do not involve manufacturing. The statutory basis and the connection to the relevant products matter.

How the Altima I evidence supported the finding

BiTMICRO relied on U.S. activities conducted by its licensee, BiTMICRO Networks, Inc. (BNI), relating to the Altima I solid-state drive. BNI carried out design, development, manufacturing, assembly, testing, and support activities at its Fremont, California headquarters, with some manufacturing stages performed by U.S. contract manufacturers.

The Commission affirmed that the evidence supported the economic prong for three asserted patents. Its analysis considered both plant and equipment expenses and labor-related investments. The record included a dedicated manufacturing area, office space used for engineering work, employee activities, contract labor, and specialized services performed by U.S. contract manufacturers.

A key issue was how reliably BNI had allocated shared facilities and employee time to Altima I. The Commission accepted estimates based on testimony about where employees worked and how much time they spent on the product. It noted that the estimates were supported by facility maps, employee testimony, and other evidence. The decision did not establish that estimates will always be sufficient; it assessed whether the allocation methods in this record were reasonable and credible.

The Commission also distinguished specialized contract services from purchases of ordinary, off-the-shelf components. The contract employees and manufacturers performed work connected to producing the drives, and the record included evidence about the services and related payments. That distinction illustrates why a company should be prepared to show what a supplier or contractor actually did—not merely the amount paid.

Why the ACE II record was different

BiTMICRO also relied on U.S. project management and production-integration activities associated with its ACE II drive. However, the product was manufactured, assembled, and tested entirely at a subsidiary in the Philippines and was still in the early stages of commercialization. The Commission did not find the economic prong satisfied for the patent associated with ACE II.

The contrast with Altima I underscores that describing U.S. oversight or project activity is not enough on its own. The evidence must support qualifying investments tied to the relevant domestic industry product. The Commission’s overall conclusion was that BiTMICRO satisfied the economic prong for the ‘243, ‘103, and ‘416 patents, but not for the ‘190 patent. The investigation was terminated with a finding of no Section 337 violation with respect to the ‘190 patent.

Documentation implications for engineering and operations teams

For companies developing or supporting products in the United States, the decision makes recordkeeping an operational issue as well as a legal one. Useful evidence may include:

  • Facility records: floor plans, equipment lists, and explanations of how space and equipment are used for specific products.
  • Labor records: employee roles, technical activities, time allocations, and the basis for estimates where precise tracking is unavailable.
  • Contractor documentation: statements of work, invoices, purchase orders, and descriptions of specialized services performed in the United States.
  • Allocation methods: clear explanations for dividing shared costs among products, periods, facilities, or activities.
  • Product linkage: evidence showing how the claimed U.S. work relates to the domestic industry products identified in the investigation.

These records should distinguish technical work from activities that may not independently establish the economic prong. They should also make the allocation method transparent enough to evaluate, particularly when facilities, employees, or suppliers support multiple products.

Practical takeaway

The ITC’s opinion takes a broad view of the types of U.S. activity that can support the economic prong: qualifying investment is not limited to manufacturing, and engineering or R&D may be considered under subsections (A) and (B). But the outcome remains evidence-dependent. Industrial technology companies should track domestic facilities, technical labor, and specialized supplier work at a product level, while documenting how shared resources are allocated. In a Section 337 investigation, a credible account of what happens in the United States—and how it relates to the products at issue—can be as important as the activities themselves.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author