Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Electron spin resonance (ESR) can help characterize magnetic interactions in layered materials by tracking how an unpaired electron responds to a magnetic field. In bulk single crystals of CrI3 and CrCl3, measurements across a wide temperature range reveal differences in high-temperature signal behavior and provide evidence of magnetic correlations above CrCl3’s long-range ordering temperature. These findings are relevant to understanding van der Waals magnets being investigated for future electronic and spintronic devices.

Why study ESR in layered magnetic materials?

CrI3 and CrCl3 are transition metal halides made up of layers held together by weak van der Waals forces. Their layered structures make them cleavable down to very thin flakes, where magnetic behavior can differ from that of bulk material. Both compounds contain Cr3+ ions arranged in a honeycomb network within octahedra formed by halogen atoms.

The compounds have different magnetic ordering. CrI3 is ferromagnetic, with a Curie temperature of 61 K. CrCl3 is ferromagnetic within its layers but antiferromagnetic between layers, with a Néel temperature near 17 K. Their behavior depends on interactions within and between layers, as well as magnetic anisotropy.

ESR spectroscopy detects the response of unpaired spins to an applied magnetic field. Two useful features of an ESR signal are its linewidth, which reflects interactions between spins and their local environment, and its g-value, which provides information about the electron’s environment and the influence of spin-orbit coupling. Following these features as temperature changes can reveal changes in magnetic correlations.

CrCl3 magnetic properties across temperature ranges

Measurements of CrCl3 at 9.45 GHz found a Lorentzian ESR signal at 300 K, with a g-value of 1.986 and a peak-to-peak linewidth of 131 G. The signal retained its shape as the sample was heated to 500 K, while the linewidth increased to 146 G. Its intensity decreased with temperature, but the signal remained detectable throughout the measured range.

The gradual broadening may be associated with phonon modulation of the Dzyaloshinskii–Moriya antisymmetric exchange interaction between antiferromagnetically coupled spins. This interpretation connects the measured linewidth to the way lattice vibrations can influence magnetic interactions; the reported measurements do not establish a single cause for the broadening.

Evidence of correlations above the ordering temperature

To examine CrCl3 closer to its magnetic transition, ESR measurements were also made at 120 GHz between 5 and 289 K. From 289 K down to about 40 K, the spectra showed a single Lorentzian signal with a g-value of 1.98 and a linewidth of 15 G. On cooling below approximately 40 K, additional signals appeared.

This change occurs above the long-range antiferromagnetic ordering temperature of about 17 K. ESR can detect ferromagnetic correlations before a material develops long-range magnetic order. The additional signals are consistent with local magnetic inhomogeneity associated with those correlations; the researchers ruled out magnetocrystalline anisotropy as the likely explanation in this case.

The linewidth and g-value of the tracked signal also changed around 40 K. As the sample cooled, the linewidth first increased and then began to decrease near that temperature, while the g-value fell sharply. These changes may reflect developing internal magnetic fields and evolving magnetic correlations. Together, they point to in-plane ferromagnetic behavior emerging above the temperature at which long-range antiferromagnetic order is established.

CrI3 shows a different high-temperature ESR response

At 9.45 GHz, CrI3 produced a broad ESR signal at 300 K, with a g-value of 1.986 and a linewidth of 550 G. As temperature rose, the signal broadened substantially, reaching about 1,250 G at 450 K, and its intensity declined. Above 450 K, it either disappeared or broadened beyond the detection limit of the X-band measurement.

In comparison, the room-temperature CrCl3 signal was narrower. The difference is consistent with distinct strengths of magnetic interactions in the two materials, including effects associated with the halide ion and spin-orbit coupling. The measurements show different ESR responses; they do not, by themselves, identify every mechanism behind that contrast.

Environmental sensitivity is also a consideration when interpreting the CrI3 result. CrI3 is more air-sensitive than CrCl3, and exposure to small amounts of oxygen or water at elevated temperature could affect the crystal or its ESR signal. A possible reaction with the nitrogen used during high-temperature measurements was also raised, but was not established. The high-temperature signal loss therefore requires further investigation.

What the measurements mean for materials research

The study demonstrates how ESR at different microwave frequencies can provide complementary views of magnetic behavior. X-band measurements tracked the high-temperature signals of both crystals, while 120-GHz measurements revealed changes in CrCl3 as it cooled toward its antiferromagnetic transition. Signal shape, linewidth, intensity and g-value each offer information about different aspects of the magnetic environment.

For engineers and technical decision-makers following emerging materials, the practical takeaway is not an immediate device specification. Rather, these measurements help characterize the underlying magnetic interactions that must be understood before layered magnets can be assessed for electronic applications. Their potential relevance to spintronic and magnetoelectronic devices depends on controlling and measuring magnetic behavior at reduced dimensions, while accounting for temperature and environmental sensitivity.

Conclusion

ESR measurements distinguish the temperature-dependent magnetic signatures of CrI3 and CrCl3. CrCl3 retains a detectable signal to 500 K and shows evidence of ferromagnetic correlations around 40 K, above its approximately 17 K antiferromagnetic ordering temperature. CrI3’s signal broadens and becomes undetectable above about 450 K under the reported measurement conditions, with environmental effects remaining a possible factor. Together, the results show how ESR can help map magnetic interactions in layered materials and support their evaluation for future device research.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author