Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Index fund tracking error is one measure of how consistently a fund’s returns follow its benchmark. The 2017 annual report for Legal & General ICAV illustrates why that measure should be read alongside tracking difference, index changes and portfolio activity. Although the report covers investment funds rather than industrial automation, its detailed account of benchmark-based portfolio management provides a clear case study in how an index strategy is monitored and maintained.

The report covers the year ended 31 December 2017. It describes a range of funds, including North American, European and Asia-Pacific equity index funds, as well as bond and diversified strategies. The index funds aimed to reflect specified benchmarks, while the diversified funds combined exposures across several asset classes. Understanding the distinctions between these approaches helps readers interpret the performance figures and management activity presented in the report.

Index fund tracking error and tracking difference are not the same

The report defines tracking error as the volatility of the differences between a fund’s returns and those of its benchmark. It is calculated using monthly returns and expressed as an annualized measure. In practical terms, it describes how much the gap between fund and index returns varies over time, taking into account factors such as charges and taxation.

Tracking difference, by contrast, is the difference in return over a particular period. It answers a simpler question: how far apart were the fund’s and benchmark’s reported returns for that review period? A positive or negative tracking difference does not, by itself, describe how variable that gap was month to month.

For the year under review, the North American Equity Index Fund returned 21.21%, compared with 20.89% for the MSCI North American Index—a tracking difference of +0.32%. The fund’s annualized tracking error for the review period was 0.02%, the same as its figure since launch. The report states that both tracking error figures were within the prospectus’s anticipated range of plus or minus 0.20% per annum.

The Europe excluding UK Equity Index Fund returned 11.75%, compared with 11.40% for its benchmark, a +0.35% tracking difference. Its annualized tracking error was 0.03% for the review period and since launch. These examples show why the two measures are complementary: one reports the return gap, while the other describes its volatility.

Index fund rebalancing responds to benchmark changes

Following an index is not simply a matter of holding the same securities indefinitely. Index providers review their benchmarks, and changes to membership or constituent weights can lead to portfolio transactions. The report documents additions, deletions and changes to free share capital across several scheduled reviews during 2017.

For the North American fund, the year included quarterly and semi-annual index reviews. The February review involved one addition and two deletions, while the May review included 23 additions and 10 deletions. Later reviews also changed the index composition. The report records two-way index turnover of 1.4% in February and 2.4% in May, with further turnover in August and November.

The Europe excluding UK fund had two semi-annual reviews. In May, five securities were added and four removed; in November, 13 were added and six removed. The report also describes company acquisitions and share placements that affected index membership or constituent weights. Such events demonstrate that index maintenance can involve both scheduled reviews and changes arising from corporate activity.

For a portfolio designed to track an index, these changes create practical implementation requirements. The report explains what changed and gives turnover figures, but it does not attribute every performance difference to a particular transaction or cause. That distinction matters when interpreting an annual report: documented portfolio activity is not necessarily a complete explanation of relative performance.

Portfolio adjustments differ across fund strategies

The report also separates index strategies from actively adjusted, diversified allocations. The diversified EUR and USD funds used a mix of collective investment schemes, securities and derivatives to obtain exposure to equities, credit, commodities, real estate and other asset classes. Their holdings and target allocations did not follow a single equity benchmark in the same way as the index funds.

During 2017, the Diversified EUR Fund added exposure to euro-denominated listed property, funded predominantly by reducing global property exposure. Both diversified funds were rebalanced in response to market movements and fund flows. The Multi-Index EUR funds also changed allocations among equities, bonds, currencies and other exposures. Examples in the report include adjustments to high-yield bonds, government bonds and currency hedges.

These decisions help explain why a diversified fund may not match an equity index during a strong equity market. The report explicitly notes that the diversified funds’ asset allocation was not intended to match equity returns during an extended rally. Their composition included assets beyond equities, and their reported results therefore need to be understood in the context of their broader strategies.

What to look for when reviewing fund performance

For technical and financial decision-makers evaluating a benchmark-based strategy, the report suggests several useful distinctions to keep in view:

  • Benchmark return: the performance of the index the fund is designed to follow.
  • Fund return: the result achieved by the portfolio over the stated period.
  • Tracking difference: the gap between those two returns for that period.
  • Tracking error: the volatility of the return differences over time.
  • Portfolio activity: index reviews, corporate events and allocation changes that may alter holdings.

These measures answer different questions. Reading them together gives a more complete view than relying on a single annual return or a single tracking statistic. It also helps prevent a short-term difference from being mistaken for evidence about the consistency of tracking over a longer series.

Conclusion: interpret tracking measures in context

The 2017 Legal & General ICAV report shows that benchmark performance, portfolio returns and the management of index changes are connected but distinct parts of fund oversight. Tracking difference records the period’s return gap; tracking error measures how variable that gap was. Index reviews and corporate events can change holdings, while diversified strategies may adjust exposure for reasons beyond following a single benchmark.

The practical takeaway is to assess performance using the benchmark, the relevant time period, both tracking measures and the portfolio activity described in the report. That approach offers a more precise understanding of what an index fund did—and what its reported tracking statistics do and do not establish.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author