Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Integrated resource planning helps utilities determine how to meet future electricity demand while balancing reliability, cost and environmental objectives. Portland General Electric’s 2019 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) offers a detailed example of this process: rather than relying on a single forecast or resource type, it evaluated different futures and assembled a portfolio of near-term actions that could adapt as conditions changed.

For industrial automation engineers, system integrators and energy decision-makers, the plan’s central lesson is that generation is only one part of resource adequacy. Energy efficiency, demand response, customer-sited technologies, storage and access to existing regional capacity can all influence how much new supply a utility needs.

Why PGE used a portfolio approach

PGE developed the plan amid changes in customer expectations, clean-energy policy, technology costs and the regional electricity market. At the same time, the utility anticipated new capacity needs in the mid-2020s, including the effect of expiring regional resource contracts and coal-plant retirements. Those pressures made it difficult to treat a single long-term forecast as certain.

The IRP therefore tested 43 portfolios against varied assumptions about load, market prices, technology costs and other uncertainties. Its planning themes included decarbonization, customer decisions, flexibility and optionality. In practice, optionality meant taking measured steps while retaining room to adjust procurement as forecasts and resource economics evolved.

The plan also reflected a public process. PGE solicited stakeholder input, shared draft analysis and considered requested portfolio designs. That engagement helped inform the analysis and reinforced the importance of making planning assumptions and trade-offs visible to affected customers and stakeholders.

Integrated resource planning puts demand-side options on the table

Energy efficiency was a core element of PGE’s proposed resource mix. The plan called for 157 average megawatts (MWa) of cost-effective efficiency. MWa describes average energy production or savings over time; it is distinct from a resource’s maximum generating capacity. For planners, this distinction matters because annual energy savings and the ability to meet a specific peak are related but not interchangeable measures.

PGE also proposed expanding distributed flexibility: using customer equipment and participation to help balance electricity supply and demand. Examples considered in the plan included demand response, smart thermostats, managed electric-vehicle charging, customer backup generation and battery storage. The utility estimated that distributed flexibility programs could avoid the need for about 200 MW of conventional generation by 2025.

These resources do not work automatically as a unified system. Their planning value depends on customer adoption and participation, as well as when and how the resources can respond. The IRP’s treatment of customer resources therefore connected adoption scenarios with system needs rather than assuming every installed device would provide dispatchable capacity.

Renewables and reliability require different measures

PGE’s preferred plan called for 150 MWa of additional renewable resources by 2023. The broader analysis also estimated that reaching the utility’s long-term decarbonization goal would require adding at least 50–60 MWa of new renewables annually over the following three decades. These figures describe the plan’s 2019 outlook, not a guarantee that a particular procurement would proceed unchanged.

Renewable generation can contribute energy while providing a different level of dependable capacity, depending on its availability and the timing of system demand. For that reason, PGE assessed resource value across several dimensions: energy, capacity and flexibility. The plan also examined integration costs and locational value, recognizing that a resource’s contribution depends on how and where it connects to the wider system.

This distinction is relevant to automation and grid planning. A portfolio with substantial variable generation may need resources that can respond to changing conditions. Storage, demand response and dispatchable generation can serve different roles, so comparisons based only on annual energy output or levelized cost may miss important system considerations.

A staged path to meeting capacity needs

Rather than immediately committing to a single type of new capacity, PGE proposed a sequence of actions. First, it would seek cost-competitive agreements for capacity from existing regional resources where available. If a reliability gap remained, the plan proposed a competitive solicitation for new non-emitting resources, potentially including battery storage, pumped hydro, renewables or combinations of renewables and storage. The proposed solicitation would exclude new fossil-fuel-based generation.

This staged approach linked procurement decisions to updated assessments of need. It also recognized that uncertainty affects both the amount of capacity required and the comparative economics of available technologies. For system planners, the practical takeaway is to distinguish between an identified planning risk and a final procurement decision.

What the plan means for energy decision-makers

PGE’s 2019 IRP illustrates several useful principles for utility and industrial planning:

  • Evaluate energy and capacity separately. Annual energy supply does not by itself establish that resources will be available during peak conditions.
  • Include customer-side flexibility. Efficiency, demand response and storage can affect the need for conventional supply, but their contributions depend on adoption and operational characteristics.
  • Compare resources by system value. Cost, location, integration, flexibility and capacity contribution can all influence portfolio performance.
  • Plan around uncertainty. Scenario analysis and staged procurement can help decision-makers respond as demand, markets and technology assumptions change.

For facilities considering electrification or greater participation in demand-response programs, these planning concepts also highlight why load timing and controllability matter alongside total consumption. Utility resource plans establish the broader system context in which customer technologies and operating strategies may contribute.

Conclusion

PGE’s 2019 plan treated resource adequacy as a portfolio challenge, combining efficiency, renewables, customer flexibility and potential regional or new capacity resources. Its practical implication is that reliable decarbonization depends on evaluating how resources perform together under different conditions—not simply selecting the lowest-cost generation option. For utilities and large energy users alike, transparent assumptions, flexible demand and staged decisions can help connect long-term objectives with near-term operational needs.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author