Thermoelectric materials convert a temperature difference into electrical voltage, making them candidates for energy harvesting and solid-state cooling. A central challenge is improving their Seebeck coefficient without sacrificing electrical conductivity or allowing thermal conductivity to overwhelm the benefit. The predicted nonsaturating thermopower of Dirac and Weyl semimetals under a strong, quantizing magnetic field offers a different route: rather than relying only on conventional doping and band engineering, it uses magnetic-field-driven changes in carrier states and transport.
The result is theoretical, not a general performance guarantee for thermoelectric devices. It identifies a mechanism that can produce a transverse thermopower increasing with magnetic field in the extreme quantum limit, and outlines material and operating conditions that engineers and researchers would need to evaluate.
Why thermopower is difficult to improve
The Seebeck coefficient, S, is the voltage difference generated per unit temperature difference. Thermoelectric performance is often summarized by the figure of merit ZT = S²σT/κ, where σ is electrical conductivity, T is temperature and κ is thermal conductivity. Increasing S alone is not sufficient: a useful material must also conduct electricity while limiting heat flow.
Insulating or lightly doped materials can have a relatively large thermopower, but their electrical conductivity may be exponentially suppressed when carriers must be thermally excited across an energy gap. Heavily doped semiconductors and metals generally conduct more robustly, but their Seebeck coefficient is usually smaller. In ordinary conditions, these trade-offs make it difficult to raise ZT substantially, particularly when phonons contribute significantly to thermal conductivity.
How a quantizing magnetic field changes carrier transport
In a sufficiently strong magnetic field, charge carriers can complete many cyclotron orbits between scattering events. In the paper’s framework, this corresponds to a large cyclotron frequency multiplied by the momentum-scattering time. The field quantizes carrier motion into Landau levels and makes transverse E × B drift important to transport.
A key feature of this drift is that electrons and holes move in the same direction under crossed electric and magnetic fields, despite having opposite charge. Their contributions to heat flow therefore add, while their contributions to electrical current oppose one another. In this regime, the transverse Seebeck coefficient can be understood approximately as the total carrier entropy divided by the net carrier charge density.
This relationship helps explain why a material containing both electrons and holes can show a strong thermoelectric response. The relevant quantity is not simply the entropy associated with one carrier type: both populations contribute to heat transport, while the net charge depends on their difference.
Nonsaturating thermopower in Dirac and Weyl semimetals
Dirac and Weyl semimetals have approximately linear, gapless energy bands near their nodes. In the extreme quantum limit, where the magnetic field is strong enough that carriers occupy only the lowest Landau level, the analysis predicts that the density of states near the chemical potential increases with field. The chemical potential decreases as the field rises, while the net charge density remains fixed.
For these gapless materials, that combination allows the populations of thermally excited electrons and holes to increase even though their difference stays constant. Because both populations contribute additively to transverse heat transport in the strong-field regime, the transverse thermopower continues to increase. The predicted extreme-quantum-limit dependence is linear in magnetic field rather than leveling off at a value near the natural thermopower scale kB/e.
This distinguishes the semimetal case from a conventional semiconductor. In a semiconductor, once the field and temperature place the chemical potential far below the band edge, carriers can enter a nondegenerate, classical regime. The thermopower then approaches a value of order kB/e, with only a logarithmic dependence on field and temperature. A gapless band structure avoids that same saturation mechanism under the assumptions of the analysis.
What the prediction means for ZT and device evaluation
If electronic thermal conductivity dominates and the Wiedemann–Franz relation applies, the analysis connects ZT to the square of the Seebeck coefficient, normalized by a characteristic thermal scale. A thermopower that grows with field can therefore support a rapidly increasing figure of merit. But this conclusion depends on thermal transport and electrical resistance, not just on S.
When phonons dominate thermal conductivity, the simplified Wiedemann–Franz-based relationship no longer applies. The relevant figure of merit then depends on the material’s thermal conductivity and resistivity, including how both vary with temperature and magnetic field. A linear increase in magnetoresistance, for example, can reduce the predicted growth of ZT with field, although the theoretical discussion indicates that the increase need not saturate.
The distinction between transverse and longitudinal transport also matters. The proposed nonsaturating behavior concerns thermopower perpendicular to the magnetic field, where E × B drift makes electron and hole heat currents align. Along the field, the analysis predicts saturation at a scale of order kB/e once thermal energy exceeds the chemical potential.
Material selection and practical constraints
The work compares its predictions with measurements of Pb1−xSnxSe, where reported transverse thermopower showed quantum oscillations at lower fields followed by an approximately linear increase in the extreme quantum limit. The theoretical values were reported to agree with the measured values within about a factor of two. This comparison supports the proposed mechanism, but it does not establish that the same response or device-level performance will occur in every Dirac or Weyl material.
For material screening and experimental planning, the analysis highlights several considerations:
- Band structure: A sufficiently small gap relative to the temperature or chemical potential is important to the semimetal description.
- Carrier density: Lower net carrier density can increase the predicted thermopower, but electrical conduction must remain adequate.
- Magnetic field: The system must reach the extreme quantum limit, while also satisfying the strong-field transport conditions used in the model.
- Thermal transport and scattering: Phonon heat conduction, resistivity and mobility determine whether increased thermopower translates into improved ZT or power factor.
The numerical estimates discussed for Pb1−xSnxSe rely on particular assumptions about mobility and thermal conductivity. They should be treated as conditional projections, not universal specifications for a thermoelectric system.
Conclusion
Quantizing magnetic fields can, in theory, create a transverse thermopower in Dirac and Weyl semimetals that rises without saturation. The mechanism combines an increasing density of states, a fixed net carrier density and the additive heat transport of electrons and holes drifting together. For engineers and technical decision-makers, the practical implication is a promising materials strategy that must be assessed alongside field requirements, carrier mobility, resistivity and phonon thermal conductivity. Those factors determine whether a large Seebeck coefficient can deliver useful thermoelectric performance.