Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Patent litigation in industrial automation can reach beyond a dispute over a single component. A claim may affect a product’s design, its route to market, or the ability to sell into a particular region. For engineering and business leaders, examples involving power controls, electric vehicle charging, 3D printing, welding equipment and industrial processes illustrate how patent disputes can intersect with product development and commercial decisions.

These cases do not establish a universal formula for avoiding litigation. They do, however, show the range of issues that can arise: whether a product falls within patent claims, whether those claims are valid, and how decisions made during litigation can shape business outcomes.

Patent litigation in industrial automation: the issues at stake

Industrial products often combine multiple technologies. A charging station, power supply, display or manufacturing system may involve control circuitry, software, communications and physical components. Patent disputes can focus on one feature or on how a system operates as a whole. The legal question is not simply whether two products look or behave similarly; the analysis depends on the patent claims and how they apply to the accused technology.

A 2019 International Trade Commission dispute involving Qualcomm and Apple, for example, concerned mobile devices and radio-frequency and processing components. The administrative law judge found for Qualcomm on issues relating to a claim covering a “Power on Control” circuit and recommended a limited exclusion order for certain devices. The dispute settled after that recommendation. The case illustrates how a patent dispute can involve not only damages but also potential restrictions on imports.

For manufacturers with complex supply chains, that possibility makes it important to understand where relevant components are designed, sourced, integrated and sold. An IP issue involving a subsystem can have implications for a finished product and its market access.

Product categories show the breadth of exposure

Several disputes in the case record involved technologies closely associated with industrial and infrastructure markets:

  • EV charging: In ChargePoint v. SemaConnect, the dispute concerned patents asserted against an electric vehicle charging station provider. The Maryland court invalidated the asserted claims, while a separate federal appeal later affirmed dismissal of another action involving the parties.
  • Metal additive manufacturing: In litigation involving desktop metal printing companies Markforged and Desktop Metal, a jury found that Markforged did not infringe the asserted patents. The case also included trade-secret and contract claims.
  • Welding power supplies: Lincoln Electric asserted patents and other claims concerning Harbor Freight’s competing welding power supplies. The court denied Lincoln’s request for a preliminary injunction, and Lincoln withdrew two patents and provided covenants not to sue.
  • Power conversion: In Power Integrations v. Fairchild Semiconductor, the Federal Circuit vacated a patent damages judgment concerning switching regulation in power supplies. Its decision addressed the use of the entire market value rule to establish damages.
  • Industrial processes: In a dispute involving Shell’s benzene purification process, the Federal Circuit affirmed a finding of non-infringement. The court concluded that the patent required a boiling-point process, whereas Shell used a solubility-based process.

Together, these examples demonstrate that industrial patent risk can arise in products, production methods and enabling technologies. They also show that the outcome may turn on a specific technical distinction, the scope of a claim or the evidence presented about how a product works.

Validity challenges can be as important as infringement defenses

A patent owner must establish that an accused product or process infringes the relevant claims. A defendant may also challenge whether those claims should have been granted in the first place. One route described in several cases is inter partes review (IPR), a proceeding before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board that examines patent claims in light of cited prior art.

In a series of IPRs involving Bio-Rad and 10X Genomics, the board denied institution of all twelve petitions challenging Bio-Rad patents. In a separate proceeding, the board invalidated challenged claims in a patent dispute involving Sony and optical display technology. Other examples included disputes involving LED technology and patents related to computer, network and communications systems.

For automation companies, prior art may include earlier technical publications, patents or other evidence relevant to what was already known. The cases also underline the importance of clear technical records. Engineers and technical experts may need to explain how a system operates, how a claimed feature differs from existing approaches, or why a reference does—or does not—describe the claimed invention.

Design decisions and documentation matter

Patent disputes can involve questions that are highly specific to implementation. In the Shell case, the distinction between boiling-point and solubility-based purification was central. In the power-supply damages appeal, the court examined whether the asserted technology justified calculating damages based on the value of an entire product. Those examples show why precise descriptions of system architecture, component functions and development history can be useful when assessing IP exposure.

Practical steps for technical and business teams include:

  • Identify patents and published applications relevant to products under development and the markets where they will be sold.
  • Keep design records that explain key engineering choices, including how components and processes function.
  • Review product changes and supplier relationships for potential effects on existing IP assessments.
  • Coordinate engineering, product, procurement and legal teams when a patent concern arises.
  • Consider both infringement allegations and potential challenges to the validity or scope of asserted claims.

These measures are not guarantees against litigation, and the appropriate response depends on the facts and legal advice for a particular situation. Their value is in helping teams make technical and commercial decisions with a clearer understanding of the issues.

Conclusion: connect IP review with engineering decisions

The patent disputes described here span industrial processes, power electronics, EV charging, additive manufacturing and related technologies. Their outcomes depended on detailed questions of claim scope, product operation, patent validity and damages—not broad labels attached to an industry. For automation leaders, the practical implication is to treat intellectual property as part of product and operational planning. Early coordination between engineering and legal teams, supported by accurate technical documentation, can help organizations evaluate risks and respond more deliberately when disputes arise.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author