Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Understanding photovoltaic module cost reduction requires more than tracking prices or comparing cost with cumulative production. For engineers, operations leaders and technical decision-makers, the key question is how changes in materials, product design and manufacturing translate into lower cost. An analysis of crystalline silicon modules from 1980 to 2012 offers a structured way to examine those connections—and shows that the most influential drivers changed over time.

The analysis distinguishes between measurable, technology-specific changes and the broader processes that help produce them. This distinction is useful beyond solar manufacturing: it connects detailed engineering improvements to factors such as research and development (R&D), routine production learning and manufacturing scale.

Two levels of explanation for cost change

A cost model first describes how product and process variables combine to determine cost. For PV modules, the model accounts for module efficiency, wafer area, silicon use and price, production yield, non-silicon material costs, and manufacturing plant size. These are the low-level mechanisms: observable changes in the technology or production system that directly affect the modeled cost.

High-level mechanisms describe the processes behind those changes. The analysis considers R&D, learning-by-doing and economies of scale. These categories can explain the same reduction from different perspectives. For example, a higher production yield is a measurable, low-level change; if it results from repeated routine manufacturing, learning-by-doing is a high-level explanation.

This framework avoids treating a technology as a black box. It also helps prevent double-counting. If efficiency improves, a module generates more power from its area. That effect must be represented consistently when attributing savings to other variables, such as silicon use, or the efficiency benefit could be counted twice.

How the PV module cost model works

The model groups manufacturing costs into three broad components: silicon, other materials, and plant-size-dependent costs. Silicon cost depends on polysilicon price and the amount needed to produce wafers. Silicon use reflects wafer thickness and how effectively silicon is utilized, including losses during wafer production. Other materials include inputs used in wafer, cell and module production, such as glass, metal pastes and module components.

Plant-size-dependent costs include electricity, labor, maintenance and equipment depreciation. The model represents their relationship to plant output with a scaling function: these costs can grow less than proportionally as a facility gets larger. That means greater production volume may reduce such costs per unit of output.

To estimate each variable’s contribution, the researchers begin with a cost equation and calculate how changes in its inputs relate to changes in total cost. This matters because multiple variables can change at once, and their combined effect is not always captured accurately by simply adding up estimates made one at a time. The approach compares historical snapshots from 1980, 2001 and 2012.

What changed between 1980 and 2012?

Across the full period, module cost in the analysis fell from $29.07/W to $1.08/W in 2015 dollars. The largest low-level contributor was improved module efficiency, responsible for about 23% of the modeled decline. Lower non-silicon materials costs contributed about 21%, followed by lower polysilicon prices at 16% and reduced silicon use at 14%.

The relative importance of these factors shifted over time:

  • 1980–2001: Efficiency was the leading contributor, accounting for 24% of the cost decline. Lower non-silicon materials costs contributed 22%, and lower silicon prices contributed 18%. Reduced silicon use, larger wafer area, plant scale and higher yield also played roles.
  • 2001–2012: Plant size became the largest contributor, at 36%. Larger wafer area contributed 16%, lower non-silicon materials costs 15%, and improved efficiency 12%.

Efficiency gains came from multiple technical improvements, including surface passivation, anti-reflective coatings and wafer texturing. Silicon use fell as wafers became thinner and silicon utilization improved. Yield also increased over the period, from 75% to 95%, with automation and process improvements among the factors associated with that change.

Plant scale became especially significant in the later period. Typical plant size in the analysis grew from 1 MW in 1980 to 13 MW in 2001 and 1,000 MW in 2012. The model associates larger facilities with lower unit costs for plant-size-dependent activities, including through shared infrastructure and the spreading of fixed costs across more output.

From engineering improvements to industry-wide drivers

At the high level, R&D was the most important mechanism over the full period. It contributed to changes in efficiency, wafer area and silicon use. The analysis also identifies scale economies as a more prominent factor after 2001, approaching R&D in importance. Learning-by-doing had a smaller estimated contribution, although its role could be greater if routine production experience helped improve wafer area or silicon use.

These findings also illustrate how market growth can influence costs through several pathways. A larger market can support private R&D and larger production facilities, as well as create opportunities for manufacturing learning. The analysis therefore does not frame technology development and market expansion as mutually exclusive explanations: market growth can help enable mechanisms that produce specific engineering and operational improvements.

Practical implications for technical decision-makers

For manufacturers and system integrators, the main lesson is to connect cost targets to the variables that drive them. A useful cost analysis should make clear whether savings are expected from product performance, material use, yield, input prices or production scale. It should also distinguish an observed cost driver from the broader process that may have caused it.

For plant managers, the changing contribution of scale is a reminder that the dominant improvement opportunity can evolve as production systems mature. A factor that matters most in one period may become less influential later, while another—such as capacity expansion—gains importance. For decision-makers evaluating technology programs, separating low-level mechanisms from high-level drivers can make assumptions easier to examine and future improvement pathways easier to compare.

Conclusion

Photovoltaic module cost reduction resulted from a combination of improvements, not a single breakthrough or a simple relationship between output and cost. Efficiency led among the measured drivers over 1980–2012, while plant scale became particularly important after 2001. R&D was the leading high-level mechanism across the period, with economies of scale rising in significance. For industrial technology decisions, the practical value of this framework is its ability to link measurable process and product changes to the forces that drive them—supporting clearer cost analysis and more focused improvement priorities.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author