Proxy voting statistics provide a structured view of how an investment manager participates in corporate decision-making. KBI Global Investors’ report for April 1 through June 30, 2020, records meeting, ballot and proposal activity across markets, along with how votes compared with management recommendations and the firm’s policy. The results show high overall coverage, while also illustrating why different measures of participation should be read separately.
Proxy voting statistics: coverage at three levels
The report tracks activity at meetings, ballots and individual proposal items. These are related measures, but they describe different stages of the voting process. A meeting can contain multiple ballots, and a ballot can include multiple items requiring a vote.
- Meetings: Of 626 votable meetings, 623 were voted, a reported participation rate of 99.5%.
- Ballots: Of 3,606 votable ballots, 3,537 were voted, or 98.1%.
- Proposal items: Of 8,386 votable items, 8,312 received votes, representing 99.1%.
The figures indicate broad participation during the reporting period, but the denominators matter. The meeting rate does not mean every item at every meeting was voted: the item-level total shows that some votable proposals were not recorded as voted. Reporting each level helps readers distinguish overall meeting engagement from completion at the ballot and proposal stages.
How votes were distributed
Among the 8,312 items voted, 7,498 votes were For (90.2%) and 715 were Against (8.6%). The remaining recorded outcomes were 71 Abstain votes (0.9%) and 21 Withhold votes (0.3%). The report also identifies 395 votes on management say-on-pay (MSOP) matters, equivalent to 4.8% of items voted, and 192 votes on shareholder proposals, or 2.3%.
These categories describe vote instructions, not the reasons behind them. The statistics show how votes were cast but do not, by themselves, explain the analysis or considerations behind an individual decision. Proposal-level records provide useful context: the report includes votes on director elections, compensation, financial statements, share issuance and shareholder-submitted resolutions.
Policy alignment and management recommendations
A notable distinction in the report is between alignment with voting policy and alignment with management. All 8,312 votes were recorded as being with policy at the time they were cast; none were classified as against policy. By contrast, 7,623 votes (91.7%) were with management recommendations, while 689 (8.3%) were against management.
Those measures are not contradictory. A vote can follow an established policy while differing from a company’s recommendation. The report’s examples show this in practice: at Hewlett Packard Enterprise, a shareholder proposal to require shareholder approval of certain bylaw amendments received an Against vote, matching management’s recommendation. At the Bank of Nova Scotia, a shareholder proposal concerning human-rights policies received a For vote even though management recommended Against. The record also lists instances where votes differed from management on individual director, compensation and other resolutions.
For readers assessing voting records, keeping these reference points separate is essential. Policy alignment indicates consistency with the stated voting framework; agreement with management indicates whether the vote matched the company’s recommendation. Neither measure alone describes the full rationale for a vote.
Market-level participation varies
The market breakdown shows 100% meeting participation in most listed markets. Examples include the United States, with 159 of 159 meetings voted, and Japan, with 89 of 89. The report records lower rates in two markets: Mexico had 8 of 9 meetings voted (88.9%), while Norway had 1 of 3 (33.3%).
These figures identify differences in coverage, but the report does not explain why particular meetings were not voted. The rates should therefore be treated as descriptive rather than as evidence of a specific operational or market constraint. Comparing markets is most useful when the underlying counts are considered alongside the percentages: a single meeting can substantially affect a rate where the number of meetings is small.
What the report can—and cannot—tell readers
For technical and business decision-makers accustomed to working with performance dashboards, the report’s structure offers a familiar lesson: a summary metric is strongest when its scope and denominator are clear. Meeting, ballot and proposal-item rates answer different questions, while vote direction, policy alignment and management alignment describe separate dimensions of the record.
The statistics provide a high-level account of activity during one three-month period, supported by examples of individual resolutions. They do not establish why each decision was made, nor do they show trends beyond the stated date range. Readers should use the aggregate figures to understand the broad pattern and consult individual voting records when evaluating a specific resolution.
Conclusion
KBI Global Investors’ Q2 2020 proxy voting statistics show participation in 623 of 626 votable meetings and votes on 8,312 proposal items. All recorded votes were in line with policy, while 8.3% differed from management recommendations. For decision-makers reviewing governance data, the practical takeaway is to distinguish coverage from vote outcomes—and policy consistency from agreement with management—before drawing conclusions from headline percentages.