Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Semiconductor manufacturing incentives can influence where companies build the fabrication plants, or fabs, that underpin digital infrastructure, industrial systems and advanced electronics. A 2020 analysis by the Boston Consulting Group and Semiconductor Industry Association examined how costs and government support affected the US position in a highly globalized industry. Its figures describe the conditions and forecasts considered at that time, rather than current market conditions.

The analysis identified a strategic challenge: US companies retained a leading share of global semiconductor sales and important capabilities in design, equipment and research, while the share of worldwide manufacturing capacity located in the US had declined. The issue was not simply how many fabs to build. It was how manufacturing location could affect innovation, supply-chain resilience and the long-term competitiveness of the semiconductor ecosystem.

US semiconductor manufacturing: strong capabilities, smaller footprint

In the report’s 2020 assessment, US companies accounted for roughly 45% to 50% of global semiconductor revenues, but the US held about 12% of installed manufacturing capacity. That capacity share had fallen from 37% in 1990. The report also noted that only 6% of new capacity then in development was expected to be located in the US.

This gap reflected different growth rates, not an outright contraction in US capacity. Domestic capacity had expanded over the preceding decades, but several Asian economies had invested faster. The analysis associated that expansion with government grants, tax support and other incentives, as well as the emergence of dedicated foundries serving customers that did not operate their own fabs.

The manufacturing picture also varied by product. The US retained comparatively strong positions in discrete, analog and optoelectronics products, as well as particular compound-semiconductor and radio-frequency technologies. Its share was much lower in memory and logic, which the report identified as major sources of expected capacity growth during the following decade.

Why semiconductor manufacturing incentives matter

A semiconductor fab requires substantial capital investment and years of operating expenditure. To compare locations, the report modeled the ten-year total cost of ownership (TCO): capital costs such as land, buildings and equipment, plus operating costs such as labor and utilities, minus applicable incentives. Its modeled examples covered advanced logic, memory and analog fabs.

Depending on the fab type and location, the report estimated gross ten-year costs could range from approximately $11 billion to $40 billion before incentives. Under its assumptions, a US fab’s TCO was about 25% to 30% higher than comparable facilities in Taiwan or Singapore, and could be roughly 37% to 50% higher than in China. These were modeled comparisons, not universal costs for every project.

Government incentives were a material part of the difference. The analysis attributed approximately 40% to 70% of the US cost gap to incentives offered in competing locations. Support could reduce upfront expenses for land, construction and equipment, and in some cases help with operating costs. Other factors also mattered: the report identified higher US labor and construction costs, along with differences in utility expenses, as contributors to the gap.

Fab location decisions are not based on cost alone. The survey described in the analysis found that companies valued the strength of an existing semiconductor ecosystem, access to skilled workers and protection of intellectual property. The US rated favorably on several of these considerations, while incentives and labor costs were areas of weaker competitiveness. For decision-makers, this distinction matters: investment support can affect project economics, but it operates alongside workforce, infrastructure and ecosystem requirements.

Manufacturing capacity supports innovation and resilience

The report framed domestic manufacturing as relevant to more than production volume. Manufacturing represented a significant share of industry value added and R&D investment in its assessment. As chip architectures, materials and fabrication processes evolve, closer collaboration between design and manufacturing can help advance new technologies. The analysis argued that strengthening US manufacturing could complement existing strengths in basic science, integrated-circuit design and manufacturing equipment.

Geographic concentration was another concern. The report estimated that roughly three-quarters of global semiconductor manufacturing capacity was located in East Asia. It highlighted regional concentration in advanced logic and memory as a potential exposure to disruptions, including natural disasters, pandemics and geopolitical conflict. A geographically diversified supply chain can reduce reliance on a limited set of manufacturing locations, although the report did not argue that all production should be brought within US borders.

That qualification is important for industrial and technology leaders. Semiconductor production is globally distributed, with different regions contributing distinct capabilities. The objective described in the analysis was a more resilient and competitive footprint, not complete self-sufficiency. A stronger domestic base could also support local high-tech clusters, skilled employment and semiconductor exports, while remaining connected to international suppliers and customers.

What the 2020 capacity scenarios suggested

Looking toward 2030, the analysis forecast substantial growth in global capacity and identified a portion of that expansion as not yet committed to specific projects. It described this uncommitted capacity as an opportunity for the US to attract a greater share of future fab investment.

In the report’s scenarios, an additional federal incentive program of $20 billion to $50 billion for new fabs over the following decade could raise the US share of new addressable capacity above the 6% status quo. The modeled outcomes varied by program size: the report estimated a $50 billion program could support 19 advanced fabs and increase US-based capacity by 57% compared with its baseline. These are scenario results based on the report’s assumptions, not guaranteed outcomes or a statement of current policy.

The analysis also estimated that such a program could create about 70,000 direct jobs. Beyond employment, the potential benefits it identified included stronger local clusters and a contribution to the US trade balance. The practical implication for planners is that incentives may influence location decisions, but attracting a fab also depends on the ability to provide talent, infrastructure, a capable supplier ecosystem and effective collaboration across the value chain.

Practical implications for industrial decision-makers

For system integrators, plant managers and technical leaders, semiconductor manufacturing capacity is a strategic supply-chain consideration, even when chip fabrication is outside their direct operations. The 2020 analysis underscores several points for evaluating exposure and investment priorities:

  • Assess geographic concentration: understand where critical semiconductor products are manufactured and how dependent supply is on particular regions.
  • Consider the full fab economics: compare capital investment, operating costs and incentives over the asset’s life, rather than focusing on construction cost alone.
  • Account for ecosystem needs: skilled labor, suppliers, infrastructure and proximity to complementary capabilities shape the viability of a manufacturing location.
  • Connect manufacturing with innovation: production capabilities can support collaboration on process, material and architecture advances.

In conclusion, the report presented semiconductor manufacturing incentives as one lever in a broader competitiveness equation. Its 2020 analysis linked fab economics to the US manufacturing footprint, innovation capacity and supply-chain resilience, while emphasizing that global specialization remains important. For technical decision-makers, the lasting lesson is to evaluate manufacturing location not only as a cost decision, but also as a factor in technology development and supply continuity.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author