Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Changes to skilled immigration policy can affect more than hiring plans: they may also influence how investors assess a company’s prospects. An event study of the June 22, 2020 U.S. work-visa restriction found that publicly traded Fortune 500 firms experienced a significant short-term decline in market value after the announcement. The result offers a way to examine how markets respond when access to a specialized labor pool is abruptly constrained, while stopping short of measuring the policy’s long-run effects.

What the June 2020 order changed

The executive order suspended entry for certain people seeking to work in the United States on non-immigrant visas. Of particular relevance to companies were restrictions on new H-1B and L-1 visas. H-1B visas are used to hire workers in specialty occupations, while L-1 visas allow eligible companies with international operations to transfer employees to U.S. offices.

The order was estimated to affect nearly 200,000 foreign workers and their dependents. For employers, the restriction represented a potential limit on hiring or transferring skilled workers from abroad. The research examined whether investors reacted to that change by analyzing stock returns for 471 publicly traded companies drawn from the Fortune 500.

How the event study measured market reaction

The researchers used an event study, a method for assessing whether an event is associated with stock returns that differ from what would otherwise be expected. They first estimated each company’s usual relationship to the broader market using daily returns from 2019 and the S&P 500 as the market benchmark. They then compared actual returns around the announcement with returns predicted by that relationship.

The difference is called an abnormal return. Averaging abnormal returns across companies and over a specified period produces cumulative average abnormal returns, or CAARs. The primary analysis examined short windows around the announcement: three trading days, from one day before to one day after, and five trading days, from one day before to three days after.

Using the S&P 500 helped account for general market movements, an important consideration during the COVID-19 pandemic. The researchers also tested alternative windows and industry controls. These choices strengthen the analysis of the immediate market response, but they do not establish how companies would adjust over a longer period.

Estimated valuation decline across the sample

Across the two main event windows, average CAARs were approximately negative 0.44% to 0.45%. The estimates were statistically significant and remained similar when the analysis accounted for industry differences. The study also reported that the negative pattern persisted in analyses extending the post-announcement window to ten trading days.

To put the estimated percentage in context, the 471 firms had a combined market capitalization of about $22.68 trillion on June 19, 2020, the business day before the order was announced. Applying the estimated 0.45% decline to that total produces an estimated loss of roughly $100 billion in market value. This figure describes the sample’s estimated market-capitalization impact based on abnormal returns; it is not a direct measure of cash lost, operating costs, or a permanent reduction in company value.

Companies with greater visa demand saw larger effects

The average result was negative across the sectors examined, but the magnitude varied. The study found especially large negative estimates in its combined Financial, Information Technology and Real Estate category, followed by Mining, Utilities and Construction. The authors nevertheless reported a negative response across industries rather than an effect confined to one sector.

A clearer difference emerged when firms were grouped by their recent demand for H-1B workers. The researchers used Department of Labor Labor Condition Application (LCA) requests as a proxy for H-1B demand. LCAs are part of the application process, so they indicate employer demand but do not establish that a visa was ultimately issued.

Firms whose LCA requests, measured relative to employment, had stayed level or grown from 2016 to 2019 experienced a larger estimated decline than firms whose reliance had fallen. In the main comparison, the higher-demand group’s decline was roughly 0.2 to 0.3 percentage points greater. This suggests that investors responded more negatively where the announced constraint appeared more relevant to employers’ recent hiring patterns.

Interpreting the findings for business leaders

The study focuses on a short-run market reaction, not the full economic consequences of skilled immigration restrictions. A stock-price response reflects investors’ expectations and may capture concerns about future hiring, growth, innovation, or other business factors. The analysis does not isolate which of these expectations drove the reaction, nor does it determine how individual firms ultimately adapted.

Over time, companies may respond to labor constraints in different ways, including reallocating resources across locations. Such adjustments are outside the immediate event-study result. The findings should therefore be read as evidence that markets registered a negative shock around the announcement—not as a forecast of lasting losses for every firm or sector.

For executives and technical decision-makers, the practical implication is that workforce access can be treated by investors as a business risk, particularly when a company has maintained or increased demand for skilled foreign workers. The study does not prescribe a staffing strategy, but it underscores the value of understanding how changes in labor policy may intersect with a firm’s talent requirements and market expectations.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author