Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Supercapacitor energy storage can complement battery-based power systems when a load requires both sustained supply and short-duration bursts of power. Batteries are suited to longer-term energy delivery, while capacitors can provide rapid pulses. Comparing a supercapacitor with a conventional linear capacitor, however, requires more than comparing nominal capacitance: a supercapacitor’s capacitance can vary with terminal voltage, and the energy comparison depends on the charging conditions.

An analytical model of charging from a non-ideal DC source, such as a rechargeable battery with internal resistance, helps clarify these relationships. It shows why engineers assessing hybrid power supplies should consider both the capacitor’s voltage-dependent behavior and its initial and final voltages.

Why combine batteries and capacitors?

Batteries and capacitors serve different roles in an electrical system. A rechargeable battery can supply a load over an extended period, while a capacitor can deliver energy quickly to meet a pulse demand. Combining storage elements can therefore help address loads with both steady and transient power requirements.

Conventional linear capacitors have capacitance that is treated as constant with voltage. Supercapacitors, also called ultracapacitors, are modeled differently because their capacitance may change as terminal voltage changes. That distinction affects how much charge and energy they accumulate during charging. A comparison that treats both devices as constant-capacitance components can therefore miss an important part of the supercapacitor’s behavior.

Modeling supercapacitor energy storage

The analysis represents supercapacitor capacitance as C(U) = C1 + kU, where U is terminal voltage, C1 is the voltage-independent component, and k describes how capacitance changes with voltage. In the model, k is treated as approximately constant for the supercapacitor under consideration. This is a simplifying representation of voltage dependence, not a claim that every device has the same capacitance profile.

For a linear capacitor charged from zero to voltage U, stored energy is W = CU²/2. For the modeled supercapacitor, integrating voltage against the voltage-dependent capacitance gives W = C1U²/2 + kU³/3. The additional cubic term means the energy comparison changes with terminal voltage. Engineers should use the applicable capacitance model and operating range when estimating stored energy.

The charging source is also part of the system. A battery is not an ideal voltage source; its internal resistance and the resistance and inductance of the charging circuit influence the transient process. The study’s energy comparisons focus on energy accumulated in the capacitors under defined voltage conditions. They should not be mistaken for a general measurement of charging efficiency or total system losses.

How voltage and initial charge affect the comparison

For a charge that starts at zero voltage, the modeled supercapacitor accumulates more energy than a linear capacitor whose capacitance equals the supercapacitor’s voltage-independent component, C1, when both reach the same final voltage. The difference grows with final voltage because the voltage-dependent term contributes increasingly to the modeled supercapacitor’s stored energy.

The analysis illustrates this trend by varying final voltage as a fraction of nominal voltage. For the specific values presented, the ratio of energy accumulated in the supercapacitor to that in the linear capacitor ranges from about 1.04 at a low final voltage to 3.16 at nominal voltage. These are results for the stated model and comparison basis; they are not universal ratios for all supercapacitors and linear capacitors.

Initial voltage matters too. When a capacitor is already charged, the energy added during a subsequent charging interval is the difference between its final and initial stored energy—not the energy it would contain if charging had begun at zero. For a linear capacitor, this change is C(Uf² − Ui²)/2. For the modeled supercapacitor, the corresponding change includes both the quadratic and cubic voltage terms.

In the paper’s example of charging from an initial voltage that varies up to nominal voltage, the energy ratio between the supercapacitor and the linear-capacitor comparison changes with the starting point. It is lowest when the initial voltage approaches zero and reaches a higher value at an initial voltage of 2.28 V in the example. The practical lesson is not to apply that particular ratio to other designs, but to include the actual starting voltage when calculating the energy available from a charging interval.

Choosing a fair comparison basis

Comparisons between capacitor types depend on what is held equal. Matching the linear capacitor to C1 is not the same as matching the supercapacitor’s total capacitance at a particular voltage or matching stored energy. The analysis also derives equivalent linear-capacitance values for selected conditions, including equal voltage and energy. Those values differ according to the criterion used.

For design reviews and sizing calculations, make the comparison basis explicit:

  • Define the operating voltages. Record both initial and final terminal voltage, not just nominal voltage.
  • State how capacitance is matched. Specify whether the comparison uses the voltage-independent component, total capacitance at a selected voltage, or equal stored energy.
  • Use a voltage-dependent model where needed. Apply measured or otherwise appropriate capacitance-versus-voltage data for the device and operating range being evaluated.
  • Separate stored energy from charging losses. Energy accumulated in a capacitor is not the same as energy drawn from the battery; source and circuit losses need a separate assessment.

Practical implications for hybrid power supplies

The model supports a useful engineering distinction: a supercapacitor’s energy cannot always be estimated accurately by treating it as a linear capacitor with one fixed capacitance. Its voltage dependence affects stored energy, while the charge interval determines how much energy is added. These factors matter when evaluating a battery-backed supply intended to deliver both sustained power and pulses.

Supercapacitors can store more energy than a linear capacitor under the comparison conditions described, but that result alone does not establish which component is best for a particular application. System decisions still depend on the required voltage range, initial state of charge, load profile, circuit behavior and the chosen comparison basis. By making those assumptions explicit, engineers and integrators can produce more meaningful energy estimates and avoid treating unlike storage devices as directly interchangeable.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author