Supplier diversity procurement is not simply a matter of setting participation goals. Public agencies must understand who is available to perform contract work, how purchasing opportunities are distributed and whether program measures are supported by evidence. The City of Dallas’s 2020 availability and disparity study illustrates how those questions can be examined across a broad procurement portfolio.
Conducted for the City of Dallas, the study assessed contracting activity from October 1, 2013, through September 30, 2018. It focused on minority- and women-owned business enterprises (M/WBEs) and considered five purchasing categories: construction, architecture and engineering, professional services, other services, and goods and supplies. For industrial organizations and public-sector procurement teams, its structure offers a useful example of how to organize a supplier-participation review—without assuming that one measure or dataset tells the whole story.
Why assess supplier diversity procurement?
Dallas’s Business Inclusion and Development Plan was intended to increase procurement opportunities for M/WBEs. The study examined whether those businesses were being used in proportion to their availability in the relevant marketplace and whether the City had a legally justified basis for continuing a race- and gender-conscious program.
That distinction matters. A participation percentage on its own does not explain whether businesses had a reasonable opportunity to compete. Comparing utilization with availability helps frame the question: among firms considered ready, willing and able to perform the work, how did contract awards and payments correspond to their presence in the market?
The report also treated procurement as a system rather than a single award decision. Its scope included prime contractors and subcontractors, City policies and procedures, private-sector conditions, business-owner experiences and contractor workforce information. These lines of inquiry address different parts of the contracting environment and can help decision-makers interpret quantitative results in context.
How the study examined the contracting environment
Reviewing procurement data and market boundaries
The analysis began with City contracting and procurement records. Researchers examined where firms receiving contract dollars were located to define the relevant geographic market, then organized activity by procurement category. This step is important because supplier availability can vary by type of work. The firms capable of providing engineering services, for example, are not necessarily the same pool as those supplying goods or performing construction.
The study then compared utilization—the dollars awarded or paid to businesses by ownership classification—with estimated availability. The report describes availability in terms of businesses in the market that are qualified and able to perform relevant work. A utilization-to-availability disparity ratio can help summarize the relationship, but its interpretation depends on how the market, firms and contract activity are defined.
Considering evidence beyond award totals
The Dallas study also included private-sector analyses, a review of City policies and procedures, a peer-agency review, and anecdotal input gathered through vendor surveys, interviews and public meetings. These components served distinct purposes:
- Policy review examined the City’s procurement environment and business inclusion practices.
- Private-sector analysis considered business participation, self-employment, earnings and access to credit.
- Business-owner input captured reported experiences of firms doing business with, or seeking to do business with, the City.
- Peer-agency review compared program approaches used by other Texas municipalities.
- Workforce reporting examined the racial, ethnic and gender composition of prime contractors’ workforces in specified job categories.
These sources should not be treated as interchangeable. Contract data can show patterns in awards and payments; interviews and surveys can describe experiences that administrative records may not capture. Together, they provide a broader basis for assessing how procurement processes operate.
Legal standards shape program design
The report’s legal framework is a central part of its approach. It explains that race-conscious state and local procurement programs are subject to strict scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause. In general terms, a program must be supported by a compelling governmental interest in remedying identified discrimination and must be narrowly tailored to address that discrimination. The report also notes that race-neutral alternatives must be considered.
Gender-conscious programs are evaluated under a different standard, described in the report as intermediate scrutiny. The legal analysis therefore has practical implications: an agency must connect the evidence it collects to the program measures it adopts. Goals or other interventions cannot be treated as independent of the findings that support them.
The study’s stated research questions reflect this connection. They ask whether statistical disparities exist between availability and utilization, whether other evidence helps explain them, and whether evidence supports a legally justified program. The report’s contents indicate that it includes findings and recommendations, but the material summarized here does not provide their detailed results. Specific conclusions about Dallas’s measured disparities or recommended goals should therefore be drawn from the full report, not inferred from its methodology alone.
Practical considerations for procurement teams
For public agencies and organizations reviewing supplier participation, the Dallas study highlights several process considerations:
- Define the scope carefully. Specify the review period, purchasing categories and relevant market before drawing conclusions.
- Keep availability and utilization distinct. Establish how each is measured, including which firms and contract payments are included.
- Examine the full purchasing chain. Prime awards and subcontracting activity can reveal different aspects of participation.
- Use complementary evidence. Administrative records, policy review and vendor feedback answer different questions.
- Align interventions with evidence. Program design should follow the applicable legal standards and the specific findings.
These principles are relevant to industrial procurement, where purchasing may span equipment, engineering, construction, technical services and ongoing support. Clear category definitions and reliable contract data make it easier to understand participation patterns and evaluate procurement practices consistently.
Conclusion
The Dallas availability and disparity study demonstrates a broad framework for examining supplier diversity procurement: define the market, analyze contract utilization against firm availability, review procurement practices, gather business-owner perspectives and consider the governing legal standards. For technical and procurement decision-makers, the practical lesson is to build conclusions from clearly defined, complementary evidence—and ensure any program response is tied to the specific findings it is intended to address.