Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Systematic investment strategies turn defined selection rules into portfolio decisions. A 2018 DB Platinum annual report provides a snapshot of how this approach can be applied across global equities, dividends, commodities and credit. For readers assessing rules-based models, the report highlights an important distinction: a strategy’s selection logic is only one part of its design. Portfolio constraints, implementation, share-class currency and fees also shape the reported outcome.

How systematic investment strategies translate rules into holdings

Several DB Platinum sub-funds used the Deutsche Bank CROCI methodology, or Cash Return On Capital Invested, to evaluate companies through an economic valuation measure. The report describes the CROCI economic price-earnings ratio as a key ranking input. Strategies selected companies with the lowest positive ratios from a defined investment universe, rather than simply choosing securities by market capitalisation alone.

The details varied by strategy. CROCI World drew from at least 450 large companies in developed global markets, excluding financial companies, and aimed to select 100 shares with the lowest positive CROCI ratios. Regional and sector limits, liquidity screens and the availability of qualifying companies could result in fewer holdings. The strategy also sought to maintain regional weightings and limited exposure to any one economic sector to no more than 25%.

Other funds used a narrower sector-selection process. CROCI Branchen Stars and CROCI Sectors identified three non-financial industry sectors with the lowest median CROCI ratios, then selected up to ten qualifying companies from each. If a sector had fewer than ten companies with positive ratios, it held fewer; as a result, the portfolio could contain fewer than 30 shares.

Adding dividend and ESG screens

Valuation rules can be combined with additional eligibility tests. The CROCI Global Dividends and CROCI US Dividends strategies applied dividend-related screens before ranking the remaining companies by CROCI ratio. These screens could exclude companies based on cash returns, financial leverage and volatility. Stocks with no dividend or a below-average dividend yield could also be excluded.

The global strategy aimed to select 50 companies, while the US version aimed for 40. In both cases, the final portfolio could be smaller if fewer companies passed the screens and had positive CROCI ratios. This illustrates a practical feature of rules-based investing: a stated target holding count does not necessarily mean the portfolio will always contain that number of securities.

CROCI World ESG added an environmental, social and governance exclusion process to a developed-market global equity strategy. The report describes the strategy as systematic and rules-based, while distinguishing the roles involved: the investment manager was responsible for investing in the portfolio, but not for setting the strategy or determining its composition.

Implementation can affect results

A rules-based portfolio still needs to be implemented. In the PWM CROCI Multi Fund, a portfolio adviser advised on the allocation among CROCI strategies, while the management company retained authority over the final allocation. State Street Global Advisors was appointed to carry out portfolio replication. This separation of advice, allocation authority and replication is relevant when interpreting how a model’s intended exposures become an actual portfolio.

Other sub-funds used different approaches. The commodity funds linked returns to indices representing 12 commodities across energy, precious metals, base metals and agriculture. Futures contracts represented the index commodities, with an optimum-yield methodology used to select new contracts for all except natural gas. Long/short equity and credit funds, by contrast, described investment processes based on security selection, fundamental credit analysis or trading models.

Reading tracking difference and tracking error

For index-linked share classes, the report compared share-class performance with index performance and disclosed both performance difference and tracking error. These measures answer different questions. Performance difference is the gap between the share class’s result and its reference index over the period. Tracking error describes variation in that difference over time.

For the year under review, the report attributed much of the performance difference to share-class all-in fees. Currency-hedging costs also contributed for share classes denominated in a currency different from the sub-fund’s base currency. It reported that realised tracking error exceeded the anticipated level for certain commodity share classes, citing rounding effects where net asset value per share was below USD 5 or SGD 5, and credit-spread effects on the bond portfolio for the Commodity Euro share classes.

These explanations show why headline index comparisons need context. Fees, hedging and portfolio characteristics can affect outcomes even when a fund’s objective is to track or reflect an index. The report’s figures are specific to the stated period and share classes; they should not be treated as general performance expectations.

What decision-makers can take from the report

When evaluating a systematic strategy or a model-driven portfolio, examine the full decision chain rather than the selection signal alone:

  • Universe: Identify which markets and companies are eligible, and which are excluded.
  • Selection rules: Understand the valuation ranking and any dividend, ESG or liquidity screens.
  • Constraints: Check sector, regional and holding-count limits, including conditions that can reduce the portfolio size.
  • Implementation: Clarify who advises on allocation, who has final authority and who handles replication.
  • Measurement: Separate performance difference from tracking error and consider disclosed fees and currency-hedging effects.

The practical lesson is that a systematic investment strategy is more than an algorithmic ranking rule. Its universe, screens, constraints and implementation responsibilities define what the portfolio can hold, while fees and currency effects help explain how reported results compare with a benchmark. Understanding those elements makes strategy descriptions and performance disclosures easier to interpret.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author