Standard-essential patents and patent assertion entities can raise competition concerns, but patent ownership alone does not establish market power or an antitrust violation. A fact-specific assessment helps distinguish harmful conduct from legitimate patent enforcement and licensing.
Articles Tagged: FRAND licensing
FRAND Licensing: Lessons from TCL v. Ericsson
The TCL v. Ericsson decision offers a framework for understanding FRAND licensing of wireless standard essential patents. Its approach to royalty analysis, comparable licenses and nondiscrimination is relevant to companies deploying standardized connectivity in industrial products.
FRAND Licensing and the Role of Reasoned Decisions
Technical standards enable interoperable products across industries, but their success depends in part on fair licensing of standard-essential patents. Clear, reasoned approaches to FRAND disputes can help companies negotiate with greater predictability and limit risks associated with patent hold-up and royalty stacking.
Qualcomm Antitrust Ruling: Key Lessons for Tech Markets
The Ninth Circuit reversed a sweeping antitrust injunction against Qualcomm, finding that the FTC had not shown how the company’s licensing practices harmed competition in cellular modem chip markets. The decision clarifies the distinction between patent-contract disputes and antitrust violations.
FRAND Licensing: Lessons from the TCL-Ericsson Ruling
The 2017 TCL-Ericsson judgment established FRAND royalty rates and detailed reporting obligations for specified 2G, 3G and 4G products. Its terms offer a practical case study in how patent licensing can define product scope, royalty calculations and compliance processes.
Standard-Essential Patents: What Court Outcomes Reveal
Standard-essential patents underpin interoperability, but their status does not guarantee a finding of infringement in court. Evidence from litigated cases finds SEPs were more likely to be upheld as valid yet less likely to be found infringed than comparable patents, while non-practicing entities performed poorly.
Qualcomm Antitrust Appeal: Patents, Chips and Competition
Qualcomm’s 2019 appeal challenged a ruling that its patent licensing and modem chip sales practices harmed competition. The dispute highlights how standard-essential patents, FRAND commitments and patent exhaustion can shape technology markets.
Patent Licensing, FRAND and the SSPPU Debate
Patent licensing disputes involving standards-based technology raise difficult questions about royalty calculations, portfolio value and FRAND commitments. The Ninth Circuit amicus brief argues that SSPPU should be treated as a flexible evidentiary tool, not a universal rule for negotiations or valuation.
Patent Holdup in SEP Licensing: Theory and Debate
Patent holdup is a contested theory about bargaining power in standard-essential patent licensing. Understanding its assumptions, its distinction from transaction-cost theories of holdup, and the evidence needed to test it can help decision-makers assess claims about FRAND royalties and injunctions.