Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Trade secrets are an important part of startup intellectual property strategy, but they are not simply a low-cost alternative to patents. Evidence from the Berkeley Patent Survey, which examined U.S. startups in software, biotechnology, medical devices, and information technology hardware, points to a more varied role for secrecy. Startups may use it to preserve an advantage, protect information that patents do not cover, or work alongside formal intellectual property rights.

For industrial automation companies and other technology ventures, the central lesson is strategic: the right protection approach depends on what the innovation is, how it can be reverse engineered, and how the business expects to commercialize or license it. Secrecy and patenting should not automatically be treated as mutually exclusive choices.

Why startups use trade secrets

A trade secret can be valuable business or technical information that is not generally known, provides economic value because it remains secret, and is subject to reasonable efforts to prevent disclosure. The category can include technical information as well as business information, such as software, algorithms, customer lists, and operating know-how.

Unlike patents, trade secret protection does not depend on obtaining approval from an administrative agency. It can therefore be relevant when an invention is not patentable, when a company is uncertain about patent eligibility, or when the cost and difficulty of pursuing a patent do not fit the startup’s resources. That does not make secrecy cost-free: a company needs precautions to maintain confidentiality, and protection may be lost if information is not kept secret.

Preserving a lead-time advantage

Keeping information confidential can help a company retain an advantage gained by bringing a product or service to market ahead of competitors. If key technical details are difficult to discover from the finished product, secrecy may help extend that lead. The value of this approach depends on the circumstances, including whether competitors can reverse engineer the innovation or develop it independently.

This is one reason there is no universal answer to the question of whether to patent or keep information secret. Where reverse engineering is straightforward, secrecy may offer less protection against competitors learning how a product works. Where valuable know-how is not readily observable, keeping it confidential may be more useful.

Trade secrets and patents can be complements

Patents and trade secrets are often described as alternatives: a patent requires disclosure, while secrecy depends on limiting disclosure. In practice, a startup may use both. Secrecy can protect information during research and development while a company evaluates whether an innovation is ready for commercialization and whether patent protection is worthwhile. It may also protect know-how that is not included in a patent strategy.

This can matter when a startup is developing incremental improvements or has not yet established the commercial value of an idea. Early in development, a company may need time to assess the technology before committing to a more formal protection strategy. But if confidential information is a core company asset, the potential harm from its loss can be significant. Protecting it requires deliberate attention, including suitable confidentiality arrangements and physical safeguards.

The survey’s broader finding is that secrecy may act both as a substitute for and a complement to patenting. That challenges the assumption that a company must choose one approach for an innovation or for its portfolio as a whole. Different parts of a technology or different stages of development may call for different forms of protection.

Secrecy can be a strategic business asset

The study also indicates that trade secrets can serve purposes beyond maintaining a first-mover advantage. They may play a role in licensing and in defining the boundaries of a firm, in ways that resemble some strategic uses of patents. For a startup, protected know-how may therefore matter not only as a barrier to competitors but also as an asset in commercial relationships.

This perspective is relevant to technical decision-makers who are considering how an innovation will reach the market. A company may develop technology for its own use, license it, or rely on another business to commercialize it. The protection strategy should account for those plans rather than focusing only on whether a patent application is possible.

What the findings mean for technology companies

The Berkeley Patent Survey analyzed startups across several technology industries and examined trade secrecy in relation to other protection mechanisms and barriers to entry. Its results were segmented by factors such as industry, business model, revenue, funding sources, innovation type, patenting, and licensing. The reported variation underscores why a single rule for all startups is unlikely to fit.

For automation startups and hardware ventures, the study offers a framework for making decisions, not a finding that one protection method is best for the sector. When evaluating an innovation, decision-makers can ask:

  • Can competitors readily discover how the product or process works?
  • Is patent protection available and proportionate to the cost and effort involved?
  • Could confidentiality protect valuable information during development or commercialization?
  • Will the business need to share or license the know-how?
  • Can the company take reasonable steps to keep the information confidential?

The answers may differ across technologies and business plans. A company can also revisit its approach as an innovation moves from development toward commercialization.

Build an IP strategy around the innovation

The practical implication is not that startups should favor secrecy over patents, or the reverse. Trade secrets can preserve competitive advantages, provide protection where patenting is unavailable or unattractive, complement patents, and support licensing or other strategic relationships. At the same time, secrecy is a poor fit when information can be readily reverse engineered or when the business cannot maintain confidentiality.

Technology leaders should assess protection choices in the context of the innovation, the company’s resources, and its route to market. Treating patents and trade secrets as tools that can work separately or together gives startups a more flexible foundation for protecting know-how and building a durable commercial strategy.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author