VCSEL optical links are widely used for short-reach connections where compact, directly modulated transmitters and fiber can support high data rates. As lane speeds rise, however, simply increasing the modulation rate places greater demands on the bandwidth of the transmitter, receiver and channel. Pulse amplitude modulation (PAM) and signal pre-emphasis offer ways to use available bandwidth more effectively, but each introduces design trade-offs that engineers must account for.
These considerations are relevant to intra-datacenter links, high-performance computing systems and other applications where link reach, latency, power and signal integrity matter. Choosing a modulation format is not just a question of the number of bits carried per symbol: VCSEL dynamics, receiver noise and inter-symbol interference (ISI) also influence whether a link can operate reliably.
Why consider PAM in VCSEL optical links?
On-off keying (OOK) represents data using two optical signal levels. It remains useful, including in applications where low latency is a priority. But in a bandwidth-limited link, the bandwidth needed to transmit OOK at a higher bit rate can become a constraint. Multilevel PAM addresses this by encoding information in more than two amplitude levels.
With 4-PAM, each symbol can represent one of four signal levels. This provides twice the spectral efficiency of OOK at the same symbol rate, and can therefore double the data rate without doubling the symbol rate. The advantage comes with a cost: the receiver must distinguish between more closely spaced levels. That increases the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) requirement and makes the format more sensitive to transmitter nonlinearities and signal distortion.
In a VCSEL-based intensity-modulation/direct-detection (IM/DD) system, the electrical drive signal directly modulates the laser’s optical output. The transmitter’s frequency response and dynamic behavior therefore affect the shape and timing of the received levels. If the response is not well controlled, the signal can become skewed in time or produce ISI, complicating detection.
3-PAM as an intermediate option
3-PAM provides a middle ground between OOK and 4-PAM. It uses three amplitude levels and can require less bandwidth than OOK, while being less sensitive than 4-PAM to some VCSEL dynamics that can impair transmission. This can make it worth evaluating when bandwidth is limited but a four-level signal presents too demanding a detection challenge.
Comparisons reported in the research found cases where 3-PAM outperformed both OOK and 4-PAM over the same link. The practical lesson is that a higher-order format is not automatically the best choice. Performance depends on the characteristics of the complete link, including the VCSEL, optical fiber, receiver and signal-processing approach. Engineers should assess candidate formats in the context of the actual channel rather than selecting one solely on theoretical spectral efficiency.
How pre-emphasis addresses bandwidth limits
Pre-emphasis shapes the electrical signal before it reaches the VCSEL. By boosting selected signal components, it can help compensate for bandwidth limitations in the link and improve the received waveform. This can extend the usable data rate, but the technique is not free: increasing high-frequency content can require more modulation amplitude, which is itself limited by the transmitter and the desired operating conditions.
In studies of OOK transmission, two pre-emphasis approaches were reported to increase the bit rate for error-free operation by 9% and 27%, respectively. The difference between these results illustrates why the details of the filter and link response matter. Pre-emphasis should be designed to address the measured or modeled channel behavior, while checking that the resulting signal remains within the practical drive range.
Pre-emphasis has also been investigated with 4-PAM. A passive electrical filter used to shape the signal enabled a reported 71.8 Gbps back-to-back transmission with lightweight forward error correction (FEC). With the same pre-emphasis and offline least-mean-square (LMS) receiver equalization, a 94 Gbps net data rate was reported. These results show how transmitter shaping, receiver equalization and error correction can work together; they should not be treated as guaranteed performance for other link designs.
Match VCSEL characteristics to the modulation format
The VCSEL’s modulation response is an important part of the design. A damped, relatively smooth frequency response can help avoid pronounced resonance behavior and overshoot that may distort multilevel symbols. At the same time, any practical VCSEL-based link remains bandwidth-limited, so ISI may still need to be managed.
Research on legacy 25G-class VCSELs found that devices with moderate damping were suitable candidates for transition to 4-PAM. This points to a useful selection principle: assess the device’s dynamic response, not just its nominal data-rate class. A VCSEL that performs adequately with OOK may not produce equally clean multilevel eye openings under the same conditions.
Link evaluation should consider several connected factors:
- Signal levels and SNR: More PAM levels increase the need to resolve smaller differences between received amplitudes.
- VCSEL dynamics: Modulation response and nonlinear behavior can distort symbol shape and timing.
- Pre-emphasis and equalization: Transmitter filtering and receiver processing can mitigate bandwidth-related distortion, with implementation trade-offs.
- Latency and complexity: DSP and FEC can support transmission, but may not suit applications that prioritize a simple, low-latency link.
Practical implications for link design
For system integrators and operations teams specifying short-reach optical connections, the central decision is how to balance data rate against signal margin, reach and implementation complexity. OOK can remain appropriate where simplicity or low latency is important. 3-PAM may offer a useful compromise in bandwidth-limited conditions, while 4-PAM can increase spectral efficiency when the transmitter and receiver can support its tighter signal-quality requirements.
Pre-emphasis can improve the use of available bandwidth, but it must be matched to the link and balanced against modulation amplitude. Likewise, equalization and FEC can help manage impairments, but their value depends on system requirements. A disciplined evaluation compares formats and signal-conditioning options using the VCSEL response and complete link behavior, rather than relying on data rate alone.
Conclusion
PAM and pre-emphasis provide practical options for increasing throughput in VCSEL optical links without treating bandwidth as the only design variable. 4-PAM offers higher spectral efficiency than OOK at the same symbol rate, while 3-PAM can serve as an intermediate option with different sensitivity to VCSEL dynamics. Pre-emphasis and receiver equalization can further address bandwidth limitations, but introduce their own constraints and complexity. For reliable deployment, engineers should select the modulation and signal-conditioning strategy that fits the measured behavior and operational priorities of the full link.