Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Virginia economic development incentives are not a single type of grant with a common payment schedule or performance test. The Commonwealth’s programs serve different goals, from supporting workforce training and job creation to encouraging manufacturing investment and improvements to industrial property. For plant managers, system integrators and other business decision-makers, understanding how these programs measure results is essential to interpreting the reported figures.

A Virginia Economic Development Partnership (VEDP) report covering fiscal years 2014 through 2018 compiled information on 17 incentive programs administered by nine entities. Across that period, $386.6 million was awarded to 2,247 projects. The report’s most useful lesson is that award totals alone do not explain what a program delivered: the eligibility rules, performance measures, project status and timing of payments all matter.

Virginia economic development incentives measure different outcomes

Each program has its own purpose and metrics. Some focus on jobs created and wages; others track capital investment, employee training, retained employment or purchases of Virginia-grown agricultural and forestry products. That means two grants with similar dollar values may be designed to produce very different outcomes.

For example, the Virginia Jobs Investment Program (VJIP) supports new jobs, retraining and small-business hiring. It tracks jobs created or retrained, wages and capital investment. By contrast, the Investment Partnership Grant is intended to encourage continued investment by existing manufacturers or research and development services that support manufacturing. It does not require new job creation, but existing employment must be maintained over time.

Other programs are tied to specific activities or locations. Enterprise Zone grants support job creation and real property investment in designated communities. The Agriculture and Forestry Industries Incentive Grant focuses in part on new purchases of Virginia-grown products. A program’s performance should therefore be assessed against its own stated objectives—not against a single portfolio-wide measure.

Grant structure shapes what the reported results mean

Performance agreements and payment rules determine when a grant is paid and what happens if a project falls short. Some programs pay after a company or locality meets agreed milestones. Others require applicants to document qualified activity before applying. Agreements may also include clawback provisions, which can require funds to be repaid if obligations are not met.

The timing can be lengthy. The report describes programs in which performance periods are typically 36 months, while certain VEDP grant subfunds have a typical 10-year structure: five years to meet milestones followed by five years of payments. In those cases, an incentive award is a commitment, not necessarily an amount already disbursed. Funds may be appropriated in the years when payment is due rather than when the original agreement is signed.

Some grants are paid only after proof of performance. The Enterprise Zone Job Creation Grant, for instance, is applied for after eligible jobs have been created. From FY2014 through FY2018, it awarded about $12.7 million across 298 projects. The report states that all projects met their targets, noting that the program pays after completion has been demonstrated. That result should be read alongside the program’s design: it measures approved, qualifying applications rather than every business that might have considered applying.

Separate awards, milestones and completed projects

A useful way to read incentive data is to distinguish three stages:

  • Award: The program commits an incentive to a project, often against expected jobs, investment or other targets.
  • Milestone: The administering entity records the latest available progress, which may not coincide with a formal contractual milestone.
  • Completion: The reporting entity closes the project through its administrative process.

These categories are not interchangeable. A project can be marked complete without meeting all—or any—of its performance measures. According to the report, a company that fails to meet the measures may not receive the incentive or may be required to repay it, depending on the program’s rules. Completion status alone is therefore not proof that targets were achieved.

VJIP illustrates why the reporting period matters. Across FY2014–FY2018, 460 projects were awarded incentives, while 221 were listed as completed in the completed-project table. Those completed projects were associated with 9,074 actual jobs created against 29,600 incentivized jobs, or 31% of that target measure. The report cautions that VJIP reimbursements are limited to the jobs listed on an application, and that projects can be at different stages. The completed-project figures should not be mistaken for a final assessment of every award in the cohort.

Compare outcomes with timing and program rules in view

For technical and operational decision-makers evaluating an incentive, a practical review should include more than the headline award. Ask:

  • Which outcomes does the program measure—jobs, wages, investment, training, retained employment or another result?
  • Are the figures expected targets, verified milestones or results from completed projects?
  • When are payments made, and are funds contingent on meeting performance requirements?
  • Does the agreement include repayment provisions, and how are missed targets handled?
  • Could the reporting window exclude projects that are still underway?

These questions also help when comparing programs. A grant that reports substantial investment but few completed projects cannot be evaluated on the same basis as a program that approves applications only after qualifying activity has occurred. Differences in reporting stage and program design can explain why appropriations, awards and payments do not match in a given fiscal year.

Use incentive data as a decision tool, not a standalone verdict

Virginia’s incentive portfolio spans business expansion, manufacturing, workforce development and community investment. Its reported results are most informative when read in the context of each program’s purpose, agreement terms and project timeline. For companies considering an incentive, that means examining eligibility, performance obligations and payment conditions before treating an award as available funding. For public and operational leaders, it means distinguishing commitments from disbursements and ongoing projects from verified outcomes.

The practical takeaway is straightforward: assess each incentive against its own metrics, and interpret every number according to its status and timing. That approach provides a clearer view of what a program is designed to support—and what its reported performance can, and cannot, demonstrate.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author