Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

For engineers developing micro-optical structures on zinc sulfide (ZnS), controlling material removal without compromising surface quality is a central process challenge. ZnS ICP etching using a methane, hydrogen, and argon (CH4/H2/Ar) plasma offers a way to balance chemical reactions with physical ion bombardment. Experimental results show that gas composition—particularly the argon fraction—has a substantial influence on both etch rate and surface roughness.

Under the reported process conditions, the etch rate reached 18.5 nm/min, while the minimum measured surface roughness was Ra 6.3 nm. These results provide a useful starting point for understanding how gas flow, plasma power, and substrate bias interact when tuning a dry etch for ZnS.

Why use ICP for ZnS dry etching?

ZnS is a wide-bandgap II-VI semiconductor used in optoelectronic applications. Its optical properties make it a candidate substrate for micro-optical devices, but its chemical stability at normal temperatures makes wet etching difficult. Dry etching is therefore used to define features in the material.

Chlorine-based plasma chemistries can etch II-VI semiconductors rapidly, but high etch rates may be unsuitable for fine structures. The study also notes concerns associated with corrosive and toxic halogen gases. Hydrocarbon-based chemistries such as CH4/H2 offer an alternative: polymer formation can help limit lateral etching and support more anisotropic profiles. However, reaction products and hydrocarbon polymers may remain on the substrate or chamber surfaces, creating a need to manage deposition.

Inductively coupled plasma (ICP) systems generate a high-density plasma while allowing substrate ion energy to be adjusted separately through bias power. This separation helps process engineers tune plasma generation and ion bombardment as distinct, though interacting, variables.

How the CH4/H2/Ar chemistry removes ZnS

In the described process, methane and hydrogen provide the chemical component of the etch. Plasma-generated species react with zinc and sulfur to form products including zinc dimethyl, Zn(CH3)2, and hydrogen sulfide, H2S. The study describes H2S as readily volatile, while Zn(CH3)2 requires physical bombardment to help remove it from the surface.

Argon supports that removal through ion bombardment. It also dilutes the reactive gases and helps stabilize the plasma. The etch therefore depends on a balance: chemical reactions generate products, while physical sputtering assists in clearing less-volatile material. If products accumulate on the substrate, they can inhibit further etching and contribute to a rougher surface.

How process parameters affect ZnS ICP etching

Total gas flow

The experiments varied total gas flow from 26 to 78 sccm. Because the equipment’s chamber pressure changed with flow and could not be adjusted independently, changing flow also changed the pressure conditions. The etch rate initially rose as flow increased, then fell at higher flows. Surface roughness changed relatively little below 50 sccm and increased as flow went above that level.

At higher flow, the study attributes the deterioration to increased pressure and plasma recombination, which can reduce effective plasma concentration and weaken bombardment. Reaction products may also be less effectively removed, allowing deposits to build up on the etched surface and feature sidewalls. The lowest reported roughness occurred at a total flow of 39 sccm.

Argon content

With the CH4:H2 ratio held at 1:7, the argon proportion was varied. At lower argon content, physical removal of reaction products was limited; deposits could inhibit etching and increase roughness. As argon increased, stronger ion bombardment helped clear Zn(CH3)2 from the surface, and the etch rate rose while roughness fell up to a balance point reported near 38% argon.

Above that region, the trends became less straightforward: the etch rate first decreased and then increased, while roughness increased with additional argon. At high argon fractions, physical etching becomes more prominent. Because the study characterizes physical etching as isotropic, maximizing argon is not necessarily desirable when profile control matters.

Bias power and ICP RF power

Bias power influences the energy with which ions and reactive species reach the substrate. As bias power increased, the measured etch rate rose. Roughness first decreased and then increased, with a relatively smooth surface reported around 80 W. At low bias, insufficient bombardment can limit reaction-product removal; increasing bias improves removal, but still higher power does not continue to improve roughness.

ICP RF power primarily affects plasma generation. Increasing RF power raises the production of plasma species and strengthens the chemical and physical contributions to etching, so the etch rate increased across the tested range. Surface roughness again followed a non-monotonic trend, decreasing before rising at higher power. The study associates the higher-power increase with reaction products that are not removed quickly enough and may redeposit on the sample or chamber.

Reported process window and practical considerations

The study identifies the following conditions as a suitable balance between etch rate and surface quality:

  • Gas ratio: CH4:H2:Ar = 1:7:5
  • Total gas flow: 39 sccm
  • Bias power: 80 W
  • ICP RF power: 300 W
  • Reported etch rate: 18.5 nm/min
  • Minimum reported roughness: Ra 6.3 nm

These values are specific to the reported equipment and experimental setup, including its pressure behavior and cooling conditions. They should be treated as a process reference rather than assumed to transfer unchanged to other ICP tools, chamber geometries, or ZnS devices. The work also notes that hydrocarbon polymer generated through interaction with photoresist can deposit on feature surfaces and sidewalls. Alternating CH4/H2/Ar etching with O2 cleaning was identified as a possible approach to address polymer buildup; it is a consideration for process development, not a reported performance result.

Conclusion: balance removal, rate, and surface finish

ZnS ICP etching with CH4/H2/Ar depends on coordinating chemical reaction and physical sputtering. Gas flow affects both plasma conditions and chamber pressure, argon helps remove less-volatile products, bias power controls bombardment at the substrate, and RF power influences plasma generation. The reported 39 sccm, 1:7:5 gas ratio, 80 W bias, and 300 W RF settings achieved an etch rate of 18.5 nm/min and Ra of 6.3 nm in the described setup. For process engineers, the key implication is to optimize these variables together: pursuing higher etch rate or greater ion bombardment alone may increase roughness or deposition, while a balanced process can better support controlled ZnS feature fabrication.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author