Operational transformation consulting can remain important when an industrial company enters financial restructuring. Valaris plc’s 2020 Chapter 11 filing illustrates how a business sought to continue a pre-existing consulting engagement focused on operating costs, procurement and organizational change while also addressing the court’s requirements for professional retention and payment.
The filing concerned work that began before the bankruptcy cases, rather than a new consulting program created for the restructuring. Valaris asked the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas to authorize McKinsey Recovery & Transformation Services and certain affiliates to complete the remaining term of their service contract. The application described the work as ordinary-course operational support and stated that the engagement was scheduled to conclude on September 30, 2020.
Operational transformation consulting during restructuring
Valaris, an offshore drilling company, said it had already been pursuing operational initiatives in response to market conditions. The company described efforts to reduce costs and improve efficiency, including asset sales, external-spend initiatives, reductions in employee headcount and lower planned capital expenditures. These measures were presented as business initiatives that predated and were independent of the Chapter 11 filing.
The consulting work was intended to support this broader operational transformation. According to the application, the consultants had been engaged in 2019 and continued to work under agreements dated December 2019 and April 2020, as amended in July 2020. The Debtors asked the court to approve retention effective from the bankruptcy petition date, August 19, 2020, so the existing contract could be completed.
This distinction mattered to the request. Valaris argued that the services were directed at operating the business, not at administering the bankruptcy case. The company nevertheless sought court approval out of caution, and because the consultant had indicated it would not accept payment for post-petition services until the application and disclosures were filed and the court approved the arrangement.
Where the consulting work focused
The filing described a practical portfolio of operational work rather than a single technology deployment. Its main areas included external-spend optimization, onshore operational support and organizational design. The consultants had also helped improve standard procurement and supply-chain processes, according to the Debtors.
The application identified initiatives across several functions, including vessel management, facilities and logistics, information technology, human resources, treasury and training. It also described work to establish an outsourced support center in India and move from a geographic organization structure toward a functional one. Valaris said these efforts were intended to streamline workflows, reduce costs and improve productivity.
For industrial leaders, the case underscores that transformation programs often involve connected processes across departments. Procurement changes, for example, can intersect with supply-chain workflows, logistics and business support functions. Organizational redesign can also affect how work is assigned and coordinated across locations. The filing does not describe specific automation systems or technical implementations; its focus is operational and organizational change.
Continuity, coordination and governance
Valaris argued that retaining the existing consultants would preserve their accumulated knowledge of the company’s operations, cost structure, capital requirements, procurement and supply chain. It also said that replacing them near the end of the contract would require a new provider to be brought up to speed. This was the Debtors’ rationale for continuing the engagement, not a general guarantee that incumbent consultants are always the best option.
The application also addressed coordination with other advisers. The proposed professionals agreed to work with the Debtors and other retained professionals to avoid unnecessary duplication. That commitment points to a broader management consideration: transformation work needs clear boundaries when multiple internal teams and external advisers are involved. Defined scopes, accountable owners and coordination routines help clarify who is responsible for each workstream.
In the proposed order included with the filing, the court’s approval was subject to safeguards. These included requirements to seek further approval for services outside the contract, pass through certain contractor costs without markup, and provide conflict disclosures for relevant contractors. The order also modified the contract’s indemnification terms and required court approval before specified indemnification payments could be made. These provisions illustrate how operational continuity can be balanced with oversight during a bankruptcy case.
Fees and reporting arrangements
The contract used fixed monthly fees rather than compensation based on hours worked. The Debtors said the monthly amount reflected the agreed services and a threshold level of consulting resources. They also requested flexibility around detailed time-entry requirements, explaining that the arrangement was not designed around hourly billing.
Instead, the application proposed that invoices identify the amount due and describe the post-petition work, with copies provided to the Debtors, the U.S. Trustee’s Office and any appointed statutory committee. The Debtors requested payment within 30 days, while acknowledging that the court could require a formal fee application with supporting documentation.
The filing stated that no post-petition payments had yet been made and identified a fixed payment of $1,588,333 as the only amount expected to become payable by the estates after the petition date under the existing contract. These details show why payment terms, invoice content and approval processes matter when an ongoing operating engagement crosses into a court-supervised restructuring.
Practical implications for industrial leaders
The Valaris filing offers several considerations for companies managing operational improvement during financial or organizational disruption:
- Separate operational work from restructuring work. Make the scope and purpose of each engagement explicit, especially when a contract predates a major corporate event.
- Preserve continuity deliberately. Existing operational knowledge may be valuable, but leaders should define what remains to be delivered and when the engagement ends.
- Coordinate across workstreams. Procurement, supply chain, logistics and support functions can overlap, so assign clear responsibilities and manage interfaces with other advisers.
- Align commercial terms with oversight. Fixed fees, expense reimbursement, invoice detail and approval requirements should be documented in a way that supports accountability.
For industrial automation and operations teams, the broader lesson is that transformation is not only a matter of selecting technology. It also depends on process design, organizational responsibilities, supplier and spending controls, and disciplined governance. Valaris’s application shows how a company sought to maintain an existing improvement program through Chapter 11 while asking the court to review its scope, costs and contractual protections.