For organizations developing software-enabled services, operational methods or technology that connects digital and physical processes, business method patent examination can be an important part of protecting innovation. A U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) customer partnership meeting held on April 2, 2019, set out to address several parts of that process, including examiner communication, subject matter eligibility, examination quality and drafting claims involving blockchain technology.
The meeting brought together USPTO leaders and staff from Technology Center 3600, alongside patent practitioners, for sessions in Alexandria, Virginia, and Dallas, Texas. Its agenda offers a useful view of the examination topics the office and applicants were seeking to discuss. The published material describes the meeting’s speakers and planned sessions; it does not provide detailed findings or guidance from the presentations themselves.
Business method patent examination and stakeholder dialogue
The program opened with remarks from Andrew Hirshfeld, then Commissioner for Patents, followed by updates from Technology Center 3600 directors Tariq Hafiz and James Trammell. The center oversees examination in business methods, making its leadership a direct point of contact for applicants and representatives seeking to understand examination operations and raise recurring concerns.
A customer partnership meeting can provide a structured setting for discussion between the patent office and the people who interact with the examination system. For technical decision-makers, that kind of engagement matters because patent prosecution involves more than preparing an application: applicants must also communicate with examiners and respond to the issues raised during review. The meeting’s focus on interview practice and an open question-and-answer forum placed that interaction alongside policy and quality topics.
Examiner interviews as a communication tool
An afternoon session was dedicated to interview practice and led by Anita Coupe, a supervisory patent examiner in Technology Center 3600. The agenda identified examiner interview practice as a subject of training and collaboration. Hafiz’s biography also noted his involvement in efforts to train examiners and increase communication between examiners and applicants.
For an applicant, an interview is an opportunity to discuss an application with the examiner handling it. The meeting’s emphasis on practice points to the importance of making that communication a deliberate part of the process. In practical terms, engineering and product teams can support patent counsel by ensuring that the technical purpose of a proposed invention, its operation and the distinctions the applicant considers important are clearly understood before discussions take place. The source material does not prescribe a particular interview strategy, so applicants should treat the session as evidence of the topic’s importance, not as a substitute for case-specific advice.
Subject matter eligibility and examination quality
The agenda also included an update on subject matter eligibility training, presented by Technology Center 3600 quality assurance specialist Jamisue Plucinski. Eligibility was a recurring area of her work, including training for the examining corps. The program did not set out the substance of the update, but its inclusion shows that eligibility questions were a topic the office chose to address with stakeholders.
For organizations filing applications in business methods, software or other technology-driven fields, eligibility is one consideration in patent examination. Technical teams can help their patent professionals by describing the system or process precisely: what it does, how its components relate, and where the technical contribution lies. That factual clarity supports preparation and discussion, although the meeting materials do not state how any particular application should be evaluated.
Patent examination quality was another agenda item, presented by Martin Rater, chief statistician in the Office of Deputy Commissioner for Patent Quality. His responsibilities included statistical work, sampling procedures and data collection supporting quality-control and quality-assurance activities. This reflects the role that review methods and measurement can play in evaluating examination processes. For applicants, quality is relevant not only as an institutional concern but also because examination decisions affect how applications are assessed and prosecuted.
Blockchain claims and emerging technology
The morning program featured a session titled “Blockchain technology: Drafting effective patent claims,” led by attorneys Salvatore P. Tamburo and Ameya V. Paradkar. Their professional backgrounds included patent litigation and counseling involving software and other technologies. The agenda does not include the presentation itself, so it cannot establish particular drafting rules or conclusions about blockchain patentability.
Still, the session’s place on a business methods meeting agenda highlights a practical challenge for applicants working with emerging technologies: claims must communicate the invention in a form that can be examined. For industrial automation organizations, this is relevant when a proposed innovation combines software, data handling, business processes or operational technology. Engineering teams should be prepared to explain the system’s actual implementation and the role of each relevant element, giving patent counsel a clear technical foundation for drafting and prosecution.
What industrial technology teams can take from the meeting
The meeting covered several connected dimensions of the patent process rather than a single technical issue:
- Office operations: updates from leaders responsible for Technology Center 3600.
- Applicant-examiner communication: a dedicated session on interview practice.
- Examination policy: an update focused on subject matter eligibility training.
- Quality oversight: discussion of patent examination quality and its measurement.
- Claim drafting: a session focused on blockchain technology.
For plant managers, engineering leaders and system integrators, the practical implication is to involve technical experts early when developing a patent application. Accurate explanations of a system’s components, operation and intended function can help counsel prepare a clear application and support productive examination discussions. The USPTO meeting also underlines the value of treating patent prosecution as an ongoing exchange, not simply a document submission.
Conclusion
The 2019 customer partnership meeting brought business method patent examination, examiner communication, eligibility, quality and blockchain claim drafting into one program. It did not publish detailed outcomes in the supplied meeting materials, but its agenda identifies issues that matter to organizations pursuing patent protection in software-enabled and process-oriented fields. Technical teams that communicate their inventions precisely and work closely with patent professionals are better positioned to engage thoughtfully with the examination process.