An effective innovation strategy has to address two competing demands: maintaining performance in established businesses and investing in uncertain opportunities that may shape the company’s future. For industrial organizations, where capital allocation, technology development, and operational performance are closely linked, treating those demands as separate can leave promising ideas without the resources or support they need.
Leadership lessons discussed in the 2018 Feigen Advisors New CEO Report point to a recurring risk: a profitable core business can make new ventures appear unattractive, even when they represent a significant technological shift. The report also argues that long-term corporate value depends on broader considerations, including talent, governance, innovation, and societal and environmental impact. Together, these ideas offer a useful framework for industrial executives, plant leaders, and system integrators navigating change.
Why a strong core can make change harder
Companies need to serve existing customers and improve current products. But a narrow focus on those priorities can make it difficult to recognize innovations developing outside the organization’s established markets or business model. New technologies may initially look less proven and less financially attractive than familiar operations. That does not necessarily mean they lack strategic importance.
The report illustrates this challenge with Xerox and IBM. At Xerox’s Palo Alto Research Center, engineers developed advanced computing concepts, including networked workstations and graphical interfaces. Yet the company’s internal investment decisions favored its established copier business over uncertain projects. Some of the technology was later commercialized by companies outside Xerox.
IBM faced a comparable tension between an emerging UNIX-based server and its highly profitable AS400 business. The newer system’s projected revenue could not readily compete with the established product’s financial results in the near term. The report’s central point is not that every experimental project should receive funding. It is that current profitability can skew comparisons when uncertain innovation is assessed using the same assumptions as a mature business.
Build innovation into capital allocation
For industrial companies, this lesson applies wherever emerging technology or a new business model challenges established ways of working. A project may require time to resolve technical and market uncertainty, while existing operations offer more predictable returns. If funding decisions are based only on near-term, directly comparable financial measures, ideas with longer development horizons can struggle to advance.
Leaders can reduce this risk by making innovation a regular part of strategic and capital-allocation discussions. That means asking not only whether a proposal can outperform the current business immediately, but also what assumptions underlie the comparison and what future position the investment could help secure.
- Review emerging threats and opportunities: Routinely examine technologies and competitors beyond the company’s current product or market boundaries.
- Make uncertainty explicit: Distinguish the risks and time horizons of a new initiative from the economics of a mature operation.
- Test strategic relevance: Consider whether an investment could help the organization respond to a meaningful shift, even if its early financial case is less certain.
- Keep decisions visible: Ensure leaders can see where proposals are being delayed or rejected and understand the rationale.
This approach does not guarantee that any specific innovation will succeed. It helps ensure that established profitability does not automatically determine which opportunities the organization is willing to explore.
Connect long-term value to measurable goals
Innovation is only one part of long-term business resilience. The report’s discussion of inclusive capitalism emphasizes that companies also need to consider how they create value for employees, customers, owners, and society. It identifies talent, corporate governance, innovation, and societal and environmental impact as important drivers that traditional financial statements may not fully capture.
For industrial leaders, the practical challenge is to make these considerations part of management rather than leaving them as broad statements of intent. The report calls for environmental, social, and governance (ESG) goals to be embedded in strategy, measured, and discussed regularly at board level. It also notes that differing ESG questionnaires and non-comparable scores make it difficult to assess performance consistently.
That observation has a clear implication: leaders should be deliberate about which goals are material to their business and how progress will be evaluated. Metrics should help decision-makers understand performance and trade-offs, rather than simply add another reporting layer. The report’s argument is that financial and ESG goals are connected, and that attention to long-term drivers should complement—not replace—financial discipline.
What new CEOs and established teams can do
A leadership transition can create an opportunity to reassess strategy, investment priorities, and measures of success. But the underlying responsibilities apply to current executives as well. Whether leading a large enterprise or an industrial operation, decision-makers can use several questions to focus the discussion:
- Are we scanning beyond our existing customers, products, and operating assumptions?
- Could our evaluation process favor familiar returns over strategically important, uncertain opportunities?
- Are innovation and other long-term value drivers discussed alongside financial performance?
- Do our goals have clear measures and appropriate oversight?
These questions help connect strategic intent to practical governance. They also make it easier to recognize when a business is protecting today’s performance at the expense of its ability to respond to change.
Conclusion: protect today’s performance without neglecting tomorrow
The core lesson is not to abandon profitable operations or invest indiscriminately in every new idea. It is to avoid letting current success become the sole filter for future decisions. The Xerox and IBM examples show how financial comparisons can disadvantage emerging innovation, while the report’s discussion of ESG highlights the need to identify and measure longer-term sources of value.
For industrial decision-makers, a durable approach combines disciplined operations with active scanning for disruption, thoughtful evaluation of uncertain investments, and measurable strategic goals. That balance can help organizations serve current needs while remaining prepared to adapt as technologies, markets, and stakeholder expectations change.