Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Processor radiation testing is essential when selecting computing hardware for space missions, where radiation can disrupt operation in ways that are not captured by a simple memory-bit error rate. Evaluating a processor means considering its architecture, operating system, workload, and configuration alongside the radiation response of individual device structures. A NASA Electronic Parts and Packaging Program effort described in 2018 illustrates why these system-level questions matter for both commercial processors and radiation-hardened designs.

Why processor radiation testing needs a system-level view

Radiation testing can help identify failure sensitivities and modes in advanced CMOS devices and provide guidance for project-specific qualification. It can also build knowledge about emerging architectures, fabrication technologies, and methods for evaluating processors used in flight systems. This is particularly relevant as computing designs move toward multicore systems-on-chip (SoCs), graphics processors, and other architectures that differ substantially from older, simpler devices.

Single-event effects (SEEs) can affect more than stored data. A device may experience a crash or another functional interruption, and test results can depend on what software is running and how heavily the processor is being used. For this reason, a useful evaluation needs to connect radiation exposure to observable system behavior—not just count bit upsets.

Testing also has a practical role: it can inform radiation qualification plans without replacing the responsibility of a flight project to evaluate the specific part and application it intends to use. Shared methods and reports help projects make better-informed decisions, while application-specific testing addresses the details of the actual system.

Designing workloads for processor radiation testing

A processor under test (DUT) should be exercised with workloads that represent relevant functions and expose behavior across the system. In the 2018 Snapdragon 835 work, the available development board ran Android, and the test approach used debugging utilities such as Android Debug Bridge. The team planned to run a suite of programs during irradiation and compare debug output under the beam with nominal output, where data remained available before a crash.

The applications included memory tests and matrix operations such as transpose and multiplication, as well as image rotation. Memory testing was considered useful because it could exercise memory more effectively than register-focused tests while an operating system was running. Camera and sensor applications were also considered, but were lower priority in that effort. The board’s software and package-on-package implementation shaped what could be tested; the stated setup did not provide a path to install Linux.

Choosing workloads carefully matters. Running several programs that produce essentially the same data can add effort without adding useful coverage. At the same time, test designers need to account for the difficulty of exposing some systems to heavy ions: earlier Snapdragon 820 testing showed that a crash could occur before many exposures were completed.

Use performance and debug data as evidence

Available monitoring tools can provide context for interpreting results. For the Snapdragon platform, the profiler exposed CPU measures such as cache misses, branch misses, clock and core utilization, cycles, instructions, and page faults. It also reported memory utilization and DDR frequency, along with GPU measures including frequency, utilization, memory latency, and data reads and writes.

These indicators do not by themselves establish radiation tolerance. They can, however, help characterize the device’s operating state and support comparisons between nominal behavior and behavior during exposure. Test documentation should make clear which outputs were available, which workloads were active, and whether the system returned data before failure.

Commercial and radiation-hardened processors pose different questions

Commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) processors offer access to newer manufacturing processes and architectures, but they may come with limited documentation or constraints imposed by their development boards and software environments. The 2018 program’s targets included commercial mobile SoCs, Intel and AMD processors, and GPUs, alongside radiation-hardened microcontrollers and processors. Those device examples describe the program’s plans at that time, rather than a current product roadmap.

Radiation-hardened-by-design (RHBD) processors raise a related but distinct measurement challenge. The effort noted that bit-level SEE behavior does not tell the whole story for modern processors. A single bit error rate may fail to represent how a complex device performs across functional units, configurations, and workloads. Comparing a high-performance processor with an older flight processor therefore requires more than comparing raw processing capability or a single radiation metric.

For RHBD systems, the evaluation approach under development aimed to relate radiation response to functional units and to examine how tolerance changes with device configuration and performance per power. The work also sought to compare high-performance operation with high-reliability configurations. These questions are important when fault tolerance is built into a system, because the relevant measure is how the complete system performs under radiation—not simply whether individual bits are hardened.

Building a repeatable evaluation strategy

A practical processor evaluation program can organize its work around several connected areas:

  • Architecture: Identify the processor or FPGA-based design and the features that influence its use.
  • Implementation: Record the device form factor, board, operating system, and accessible test interfaces.
  • Workload: Select applications that exercise relevant functions without unnecessary duplication.
  • Radiation response: Define the exposure and observations needed to characterize effects such as crashes and data deviations.
  • Use case: Relate results to the intended mission function and the project’s qualification needs.

Consistency in these areas supports more meaningful comparisons across devices. The 2018 effort also emphasized test guidelines, radiation reports, collaboration with manufacturers and research partners, and a shared knowledge base of processor architectures and evaluation methods. That foundation is especially useful when a device is difficult to test or when public documentation is limited.

Conclusion: Evaluate the processor in context

Processor radiation testing is most informative when it connects radiation exposure to system behavior under defined operating conditions. Workloads, operating systems, debug access, device configuration, and performance monitoring all affect what a test can reveal. For commercial and radiation-hardened processors alike, engineers should look beyond isolated bit-level results and develop measures that relate radiation response to useful system function. The practical outcome is a stronger evidence base for selecting hardware and planning the project-specific qualification needed for a mission.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author