SOI pixel detectors combine a silicon sensing volume and CMOS readout circuitry in a single device. For engineers developing X-ray imaging or charged-particle measurement systems, this architecture offers a compact alternative to detectors assembled from separate sensor and readout components. Tests of the INTPIX4 detector show how the choice between Float Zone (FZ) and Czochralski (Cz) silicon influences important design trade-offs, including leakage current, spatial resolution and depletion voltage.
How SOI pixel detectors combine sensing and readout
A silicon-on-insulator detector is formed by bonding a thick, high-resistivity silicon wafer used for particle sensing to a thin, low-resistivity silicon layer that contains the CMOS circuits. Because the sensing and readout functions are integrated, the design avoids mechanical bump bonding between separate detector and electronics dies. The CMOS process can also support complex functions within individual pixels.
The reported detectors use a 0.2 μm fully depleted, low-leakage SOI CMOS process. A buried oxide separates the thin circuit layer from the sensing substrate, while a buried p-well structure is used in each pixel to address the back-gate effect. The sensing substrate can be illuminated from either the front or the back, enabling different detector configurations.
One benefit of a fully depleted detector is low capacitance at the sensing node. The reported value is approximately 10 fF per pixel, supporting high conversion gain and low noise. These characteristics matter in imaging and measurement systems where the readout must distinguish signals generated by individual X-rays or charged particles.
INTPIX4: an integration-type imaging detector
INTPIX4 was developed primarily for X-ray imaging. Its active area measures 8.704 × 14.144 mm and contains 512 × 832 pixels, each 17 × 17 μm. Each pixel includes a correlated double sampling (CDS) circuit with two capacitors. CDS helps reduce reset noise by sampling and comparing signal levels during readout.
The detector has 13 parallel output lines and is operated with a separate evaluation board, SEABAS2. The board includes analog-to-digital conversion, digital-to-analog conversion, FPGA-based control and a Gigabit Ethernet connection to a data-acquisition computer. With one INTPIX4 chip, the reported readout rate was approximately 90 frames per second.
In a demonstration, the system captured a medical stent wire using 33.3 keV monochromatic X-rays. The wire, which was 40 μm in diameter, was visible in images acquired with a 200 μs integration time. This illustrates the detector’s imaging and readout capabilities without implying that the system is a production inspection solution.
FZ and Cz silicon: balancing leakage current and resolution
The main comparison is between detectors made with FZ and Cz sensing wafers. The reported Cz substrate had a resistivity above 700 Ω-cm and a thickness of 260 μm. The FZ substrate exceeded 7 kΩ-cm in resistivity and was 500 μm thick. The higher-resistivity FZ material enabled a thicker sensing volume, while also changing the voltage required for full depletion.
Measurements showed lower leakage current in the FZ detector than in the Cz detector. Lower leakage current can be useful when evaluating detector noise and operating conditions, although system-level performance still depends on the complete detector and readout configuration.
Thickness introduces a spatial-resolution trade-off. At 20 line pairs per millimeter, the measured contrast transfer function (CTF) was 66% for the 500 μm FZ detector and 78% for the 260 μm Cz detector. The authors attributed the difference in part to charge spreading: electron-hole pairs generated by X-rays spread as they drift through the silicon, and the thicker FZ sensing volume allows more spreading. This is a useful design consideration when selecting substrate thickness for an imaging task.
Signal performance and operating voltage
Other reported measurements indicate broadly comparable signal behavior for the two substrate types. The FZ detector’s circuit gain was 0.87 ± 0.02, compared with 0.823 ± 0.001 for the Cz detector. For X-ray energy measurements, the FZ detector produced a gain of 13.1 μV per electron and a full-width at half-maximum of 624 electrons at 17.48 keV, corresponding to 12.8%. The reported Cz results were also described as consistent, though they were measured at a different X-ray energy.
Electrical characterization helps clarify the voltage requirements. The FZ detector showed no significant breakdown up to 500 V across tests from −60°C to +20°C. Its full-depletion voltage was measured at approximately 321–325 V, depending on measurement frequency. The Cz detector reached full depletion at approximately 238–239 V under the reported measurement conditions. The thicker FZ substrate therefore required a higher depletion voltage.
The leakage-current temperature measurements gave an activation energy of 0.55 eV for FZ silicon at 30 V, close to the reported Cz value of 0.56 eV. In a beta-ray test using a strontium-90 source, both detector types could observe minimum-ionizing particles. The reported signal-to-noise ratios were approximately 75 for FZ and 18 for Cz in the respective test configurations; these results should be interpreted in the context of their differing thicknesses, bias voltages and integration times.
Practical implications for detector selection
For engineers specifying X-ray or particle-detection equipment, the comparison highlights why substrate selection should be tied to the measurement objective rather than a single headline metric. FZ silicon offered lower leakage current and a thicker sensing volume, but required a higher voltage for full depletion and showed lower CTF at the finest tested pattern than the thinner Cz detector.
INTPIX4 demonstrates how monolithic SOI architecture can integrate pixel-level readout with a silicon sensing layer and support high-speed image acquisition. When assessing this approach for an imaging or instrumentation project, consider the required spatial resolution, sensing depth, bias-voltage range, noise behavior and readout needs together. The reported results show that FZ and Cz detectors can both provide useful signal performance, while their material and thickness differences shape the trade-offs that matter in system design.