Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Solar street lighting can address a road-safety need while generating electricity close to where it is used. A proposal for a 5.5-mile stretch of North Dakota Highway 281 on the Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa reservation offers a useful comparison of three approaches: conventional grid-connected lights, a solar microgrid and individual stand-alone solar lights. The assessment highlights how infrastructure access, installation costs and ongoing electricity expenses shape a project’s choice of system.

Why Highway 281 needed a lighting plan

Highway 281 is the main route through the reservation, where residents also walk along the road shoulders because there is no walking or bike path. The route is busy, and the stretch between the west end of Belcourt and an area west of the Sky Dancer Casino and Resort was identified as a particular safety concern. The paper documented 17 deaths on the highway from 2008 to 2017, including six pedestrians and one bicyclist.

The proposed project would add lighting between mile markers 239 and 245. Its purpose is practical: improve visibility along a dark corridor while considering a renewable energy option that reflects the community’s interest in protecting the environment. For engineers and project planners, it also illustrates why lighting design must account for more than the fixture itself. Power supply, civil installation, maintenance and operating costs all affect the decision.

Solar street lighting system options

Grid-connected LED lighting

Traditional street lights draw electricity from the utility grid. Modern LED lamps can improve energy efficiency compared with older lighting technologies, but the installation still requires poles, electrical work and access to power. The Highway 281 estimate assumed 108 lights spaced about 270 feet apart across 5.5 miles. Using the paper’s estimated unit, installation and labor costs, initial project costs were approximately $361,387, before electricity expenses.

The analysis estimated electricity for the lights at about $110,810 per year, based on 12 hours of operation each day and the electricity rate used in the assessment. This recurring cost is a key distinction from an off-grid design. The paper also noted a nearby substation, making grid-connected lighting technically possible, although extending electrical service and installing the system would still involve substantial project costs.

Solar lighting with a microgrid

A microgrid is a local electrical network that can operate alongside the main grid or, when equipped with generation and energy storage, independently. For street lighting, a centralized solar array and battery system could supply multiple fixtures. This differs from a stand-alone arrangement, where each light has its own power system.

The Highway 281 assessment estimated that a 93 kW solar system would be needed for the proposed lighting and projected a total project cost of about $752,000. Its comparison indicated a payback period of roughly seven years when set against the estimated annual grid-electricity expense. These figures were preliminary estimates, not a detailed engineering design or final procurement cost. Site requirements, including the potential need to acquire land for the solar installation, could change the project cost.

Stand-alone solar street lights

Each stand-alone solar light combines a photovoltaic panel, a battery and power-management components. During daylight, the panel generates direct-current electricity, which is regulated by a charge controller and stored in the battery. After dark, the stored energy supplies the light. Depending on the equipment and load, the system may also use an inverter to provide alternating current.

This configuration avoids connecting every light to the utility grid or building a central microgrid. Battery capacity and energy management matter because stored power must support operation when sunlight is unavailable. The source notes that charge controllers help prevent battery overcharging and that system operation should account for battery condition and energy use.

For 108 lights, the paper estimated a total installation cost of $484,000, using an assumed cost of $3,500 per light and pole plus $1,000 for installation. Unlike the grid-connected option, the stand-alone estimate did not include a continuing electricity bill. Comparing the initial cost with the estimated annual grid-electricity expense produced a simple payback estimate of just over four years. The assessment also acknowledged that maintenance, including replacement bulbs and batteries, would still be required.

How photovoltaic power supports lighting

Photovoltaic cells convert sunlight into electricity through semiconductor materials. In a grid-connected PV system, an inverter converts the panels’ direct-current output to alternating current for use by electrical loads. Any electricity not used may be exported to the grid where the applicable arrangement allows it.

In an off-grid system, the electricity typically passes through a charge controller before charging batteries. Stored energy can then supply DC loads directly or pass through an inverter for AC equipment. A power-management system helps regulate generation and use. A stand-alone street light applies these basic principles at the individual fixture level, while a microgrid coordinates power for a group of lights from a shared local system.

Comparing the alternatives

The estimates in the assessment point to different cost profiles:

  • Grid-connected LED lighting: About $361,387 in initial project costs, plus an estimated $110,810 in annual electricity costs.
  • Solar microgrid: About $752,000 in estimated total project costs, with the potential to avoid the modeled grid-electricity expense after installation.
  • Stand-alone solar lights: About $484,000 in estimated installation costs, without a recurring utility electricity bill, but with ongoing maintenance needs.

These figures should be treated as planning estimates from the assessment, not current vendor quotes or a substitute for detailed design. Before selecting a system, project teams would need to confirm lighting requirements, site conditions, equipment and battery specifications, installation needs, maintenance plans and any land requirements.

Practical implications for project teams

The recommendation in the Highway 281 assessment was to pursue stand-alone solar street lights. On the estimates presented, this option cost less than the solar microgrid and avoided the annual electricity expense associated with conventional grid-connected lighting. It also aligned the safety project with the community’s interest in renewable energy.

For industrial and infrastructure decision-makers, the broader lesson is to compare lifecycle considerations rather than fixture prices alone. The best-fit architecture depends on where power is available, whether a centralized system is practical, how energy will be stored and managed, and what maintenance the site can support. In this case, the analysis favored individual solar systems as a way to illuminate a specific road corridor without extending grid service to every light. A project-specific engineering and cost review remains essential before implementation.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author