Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Technology equity compensation can help companies recruit, retain and motivate employees, but it also creates trade-offs involving dilution, shareholder expectations and reported expense. A 2018 review of 150 publicly traded software, hardware and semiconductor companies illustrates how those considerations appeared across the sector. Its figures reflect fiscal years ending from March 2017 through February 2018, so they are a historical snapshot rather than a description of current market conditions.

The analysis offers a useful framework for technical and business leaders evaluating incentive-plan design: look beyond the number of awards granted and consider the award mix, annual share usage, cumulative plan commitments, grant value and financial-statement impact together.

Equity award choices were shifting away from options

Stock options were becoming less prevalent in the surveyed group. Just 51% of companies granted options in the most recent fiscal year reviewed, compared with 65% in the prior year. By contrast, nearly all companies granted time-based restricted stock or restricted stock units (RSUs), and 61% granted performance-based awards.

Options may require more shares to deliver a given grant value than full-value awards, contributing to concerns about dilution. The report also identifies uncertainty about options’ retention effectiveness and proxy advisory firms’ treatment of options as performance-based awards as factors in their declining use.

RSUs and restricted stock awards were close to universal in the sample. Because these full-value awards are not dependent on a share price rising above an exercise price to hold value for employees, they can provide a different incentive structure from options. Performance-based awards, meanwhile, tie vesting to specified performance conditions. Their prevalence varied by sector: semiconductor companies were most likely to grant them, at 71%, while use in hardware rose to 58%.

How to interpret equity award burn rate

Gross burn rate measures the number of shares granted during a year relative to weighted average shares outstanding. In the study, it was adjusted to account for the different share usage associated with full-value awards and options. The measure reflects intended grants, rather than subtracting cancellations and expirations.

The median gross burn rate declined 8% year over year in the latest period examined, reversing increases in several preceding years. The decline was largest in the semiconductor sector, at about 16%. Software companies continued to show the highest burn rates among the three sectors, reflecting their greater emphasis on equity in compensation and pressure to compete for talent. Hardware’s median rate was approximately 5.5% and remained broadly unchanged year over year.

Company size and location also corresponded with different patterns in the survey. Smaller, faster-growing companies used equity at approximately 1.5 times the rate of larger companies. California-headquartered companies had burn rates about 1.5 times those of companies based elsewhere. These findings describe the surveyed group; they do not establish that location or size alone determines an appropriate plan budget.

Overhang captures cumulative commitments

Burn rate focuses on annual grants. Equity plan overhang provides a longer-term view of shares already committed or available for future awards. Issued overhang includes outstanding, unexercised options and unvested full-value awards. Total overhang also includes shares reserved for future grants under active plans.

The distinction matters because awards remain in these calculations for different periods. Options can stay outstanding until exercise or cancellation, potentially for years, while full-value awards generally leave overhang when they vest or are earned. Consequently, an ongoing pattern of grants can compound in a company’s overhang, particularly where an active plan includes an evergreen provision that replenishes shares annually.

About 37% of the surveyed companies had an evergreen provision. Such provisions were more common among software companies and businesses with revenue between $50 million and $400 million. For plan oversight, the practical point is to assess both the current share pool and the way automatic replenishment affects future availability.

Shareholder value transferred adds a dollar-based view

Shareholder value transferred (SVT) complements share-count measures by comparing the aggregate grant-date value of equity awards with market capitalization. The grant value includes option value and the value of restricted and performance awards. In the sample, median grant values rose approximately 14% year over year, while SVT as a percentage of market capitalization fell about 8% at the median.

Results differed across sectors. Software companies’ award values and SVT were approximately 1.75 to 1.9 times those of hardware and semiconductor companies. California-based companies also had higher SVT than companies headquartered elsewhere. These comparisons show why an award budget should be assessed in context rather than by grant value alone.

Stock-based compensation affects financial reporting

Stock-based compensation expense was another area of attention in the review. Median expense increased approximately 16% year over year. The report notes that this expense affects non-GAAP earnings measures when companies choose whether to exclude it, and also has implications for free cash flow. Investors and analysts were paying closer attention to these measures and related public-company disclosures.

Monitoring grant activity therefore involves more than managing dilution. Companies need to understand how plan decisions affect reported expense and how those effects fit with the financial measures stakeholders use to assess performance.

Build an integrated equity-use review

The survey’s central lesson is that no single metric describes equity-plan use. A disciplined review considers:

  • Award mix: which vehicles suit recruitment, motivation and retention objectives.
  • Annual usage: gross burn rate, participation and grant guidelines across employee groups.
  • Cumulative commitments: issued and total overhang, including any evergreen replenishment.
  • Economic value: grant-date value and SVT relative to market capitalization.
  • Financial impact: stock-based compensation expense and its role in reported measures.

For industrial automation companies competing for technical and engineering talent, these measures can inform a broader workforce and compensation discussion. The 2018 figures should not be treated as current benchmarks, but the framework remains useful: evaluate awards against company strategy, employee needs, dilution concerns and financial reporting together. Thoughtful monitoring helps decision-makers understand the consequences of plan choices before setting targets or seeking shareholder support.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author