The second-quarter 2018 results of The Insiders Fund illustrate a recurring question in active vs. passive investing: does trading a portfolio add value compared with holding its existing positions? The fund reported a positive quarter and outperformed the S&P 500 over that period, but a comparison of its previous quarter’s top holdings showed that a simple buy-and-hold approach would have delivered a higher average return.
The figures also highlight how performance, trading outcomes, cash allocation, and market outlook can tell different parts of the same investment story. For investors evaluating an active strategy, the quarter provides a useful example of why results need to be considered across multiple measures and time horizons.
Quarterly performance: a rebound, but a negative year to date
The fund gained 4.60% in June, compared with a 0.62% return for the S&P 500. For the full second quarter, the letter reported a fund return of 4.69%, ahead of the S&P 500’s 3.43% total return. The fund remained down 6.28% for the year to date, while the index was up 2.65% over the same period.
These figures describe different performance windows. The strong June result contributed to a positive quarter, but it did not erase the fund’s earlier losses. Looking at both quarterly and year-to-date returns gives a more complete view than relying on the latest monthly result alone.
Active vs. passive investing: what the holdings comparison showed
To assess the effect of trading, the fund compared its ten leading holdings from the previous quarter as if they had been held from March 29 to June 29, 2018. That hypothetical portfolio had an average gain of 6.10%, compared with the fund’s reported second-quarter return of 4.60% in the comparison table and an S&P 500 gain of 3.43%.
The result does not establish that buy-and-hold will always outperform active management. It does show that, during this particular quarter, the previous top holdings collectively gained more than the fund’s reported return. A comparison like this can help investors ask whether trading decisions improved results, while recognizing that the calculation covers a specific set of holdings and a limited period.
Performance among individual positions varied considerably. Selecta Biosciences gained 30.0% in the buy-and-hold comparison, Facebook rose 21.6%, and Tallgrass Energy gained 16.5%. Other holdings declined: Dentsply Sirona fell 11.8%, Delta Airlines lost 9.6%, and Hain Celestial fell 7.1%. The average return therefore reflects a mix of strong contributors and meaningful losses.
Winners, losers, and trading activity
The fund’s list of top quarterly gainers included Twitter, Selecta Biosciences, Tallgrass Energy, and Alphabet. Its largest listed loss came from Hain Celestial, followed by a Delta January 45 call position and Extreme Networks. These results underline how a portfolio’s overall return can depend on a relatively small number of large gains or losses, as well as the timing of trades.
The letter reported that 57.7% of long trades were profitable, compared with 43.92% of short trades. A win rate alone, however, does not indicate whether a strategy was profitable: it does not show the size of gains relative to losses or the effect of position sizing. The fund also noted that it had made few short sales, limiting the role of those trades in the overall result.
Cash allocation and the manager’s market outlook
At the time of the update, cash represented 58.8% of the fund. The manager described this as the largest cash position in months and connected the cautious stance to limited insider buying and concerns about valuations. The letter also identified trade tensions, uncertainty around the U.S. and China relationship, and rising interest rates as risks to monitor.
A high cash allocation can be part of a manager’s response to perceived market risks, but it also means less of the portfolio is invested in stocks at that point in time. The fund said the allocation could change quickly. Its disclosed holdings included long positions in companies such as Tallgrass Energy, Extreme Networks, and Coty, alongside the substantial cash balance.
What investors can take from the quarter
This review offers several practical considerations for evaluating an actively managed fund:
- Compare consistent periods. Monthly, quarterly, and year-to-date returns can present different pictures of performance.
- Use an appropriate benchmark. The fund’s comparison with the S&P 500 provided context, while the holdings analysis offered a separate view of the trading strategy.
- Look beyond the win rate. The proportion of profitable trades does not explain the magnitude of gains and losses.
- Examine cash alongside returns. Cash levels are part of the portfolio positioning behind reported results.
- Treat a single-quarter comparison as limited evidence. The buy-and-hold calculation covered a defined group of previous holdings and one quarter, not every possible market condition.
Conclusion
The Insiders Fund’s second-quarter 2018 report presents a mixed picture: the fund beat the S&P 500 for the quarter and had a strong June, yet the year-to-date result remained negative and its previous top holdings performed better on a buy-and-hold basis in the quarter examined. For investors weighing active management against a passive approach, the central lesson is to assess returns alongside trading outcomes, portfolio composition, cash exposure, and the length of the comparison period.