Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

The ADA Amendments Act (ADAAA) changed how disability is assessed under the Americans with Disabilities Act. For employers, HR teams and workplace decision-makers, its central message is that determining whether a person meets the definition of disability should not become an overly demanding threshold that prevents consideration of whether discrimination occurred. The law broadened coverage and established interpretive rules that continue to shape disability claims and employment practices.

Why the ADA Amendments Act changed the disability standard

When Congress passed the ADA in 1990, it intended to provide broad protection. But Supreme Court decisions in 1999 and 2002 narrowed the interpretation of disability. Courts often dismissed claims because a person did not meet the disability definition, without reaching the question of whether discrimination had taken place. People with conditions such as diabetes, epilepsy, cancer, depression and back injuries sometimes struggled to establish coverage.

Congress responded in 2008 by passing the ADAAA. It directed that the definition of disability be interpreted in favor of broad coverage, to the maximum extent allowed by the law. Regulations from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and Department of Justice likewise emphasize that the primary purpose of the amendments is to make it easier for people with disabilities to obtain ADA protection.

This does not mean every claim automatically succeeds. It does mean that disability eligibility is generally not meant to demand extensive analysis. The practical focus should be whether the circumstances indicate discrimination, rather than prolonged debate over whether an impairment qualifies.

How courts assess a substantial limitation

For an actual-disability claim, a person generally must show an impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities. The ADAAA relaxed how courts should approach that question. A limitation need not prevent an activity entirely: courts may consider the difficulty, effort, time or pain involved in performing it, and compare the person’s ability with that of most people in the general population.

Courts have allowed claims to proceed where evidence described meaningful limits on activities such as reaching, lifting, walking, sleeping or using a hand. For example, a person unable to raise an arm above shoulder height may have evidence of a limitation in reaching or lifting. In other cases, appellate courts have reversed decisions that applied too narrow a view of the standard.

However, outcomes have not been uniform. Some decisions have acknowledged the ADAAA’s relaxed standard but still found the evidence insufficient. The person bringing a claim must provide information about how the impairment affects a major life activity; simply naming a diagnosis may not establish the necessary limitation.

Episodic conditions and treatment measures

Consider episodic conditions when active

An impairment that comes and goes, or is in remission, may still qualify as a disability if it would substantially limit a major life activity when active. This rule is relevant to conditions such as migraines, asthma, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, cancer and some mental health conditions. A person does not necessarily have to be experiencing symptoms at the time of an employment decision for the condition to qualify.

Courts have considered evidence about what happens during a severe episode, including the duration and effects of symptoms. A condition’s episodic nature, by itself, is not a reason to dismiss it. The key question is whether its active symptoms substantially limit a major life activity. At the same time, separate injuries or flare-ups may be treated as distinct conditions rather than episodes of one continuing impairment, depending on the evidence.

Do not count the benefits of mitigating measures

When determining whether someone has a disability, courts generally must disregard the positive effects of mitigating measures. These may include medication, hearing aids, mobility devices, assistive technology, physical therapy, psychotherapy and reasonable accommodations. Ordinary eyeglasses and contact lenses are an exception to this rule.

The rule does not make the details of treatment irrelevant in every respect. Negative side effects of medication or burdens associated with a treatment regimen may be considered when assessing limitations. Separately, the benefits of a mitigating measure may be relevant when evaluating whether a person can perform essential job functions. A claim still needs evidence of how the condition would affect a major life activity without the measure.

Major life activities and bodily functions

The ADAAA expanded and clarified the activities courts may consider. Examples include walking, lifting, reading, communicating, concentrating, sleeping, breathing and working. Regulations also recognize activities such as sitting, reaching and interacting with others. The statutory and regulatory lists are not exhaustive, and courts have also considered activities such as bending, carrying, pushing and pulling.

The law also recognizes major bodily functions, including the immune, neurological, circulatory, digestive, respiratory and endocrine systems, as well as normal cell growth. This can make a difference when an impairment affects internal bodily processes even if its effect on a familiar activity is less obvious. For example, cancer may affect normal cell growth, while diabetes may affect endocrine function.

Evidence matters when a claim relies on a bodily function that may not be readily understood through everyday observation. A person may be able to describe symptoms and functional effects, but medical evidence may be needed to explain how a particular condition affects an internal bodily function.

The broader “regarded as” path

The ADAAA also broadened the “regarded as” definition. A person may qualify under this provision by showing that an employer took action because of an actual or perceived impairment. The person generally does not have to prove that the employer believed the impairment substantially limited a major life activity.

This route can be important when an employment decision appears to be based on an employer’s perception of a condition. However, the “regarded as” provision does not require employers to provide reasonable accommodations to someone who qualifies only under that prong. The distinction between the different ways of establishing disability can therefore matter to both sides.

Practical implications for workplace decisions

For employers and workplace decision-makers, the ADAAA calls for careful, individualized consideration rather than assumptions based on diagnosis, symptom patterns or treatment. Practical steps include:

  • Focus on the circumstances of the employment decision and whether discrimination may have occurred.
  • Do not dismiss a condition solely because it is episodic, in remission or managed with treatment.
  • Consider the effects of an impairment on major life activities and bodily functions, including pain and the effort required to perform activities.
  • Keep disability eligibility distinct from the separate assessment of essential job functions and reasonable accommodation.
  • Document the evidence and reasoning used in workplace decisions, while avoiding conclusions based only on stereotypes or a person’s diagnosis.

The ADA Amendments Act makes broad coverage the starting point for disability analysis, not a substitute for examining the facts of an individual situation. For organizations, the practical implication is to avoid treating disability eligibility as an unnecessary barrier to evaluating a claim. A thoughtful assessment of impairment, workplace decisions and possible discrimination is more consistent with the law’s intended approach.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author