Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

Chloride-induced corrosion of steel in concrete is a durability concern for infrastructure owners and the teams responsible for assessing reinforced-concrete assets. The chloride threshold in carbon steel—the chloride concentration at which a protective passive film breaks down—depends on the surrounding chemistry and the condition of that film. Tests on HPB335 carbon steel in simulated concrete pore solutions illustrate how pH, electrochemical measurements and point defect theory can be used to examine this transition.

The results are relevant to engineers interpreting corrosion tests, but they are not a universal threshold for concrete structures. The experiments used controlled laboratory solutions, and the researchers emphasize that chloride thresholds vary with environmental and material factors.

Why the passive film matters

Concrete’s highly alkaline pore environment can support formation of a dense oxide film on carbon steel. While intact, this passive layer limits corrosion. Carbonation can lower alkalinity, and chloride ions can damage the film; if the steel depassivates, localized pitting may follow.

A single chloride concentration cannot describe the onset of corrosion in every case. The threshold can be influenced by steel surface condition, material characteristics and the solution’s balance of aggressive and inhibitive ions. This variability makes it important to evaluate steel under conditions that reflect the particular environment being considered.

How the study assessed the chloride threshold in carbon steel

The researchers examined HPB335 plain carbon steel in three simulated pore solutions. Their pH values were 13.6, 13.5 and 12.9. The solutions also differed in composition, including the presence and concentration of bicarbonate. The steel was allowed to passivate before sodium chloride was added in measured increments.

Three electrochemical approaches provided complementary information:

  • Open-circuit potential (OCP) tracked changes in the steel’s electrochemical state without applying an external polarization.
  • Linear polarization resistance (LPR) measured resistance near the open-circuit potential, helping identify changes associated with loss of passivity.
  • Mott–Schottky analysis assessed the semiconductor behavior and estimated properties of the passive film.

The team also used potentiodynamic polarization and the point defect model (PDM) to investigate film breakdown. These techniques address different parts of the corrosion process: monitoring the transition, characterizing the film, and examining mechanisms that may lead to rupture.

pH and passive-film properties shaped the results

OCP measurements rose as the steel passivated and generally stabilized after about six days. The lower-pH solution showed a higher passive potential, while the two solutions with similar, higher pH had broadly similar potential development. Mott–Schottky plots indicated n-type semiconductor behavior and a shape consistent with a film containing more than one donor state. The researchers interpreted this as evidence of a layered passive film, with a denser inner barrier layer and a more porous outer layer.

In the chloride-addition tests, the estimated thresholds were approximately 2.8 mol/L in the pH 13.6 solution, 2.6 mol/L in the pH 13.5 solution and 0.6 mol/L in the pH 12.9 solution. The sharp declines in OCP and LPR helped identify the transition toward pitting. These values apply to the specific steel, solution compositions and test procedure; they should not be treated as general design limits for reinforced concrete.

The analysis linked threshold variation with passive-film characteristics, including donor density, estimated thickness and resistance. In these tests, higher donor density was associated with a lower threshold, while greater estimated film thickness corresponded to a higher one. The researchers also reported an inverse relationship between measured film resistance and chloride threshold. That result is specific to their measurements and illustrates why no single film property should be used in isolation to predict corrosion resistance.

What the point defect model adds

The PDM describes passive-film formation and breakdown in terms of defects that move through the oxide layer and are generated or consumed at its interfaces. In the proposed chloride-related mechanism, chloride ions interact with oxygen vacancies. This promotes processes that increase cation-vacancy transport toward the metal-film interface. If vacancies accumulate faster than they are removed, the barrier layer may rupture once a critical condition is reached.

Repeated polarization tests produced breakdown potentials within a relatively narrow range, and the measured distribution was consistent with a normal distribution. The model also relates breakdown potential to chloride activity and scan rate. Its agreement with the observed behavior supports its use as a framework for interpreting passivation and depassivation, rather than as a substitute for testing under relevant conditions.

Practical implications for corrosion assessment

For engineers and asset decision-makers, the central lesson is to connect corrosion indicators with the environment in which they were measured. A threshold derived from one pore-solution chemistry may not transfer directly to another. pH, ionic composition and passive-film condition all matter, while OCP, LPR and Mott–Schottky analysis provide different kinds of evidence.

Simulated pore solutions enable controlled electrochemical testing, but they cannot fully reproduce the heterogeneity of concrete or mortar. Laboratory results are therefore most useful for comparing defined conditions and examining mechanisms. For practical assessments, test conditions and interpretation should be matched to the material and exposure being evaluated.

Overall, the study shows that pH has a substantial relationship with passive-film quality and the measured chloride threshold for HPB335 carbon steel. Combining electrochemical measurements with the point defect model helps explain how chloride exposure can lead to depassivation, while also highlighting the limits of applying a single threshold across different environments.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author