Access Official Technical PDF

Share Summary:LinkedInEmail

The Desert Quartzite Solar Project illustrates how a large energy development can involve several connected approvals, land-use decisions, and environmental reviews. The project’s 2019 Final Plan Amendment/Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report (PA/EIS/EIR) evaluates a proposed solar facility on Bureau of Land Management (BLM)-administered land and adjacent private property in Riverside County, California. For infrastructure developers and project stakeholders, the document’s structure shows how agencies assess alternatives and resource impacts before deciding whether to authorize a project.

Project scope and approval framework

First Solar Development, LLC applied to the BLM for a right-of-way (ROW) grant, identified as CACA-049397. The application covered approximately 5,115 acres, providing room for agencies to consider different project layouts. The proposed development itself would occupy approximately 3,770 acres across federal and private land.

That proposed footprint included about 3,560 acres for the solar facility on BLM land, 54 acres for a proposed 230-kilovolt generation interconnection line on BLM land, and a small area for telecommunications and possible electrical service infrastructure. The proposal also included 154 acres for the solar facility on privately owned land. The applicant separately sought a Riverside County Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for private property adjacent to the BLM land.

The final proposed ROW, if granted, would cover 3,616 acres of BLM land. County authorization would address use of the 154-acre private-land portion. These distinct approvals reflect the project’s split land ownership: the BLM would decide whether to grant, deny, or modify the federal ROW, while Riverside County would decide whether to issue a CUP.

Why the California Desert Conservation Area Plan matters

The project review also considers amendments to the California Desert Conservation Area (CDCA) Plan. Under the existing plan, the proposed development would require changes to accommodate certain elements of the project. The document identifies three proposed plan decisions:

  • Development footprint: Amend the CDCA Plan to identify the area as suitable for the proposed type of solar energy use.
  • Transmission corridor: Authorize a portion of the generation interconnection corridor outside BLM Utility Corridor K and Section 368 Federal Energy Corridor 30-52.
  • Routes within the project area: Close 6.8 miles of existing routes within the project area.

These amendments would be adopted if the BLM granted a ROW for the proposed project or either of the two action alternatives. If the No Action Alternative were selected, the proposed amendments would not be made. In this way, the land-use plan decisions are linked to, but distinct from, the decision on the ROW application.

Alternatives support comparison, not just project approval

The PA/EIS/EIR evaluates four alternatives: the Proposed Action, a Resource Avoidance Alternative, a Reduced Project Alternative, and a No Action Alternative. Comparing alternatives enables the agencies to assess different development footprints and outcomes rather than review only one project configuration.

The larger application area—approximately 5,115 acres—gave the agencies space to examine alternative layouts, even though the proposed project footprint was smaller. The Resource Avoidance and Reduced Project alternatives are among the action alternatives that could also trigger the three identified CDCA Plan amendments if approved. The No Action Alternative provides a comparison in which the project would not proceed under the decisions being considered.

The final document is an analysis, not an approval. It is intended to inform the BLM’s ROW and land-use decisions and the County’s CUP decision. The BLM stated that it would issue a Record of Decision after resolution of any protests concerning land-use planning decisions. Implementation decisions are handled through a separate administrative review process.

Environmental review spans multiple resource areas

The review covers a broad range of potential effects on federal and private lands. Its analysis includes air quality, greenhouse gas emissions and climate change, vegetation and wildlife, cultural and paleontological resources, water, geology and soils, hazardous materials, noise, recreation, transportation, utilities, visual resources, and social and economic conditions.

It also considers cumulative impacts—the potential effects of the project alongside other known actions and activities included in the cumulative scenario. This matters for large infrastructure proposals because an agency’s review is not limited to the project’s physical footprint or to impacts considered in isolation.

Project features and management measures are part of the review as well. The document describes proposed facilities, construction, operations and maintenance, and decommissioning, together with plans or measures addressing topics such as hazardous materials, vegetation, fire prevention, wildlife, water conservation, stormwater, traffic, cultural resources, and public access. These are considered within the environmental analysis; their inclusion does not, by itself, establish that the project was approved or that all impacts were eliminated.

Public process and agency coordination

The BLM and Riverside County prepared the document under federal and California environmental review frameworks. The BLM’s review also considered its land-use planning responsibilities and the proposed amendment to the CDCA Plan. Other agencies have roles in related reviews or authorizations, including the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and California Department of Fish and Wildlife.

The Draft EIS/EIR was published in August 2018, followed by a 90-day public comment period and public meetings in Palm Desert and Blythe. The final document includes comments received and agency responses. Following publication of a Notice of Availability in the Federal Register, the proposed plan amendment was subject to a 30-day protest period under the BLM’s planning regulations.

Practical implications for infrastructure stakeholders

The Desert Quartzite Solar Project review shows why project planning must account for more than engineering design and construction boundaries. Land ownership, local permits, federal ROW authorization, land-use plan consistency, environmental resource assessments, alternatives, and public participation can all shape the approval pathway. For project teams, understanding which agency controls each decision—and how those decisions depend on one another—is essential to interpreting an environmental review.

Most importantly, a final EIS/EIR provides the analytical basis for agency decisions; it is not itself a permit or final authorization. The practical next step is to distinguish the document’s findings and proposed measures from the separate decisions that determine whether, and under what conditions, a project may proceed.

Access Official Technical PDF

About The Author